An electron moving through a uniform magnetic field

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves an electron moving through a uniform magnetic field represented by B = Bx i + (3.68 Bx) j. The electron's velocity is given as v = (1.88 i + 4.86 j) m/s, and the magnetic force acting on it is (2.43 × 10^-19) N. The objective is to find the value of Bx.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Conceptual clarification

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the cross product involved in the magnetic force equation and express confusion about isolating Bx. Some suggest considering the dimensions of Bx and question the interpretation of the force's direction. Others raise concerns about the assumptions regarding the uniformity of the magnetic field and the nature of the vectors involved.

Discussion Status

The discussion is ongoing, with participants providing clarifications about the nature of Bx and the magnetic force equation. There are multiple interpretations being explored, particularly regarding the direction of the force and the assumptions about the magnetic field.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the potential ambiguity in the problem statement regarding the direction of the force and the interpretation of Bx as a subscript rather than a variable. There is also mention of the charge of the electron being negative, which may affect the direction of the force.

Destroxia
Messages
204
Reaction score
7

Homework Statement



An electron moves through a uniform magnetic field given by B = Bx i + (3.68 Bx) j . At a particular instant, the electron has velocity v = (1.88 i +4.86 j) m/s and the magnetic force acting on it is (2.43 × 10-19) N. Find Bx.

Givens

B = [Bx i + (3.68 Bx)]

v = (1.88 + 4.86)

Fb = (2.43 × 10-19) N. Find Bx.

2. Homework Equations


Fb = q(B x V)

The Attempt at a Solution



(2.43 x 10^-19)k = (1.602 x 10^-19) [(Bx i + (3.68Bx) j) x (1.88 i + 4.86 j)

cross product resultant:

(2.43 x 10^-19)k = (1.602 x 10^-19) (-2.06*Bx)k

(2.43 x 10^-19)k = (-3.30 x 10^-19*Bx) k

I don't understand how to solve for the Bx, we haven't learned how to divide vectors, and I can't really pull the Bx out of the k vector as a scalar. How do I solve for the Bx?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
RyanTAsher said:

Homework Statement



An electron moves through a uniform magnetic field given by B = Bx i + (3.68 Bx) j . At a particular instant, the electron has velocity v = (1.88 i +4.86 j) m/s and the magnetic force acting on it is (2.43 × 10-19) N. Find Bx.

Givens

B = [Bx i + (3.68 Bx)]

v = (1.88 + 4.86)

Fb = (2.43 × 10-19) N. Find Bx.

2. Homework Equations


Fb = q(B x V)

The Attempt at a Solution



(2.43 x 10^-19)k = (1.602 x 10^-19) [(Bx i + (3.68Bx) j) x (1.88 i + 4.86 j)

cross product resultant:

(2.43 x 10^-19)k = (1.602 x 10^-19) (-2.06*Bx)k

(2.43 x 10^-19)k = (-3.30 x 10^-19*Bx) k

I don't understand how to solve for the Bx, we haven't learned how to divide vectors, and I can't really pull the Bx out of the k vector as a scalar. How do I solve for the Bx?
Since the two unit vectors are identical, you can cancel them. But if you want to do it by pure methods, there are two ways: consider magnitudes; take the dot product of each side with something convenient.
 
BX is not a vector, it is a number with a dimension. The vectors are ##\vec v## and ##\vec B = B_X \hat\imath + (3.68\;B_X) \hat\jmath\ ##.
So check the dimensions (they should be fine) and find the value as you intended to do: by dividing.
 
BvU said:
BX is not a vector, it is a number with a dimension. The vectors are ##\vec v## and ##\vec B = B_X \hat\imath + (3.68\;B_X) \hat\jmath\ ##.
So check the dimensions (they should be fine) and find the value as you intended to do: by dividing.
I believe Ryan is referring to the two k vectors.
 
Hello RyanTAsher,

Before I go through the math (privately on my own), could you help clear up a few ambiguities?

I'm assuming that the x in Bx is a subscript and not a variable. (In other words, I'm assuming that \vec B is uniform and not a function of x.) Is that correct?

Are you sure about \vec F = q \left( \vec B \times \vec v \right)? Is that correct or is something backwards?

(Also, don't forget that the charge of an electron is negative. i.e., q = -e)

In the initial problem statement, the force was given as (2.43 × 10-19) N with no direction specified. Later, you tacked on a \hat k. I'm just wondering if the original problem statement had the \hat k in it, or if the (2.43 × 10-19) N figure was meant to be magnitude only without specifying a direction. [Edit: Going through the math, I realize that the force must be along the z axis. But ultimately, one still needs to determine if the force is pointing in the positive or negative direction of the axis.]
 
Last edited:
@Haru: of course, naive of me to overlook that; thanks!
@CM: well pointed out. But now the wrong expression is appearing twice already in this thread (shudder) ...

@RTA: you're in good hands ! Bedtime for me. Good luck. And dividing out vectors is like dividing out Yuzzamatuzzes: if Zfluff Yuzzamatuzzes = 2.5 Yuzzamatuzzes, then you can be sure Zfluff = 2.5. It's a property of multiplication, not a property of Yuzzamatuzzes. There is only one snag to beware of: things go awry if Yuzzamatuzz = 0, because then you can't "divide them out" any more. (With thanks to dr. Seuss)
 
collinsmark said:
Hello RyanTAsher,

Before I go through the math (privately on my own), could you help clear up a few ambiguities?

I'm assuming that the x in Bx is a subscript and not a variable. (In other words, I'm assuming that \vec B is uniform and not a function of x.) Is that correct?

Are you sure about \vec F = q \left( \vec B \times \vec v \right)? Is that correct or is something backwards?
I'm just wondering if the original problem statement had the \hat k in it, or if the (2.43 × 10-19) N figure was meant to be magnitude only without specifying a direction.

Yes, the Bx is a B with subscript x, Bx, and the force value did have the \hat k with it. Sorry for the confusion. I am pretty positive about the \vec F = q \left( \vec B \times \vec v \right) as that is what it says in my textbook.
 
The Lorentz force is definitely $$
\vec F = q\, \left (\vec E + \vec v \times \vec B \right )
$$no matter what your textbook says.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 26 ·
Replies
26
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K