Atomic/Physic description of life, growth and evolution

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion explores the relationship between physics and biology, specifically focusing on whether concepts of life, growth, and evolution can be described in terms of atomic and physical principles. Participants examine the replication of cells and the underlying mechanisms from a physics perspective.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants propose that the laws of physics govern all biological processes, suggesting that biology is an emergent property of physical laws.
  • Others argue that while organisms are fundamentally products of biochemistry, the chemical reactions involved in processes like cellular replication are rooted in physics.
  • A participant seeks clarification on how cells replicate themselves from a physics standpoint, emphasizing the role of molecular interactions and the complexity of these processes.
  • Concerns are raised about the use of terms like "molecular machines" and "proteins," which some participants feel obscure the underlying mechanisms of cellular replication.
  • Links to external resources are provided to illustrate the atomic-level processes involved in DNA replication.
  • There is a suggestion that the question posed may be overly vague or framed as a false dichotomy between biology and physics.
  • Some participants express interest in the philosophical implications of the relationship between biology and physics, referencing notable thinkers in the field.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on whether life, growth, and evolution can be fully explained through physics. Multiple competing views remain regarding the relationship between biological processes and physical laws.

Contextual Notes

The discussion highlights limitations in understanding the detailed mechanisms of molecular machines and cellular processes, with some participants expressing a desire for more specific explanations beyond general terms.

eextreme
Messages
24
Reaction score
0
I have no idea where this topic belongs since it combines physics and biology.

Is there a way to describe life, growth, and evolution in terms of Atoms or Physics. Or are they two completely different things?
 
Biology news on Phys.org
The laws of physics govern everything; chemistry and by extension biology are emergent properties of those laws. You're question is quite vague, can you give examples of what you're trying to find out?
 
Actually, the main thing that I m looking for is how (in an Physic's sense) do cells of living organism replicate themselves.
 
eextreme said:
Actually, the main thing that I m looking for is how (in an Physic's sense) do cells of living organism replicate themselves.
I'm still not sure what you mean by "in a physics sense"? Fundamentally organisms are the product of biochemistry, these chemical reactions occur due to the laws of physics. Cells of eukaryotic organisms replicate via mitosis and cytokinesis, prokaryotes replicate via binary fission.
 
eextreme said:
Actually, the main thing that I m looking for is how (in an Physic's sense) do cells of living organism replicate themselves.

Well, first, organisms replicate their "code" or DNA; they don't do it perfectly, of course, but neither does a production plant perfectly produce the same design). However, in both cases, the result is generally functionally equivalent. When these copy errors are not functionally equivalent, we call it a mutation or evolution.

Go here, under DNA, click Replication. It will show you what the molecules are doing during replication. All the constituents are available, floating around in the region of the cell; the information about the form and structure is what transfers from a structured set of molecules to a bunch of free-floating molecules through electrodynamic interactions (reactions, attraction, repulsion) and concentration gradients. Some molecules can come together and form a little machine that handles specially designed reactions that help the process of replication, but they still operate on these principles.

At the physics level, you could see this as a bunch of electrodynamic interactions, but the reactions would require some quantum physics to understand. Chemists generally learn this as "physical chemistry".

Cellular replication requires the previously mentioned molecular machines. Now that there's a new copy of the code, a new cell can be made, using that copy. You can look at mitosis or meiosis in that website to see what's going on with the actual molecules. Basically, another nucleus is built inside the membrane and the membrane seals and separates into two membranes, each with their own nucleus (which each has their own copy of the code).

From there, the new replicated code is "interpreted" by molecular machines and cells turn into specific kinds of cells and form bonds with their neighboring cells, and keep making new cells. In development of new offspring, this is called morphogenesis and really comes back to molecular machines (and structures) following "directions" from the code. They are really always just following the laws of classical and quantum electrodynamics and diffusion and gravity, but...

It is a very complex arrangement of events that can happen following these simple rules (because of the complicated geometry of all the different particles.. especially carbon). So we call different events that we see a lot by a specific names like DNA, cell, proteins (which can be both "molecular machines" and "signals"; terms we associate with our ever day life, but aren't quite the same. It's just a way to try and archive all the complicated interactions underlying life so that we can make sense of them).
 
Last edited:
From your descriptions the word, 'molecular machine', 'protein' sound like a black boxes where we have no idea what is happening inside but we know that they do something to make cellular replication possible.

I would like to know what that 'complex arrangement of events' are and how they are achieved.

I'm grateful that they are archived under comprehensible terms. But they do (in my opinion) hide or cover up how exactly they work.
 
Is this http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNA_polymerase an example of a black box?

You seem to be asking 'explain to me basic molecular and cellular biology' .

We are running a satire on this sort of question on another thread. :-p
 
eextreme said:
From your descriptions the word, 'molecular machine', 'protein' sound like a black boxes where we have no idea what is happening inside but we know that they do something to make cellular replication possible.

I would like to know what that 'complex arrangement of events' are and how they are achieved.

I'm grateful that they are archived under comprehensible terms. But they do (in my opinion) hide or cover up how exactly they work.

They are generalist terms, so they are not specific. The particular proteins are vast and diverse.
 
  • #10
eextreme said:
From your descriptions the word, 'molecular machine', 'protein' sound like a black boxes where we have no idea what is happening inside but we know that they do something to make cellular replication possible.

I would like to know what that 'complex arrangement of events' are and how they are achieved.

I'm grateful that they are archived under comprehensible terms. But they do (in my opinion) hide or cover up how exactly they work.
No we have a pretty good idea what's happening. When we use the term "molecular machine" we are trying to describe the ensemble of molecules that work together to perform a function. A protein is a polymeric molecule made from amino acids. Did you look at the link Pythagorean provided above? It was very good as was his explanation.

Here are a few videos on DNA replication you might like to watch

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gL3aigv7w4A
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-mtLXpgjHL0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qn-JW-M89fo&

What you are seeing are computer visualisations of a DNA replication fork. Each individual molecule is acting simply due to their, and their environment's, chemical properties. DNA is made out of two chains of nucleotides, there are four types; A, C, G, T. The two chains of DNA bind together in a helix, this binding occurs because T binds to A and C binds to G. When new DNA is being synthesised new nucleotides are added by DNA polymerase. These nucleotides are found floating around (though in their free form they have pyrophosphate bound) and when they come in contact with DNA polymerase a energetically favourable chemical reaction occurs leading to the removal of the pyrophosphate and binds the nucleotide to the growing chain.
 
  • #11
eextreme said:
Is there a way to describe life, growth, and evolution in terms of Atoms or Physics. Or are they two completely different things?

Your question is vague, as already stated. Moreover, you are posing a false dichotomy. The question to ask is, Can everything in biology be explained in terms of physical laws and entities, e.g. atoms?

Answer: read Ernst Mayr, the best writer and thinker in the field.
 
  • #12
Mooky said:
Answer: read Ernst Mayr, the best writer and thinker in the field.

Thanks so much for that link. I'd never heard of Mayr before. As somebody who has moved back and forth between philosophy and the sciences, I often crave this sort of thing.
 
  • #13
ander said:
Thanks so much for that link. I'd never heard of Mayr before. As somebody who has moved back and forth between philosophy and the sciences, I often crave this sort of thing.

You're welcome. Mayr is one those guys of whom one says, If Mayr wrote it, it's worth reading it. Whether or not you agree with him, he was such an awesome writer and such a great biologist. The man worked at Harvard until his death - at 100 years of age!
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
4K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 63 ·
3
Replies
63
Views
12K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
4K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
5K