Succinct Definition of Biological Evolution

In summary: DNA replication. This can happen either by chance (random mutation) or as a result of the actions of a particular organism or agent.An allele is any genetic variant (i.e. change in a DNA sequence). These changes...occur because of errors during the process of DNA replication.
  • #1
Murdstone
49
2
Anyone exposed to academic rigor would find the use of the term "biological evolution" to be rather vague.

There is something about Darwin and common descent and then it starts to get somewhat vague.

Is there a definitive definition of "biological evolution"?

I offer this in the spirit of Niels Bohr - "Atomic Physics and Human Knowledge".
 
Biology news on Phys.org
  • #2
Evolution is the change in allele frequencies (or you could just say change in general, because epigeneticss is also a part) in a population over time. There's no need to be any more specific for the same reason dictionary writers don't feel the need to define words within a word's definition. If you need more clarification, you can look deeper into it elsewhere.
 
  • #3
Moreover, the term biological evolution is typically used to distinguish it from the evolution of stars, or planetary systems, or the universe itself. In those contexts evolution means the changes that occur over time to the respective systems.

I sense that the need for the phrase biological evolution has arisen, in part, to counter creationists who conflate these terms and use faulty logic based on that conflation in an attempt to discredit biological evolution. Adding the adjective helps to, rightly, separate them.

aroc91 has given the current, generally accepted definition. Palaeontologists would tend to use a somewhat different one, since they can view only phenotypes, not genotypes.

However, I would suggest that a precise definition is unnecessary. We do not have a precise definition of life, yet we are able to recognise it in many forms and study it in immense detail. So to with evolution.
 
  • #4
Succinct Definition of Biological Evolution

"Descent with modification." How's that for succinct?:cool:
 
  • #5
Very good. It incorporates the concept of allele frequency and phenotype changes, thus satisfying biologists and palaeontologists respectively, while demonstrating that old Charlie had a knack for a nice phrase.
 
  • #6
Ophiolite said:
Very good. It incorporates the concept of allele frequency and phenotype changes, thus satisfying biologists and palaeontologists respectively, while demonstrating that old Charlie had a knack for a nice phrase.

Gotta love good ole' Charlie.
 
  • #7
DiracPool said:
"Descent with modification." How's that for succinct?:cool:

Descent with modification under environmental attrition is one I've heard several times before. It's a good, brief and encompassing definition. Offspring are slightly different to parents, the environment means that some of them get to reproduce more. That's the fundamental of it.
 
  • #8
Ryan_m_b said:
Descent with modification under environmental attrition is one I've heard several times before. It's a good, brief and encompassing definition. Offspring are slightly different to parents, the environment means that some of them get to reproduce more. That's the fundamental of it.

This is a good definition for natural selection, but natural selection is just one mechanism by which evolution can occur. Genetic drift, founder effects, and bottlenecks can all cause evolution but are not driven by environmental attrition. Personally, I would favor the definition as changes in allele frequencies over time. It gives no information about how or why evolution occurs, but it is a perfectly fine description of what occurs in evolution (though one could argue that it captures mostly microevolution and not macroevolution).
 
  • #9
Ygggdrasil said:
Genetic drift, founder effects, and bottlenecks.

I like that one too, got a nice ring to it, succinct, pithy, and concise..And it even rhymes!:thumbs:
 
  • #10
Ygggdrasil said:
This is a good definition for natural selection, but natural selection is just one mechanism by which evolution can occur. Genetic drift, founder effects, and bottlenecks can all cause evolution but are not driven by environmental attrition. Personally, I would favor the definition as changes in allele frequencies over time. It gives no information about how or why evolution occurs, but it is a perfectly fine description of what occurs in evolution (though one could argue that it captures mostly microevolution and not macroevolution).

Of course, but if we're being succinct then we're not going to cover everything. A succinct definition is only really going to be needed with people unfamiliar with the subject matter, in which case natural selection is the best place to start and build upon that.
 
