Asymmetry in Stokes' theorem & Gauss' theorem

[fresh_42]

Also, this is the third post on the subject. It was already answered in the threads mentioned in post #12 above. Here, for example, is a good answer to the question:

https://www.physicsforums.com/threa...d-by-the-same-curve-in-stokes-theorem.989709/

@feynman1 You apparently got your answer. If you still have problems, then we may have communication problems, which is not unlikely since we are restricted to verbal only communication.

My suggestion is: Quote the original theorem you have a question to. Famous theorems are sometimes differently phrased. It looks as if you have trouble to understand the conditions of Gauß law. So the more precise you ask, the better the answers will be.