- #1

- 14

- 0

And does the answer depend on gravity? In other words would it be the same angle on the moon?

- Thread starter Paul Dirac
- Start date

- #1

- 14

- 0

And does the answer depend on gravity? In other words would it be the same angle on the moon?

- #2

berkeman

Mentor

- 59,039

- 9,138

What answers do you get when you do the math?And does the answer depend on gravity? In other words would it be the same angle on the moon?

- #3

- 14

- 0

I got 0.5sin^{2}x-sin(2x)=0 but I don't know how to algebraically solve that equation

- #4

berkeman

Mentor

- 59,039

- 9,138

Can you show us the original kinematic equations that you started with and show each of your steps that got you to that equation?I got 0.5sin^{2}x-sin(2x)=0 but I don't know how to algebraically solve that equation

- #5

SteamKing

Staff Emeritus

Science Advisor

Homework Helper

- 12,796

- 1,668

This is not an algebraic equation, so it can't be solved in that manner.I got 0.5sin^{2}x-sin(2x)=0 but I don't know how to algebraically solve that equation

You can either plot it and find the solutions graphically or use a numerical technique, like iteration or Newton's method.

Since it is trigonometric, there are probably an infinite number of solutions, but you can restrict the range of angles which interest you.

- #6

- 14

- 0

I used these equations. How do I solve the one I posted?

- #7

- 14

- 0

O okay, so would Newton's method be the best numerical technique for this trigonometric equation that we can restrict the angles?This is not an algebraic equation, so it can't be solved in that manner.

You can either plot it and find the solutions graphically or use a numerical technique, like iteration or Newton's method.

Since it is trigonometric, there are probably an infinite number of solutions, but you can restrict the range of angles which interest you.

- #8

- 14

- 0

- #9

- 14

- 0

Why is the answer 75.96? How is that intuitive? Why is it the same on every planet?

- #10

nasu

Gold Member

- 3,772

- 429

One solution is of course Θ=0. Assuming Θ≠0 you can simplify sinΘ and reduce the equation to tanΘ=4.

Which is still a non algebraic equation but the solution can be found with a simple pocket calculator.

- #11

- 14

- 0

TY nasu. Why is the answer 75.96? Why is the answer not 45 degrees?

- #12

- 8

- 2

It's not 45 degrees for the same reason it's not 12, 38.987, or 756 degrees: it's not the right answer. Yes, there is some sort of similarity between the idea of equal height and distance, and the idea of an angle being equally far from vertical and horizontal, but you will find that picking answers to mathematical equations based on what seems sort of a right answer gives poor math grades and even more poorly designed bridges.TY nasu. Why is the answer 75.96? Why is the answer not 45 degrees?

- #13

nasu

Gold Member

- 3,772

- 429

Who said is "intuitive"?Why is the answer 75.96? How is that intuitive? Why is it the same on every planet?

There is nothing special about this value. It is the value that satisfies that condition. If you ask for what angle the range is double the maximum height you will get another value for the angle. And so on.

For 45 degree the range has a maximum value (for the given value of speed) but is not equal to the maximum height.

Be careful, here "maximum" has slightly different meaning for the two quantities.

"Maximum" range assumes that you change the angle until the range has the largest value. For each one of this angle, the projectile will reach a "maximum" height on his trajectory. So there is a "maximum" height for each angle but the range is "maximum" only for 45 degrees.

This may be the source of your confusion. Or maybe my attempt to explain will be an even worse source of confusion. :)

- #14

256bits

Gold Member

- 3,314

- 1,352

One solution is of course Θ=0. Assuming Θ≠0 you can simplify sinΘ and reduce the equation to tanΘ=4.

Which is still a non algebraic equation but the solution can be found with a simple pocket calculator.[/QUOTE]

I would not have even used the equations of motion given, but deduced the answer from falling objects.

The projectile has to be aimed at a location P such that if an object is dropped from P and the projectile is fired at the same instance, they will both will fall for the same amount of time and also reach the ground at the same later instance.

At maximum height, h, the projectile will have travelled half the range, or a horizontal distance r. Knowing h = 2r, then P is at a height 4r. Thus simply by trigonometry, from the triangle with sides r and 4r, we can solve for the angle theta, and simply obtain, as you did, tanΘ=4r/r, or tanΘ=4.

Perhaps that is the "intuitive" answer being asked.

Similar to "where do you aim if one wants to hit a target, if the shot is fired at the same time the target is dropped", which is a usual textbook exercise problem.

- #15

- 311

- 23

its 75.96375.

- #16

A.T.

Science Advisor

- 11,024

- 2,491

One intuitive solution is to consider that the trajectory is a inverted parabola like the green one below:How is that intuitive?

http://hotmath.com/images/gt/lessons/genericalg1/parabola_width.gif

To fit it into a square (height = distance), you have to restrict it to the interval to [-2, 2]. The derivative at -2 is 4, so the angle is atan(4).

Last edited:

- Replies
- 1

- Views
- 3K

- Replies
- 3

- Views
- 28K

- Replies
- 7

- Views
- 3K

- Replies
- 9

- Views
- 2K

- Replies
- 4

- Views
- 3K

- Last Post

- Replies
- 2

- Views
- 2K

- Replies
- 2

- Views
- 4K

- Last Post

- Replies
- 4

- Views
- 1K

- Last Post

- Replies
- 2

- Views
- 3K

- Replies
- 1

- Views
- 688