- 3,306
- 2,529
One should always specify the function that one is optimizing - in dish washing it is usually minimizing stuff other than the dishes left on them (residues and contaminants) while also minimizing human effort and time. By comparison, costs of hot water and other consumables are not a big deal.
Before I was a scholar, I was a dishwasher - I estimate I washed about a million dishes in a variety of commercial and residential systems. How water trumps cold - other factors being equal (but they seldom are). For hand washing, good water pressure and an industrial and convenient sprayer (hanging from well above the sink) are more important than the temperature of the water. Other system elements to minimize handling after dishes are rinsed are also important, as every handling step potentially introduces contaminants.
But neglecting the importance of water temperature assumes that each and every dish has been perfectly washed and only needs to have the soap removed. It ain't so. Depending on the system, between 1 and 10% of dishes come out still dirty. High pressure hot water in a proper sprayer solves that quickly better than cold water in the same system so that fewer dishes have to go back to the start of the dish cleaning process.
But I got to admit, maybe the hard water in New Orleans gives me a different answer than the soft water in Baton Rouge. Maybe Louisiana cuisine (tends to be fatty) has a different answer than other places. The answer with good industrial sinks and sprayers may be different from slow running tap water at home.
Before I was a scholar, I was a dishwasher - I estimate I washed about a million dishes in a variety of commercial and residential systems. How water trumps cold - other factors being equal (but they seldom are). For hand washing, good water pressure and an industrial and convenient sprayer (hanging from well above the sink) are more important than the temperature of the water. Other system elements to minimize handling after dishes are rinsed are also important, as every handling step potentially introduces contaminants.
But neglecting the importance of water temperature assumes that each and every dish has been perfectly washed and only needs to have the soap removed. It ain't so. Depending on the system, between 1 and 10% of dishes come out still dirty. High pressure hot water in a proper sprayer solves that quickly better than cold water in the same system so that fewer dishes have to go back to the start of the dish cleaning process.
But I got to admit, maybe the hard water in New Orleans gives me a different answer than the soft water in Baton Rouge. Maybe Louisiana cuisine (tends to be fatty) has a different answer than other places. The answer with good industrial sinks and sprayers may be different from slow running tap water at home.