  • #11
The phrase "allele frequencies" is often repeated in the above. What is an "allele"? To me it is a difference in the sequence of amino acids that code for a protein. However, the sensitivity of the amino acid chain if vague. How many errors are required for an "allele".
 
  • #12
However, the sensitivity of the amino acid chain if vague.

How so? Any sequence change creates a new allele. All it takes is one.
 
  • #13
Murdstone said:
The phrase "allele frequencies" is often repeated in the above. What is an "allele"? To me it is a difference in the sequence of amino acids that code for a protein. However, the sensitivity of the amino acid chain if vague. How many errors are required for an "allele".

An allele is any genetic variant (i.e. change in a DNA sequence). These changes do not have to be in coding regions. For example, the allele for lactase persistence (not having lacose intolerance) is a mutation in the non-coding sequence upstream of the coding sequence for the lactase enzyme. These changes in the promoter region of the lactase gene prevent it from being turned off in adulthood, allowing individuals with this allele to be able to digest dairy products as adults.

It is often difficult to predict whether certain changes in the amino acid sequence of a protein will have an effect. Sometimes a single amino acid change will cause a drastic change in the function of the protein (e.g. in many genetic disorders such as hemophilia), but often, many amino acids in a protein can be mutated without much effect. While scientists can often make decent guesses as to whether a mutation to a coding sequence will likely alter the function of the encoded protein (for example, by looking to see how often that particular amino acid in the protein has been mutated throughout evolution), we still have problems predicting the effects of mutations, especially in non-coding DNA sequences.
 
  • #14
Biological evolution is many things.

It is a science, it is a process, it is a fact of its observation, it is a theory predicting the process details and, more than in many sciences, it is a history (set of pathways) actually taken, it is the constraint that we look at organisms*.

Here I would go with a process definition.

A succinct process definition I have seen is "differential reproduction", which encapsulates "descent with modification" with all its mechanisms and frames the population genetic definition.

If the question is to make the correspondence to other processes clearer I would perhaps say "evolution is the process that changes the genome of a population [over generations]". Compare with "gravitation is the process that changes the acceleration of a test mass".

The question is what the definition is to be used for? Definitions are often more or less superfluous outside of mathematics and dictionary usage. Say, "academic rigor" := science rigor mortis. :)

*Which is yet another definitional question. Turtles upon turtles, and all that.
 
Last edited:
  • #15
In the spirit of the anthropic principle, "I'm still here - sequence me"
 

1. What is the definition of biological evolution?

Biological evolution is the process by which organisms change and diversify over time through a combination of genetic variation, natural selection, and other mechanisms. It is the fundamental concept that explains the diversity of life on Earth.

2. How does biological evolution occur?

Biological evolution occurs through the accumulation of genetic changes in a population over many generations. These changes can be caused by random mutations, genetic drift, or natural selection, which favors certain traits that are advantageous for survival and reproduction.

3. What evidence supports the theory of biological evolution?

There is a wealth of evidence from various fields of science that supports the theory of biological evolution, including the fossil record, comparative anatomy, developmental biology, molecular genetics, and biogeography. These different lines of evidence all point to a common origin and gradual changes in species over time.

4. Is biological evolution a random process?

While genetic mutations may occur randomly, the process of natural selection is not random. It operates on the principle that individuals with traits that are better adapted to their environment are more likely to survive and reproduce, passing on their advantageous traits to future generations.

5. Can biological evolution be observed in real time?

Yes, biological evolution can be observed in real time through studies on bacteria, viruses, and other organisms with short lifespans. These organisms can undergo genetic changes and adaptations within a few generations, providing evidence for the process of evolution in action.

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
19
Views
5K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
33
Views
6K
Replies
32
Views
9K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • Art, Music, History, and Linguistics
Replies
2
Views
914
  • Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
15
Views
3K
Back
Top