Bogged down on Norton equivalent problem

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
MotoPayton
Messages
96
Reaction score
0
Picture an 8ma ideal current source pointing downward in parallel to a 20kohm resistor on the left of this picture. Wouldn't these elements contribute to the voltage drop across A and B.

Rth makes sense because the ideal voltage source will be shorted eliminating the last resistor but the voltage is confusing me.

Thanks for the help

Simplified circuit diagram: a 30 V ideal voltage source on the left in parallel with a 15 kΩ resistor, a 10 mA current source, and a 30 kΩ resistor, with terminals a and b at the right.
 
MotoPayton said:
Picture an 8ma ideal current source pointing downward in parallel to a 20kohm resistor on the left of this picture. Wouldn't these elements contribute to the voltage drop across A and B.

Rth makes sense because the ideal voltage source will be shorted eliminating the last resistor but the voltage is confusing me.

Thanks for the help

Circuit schematic with a 30V voltage source in series with a 15 kΩ resistor, a 10 mA current source and a 30 kΩ resistor in parallel, terminals a and b at the right, with the caption P 4.66 above.

You mean like this:

Circuit schematic with terminals a and b: an 8mA current source in parallel with a 20kΩ resistor, then a 30V voltage source, a 15kΩ resistor, a 10mA current source and a 30kΩ resistor in series toward the output.


The 30V voltage source is not going to change its voltage no matter what. So any KVL equations you care to write concerning what's to the right of that source are going to have 30V there. Nothing (physically realizable) that happens to the left of the voltage source can affect that.

So the voltage source acts as an effective "barrier" to what goes on to the left hand and right hand sides of it.
 
Attachments
  • Circuit schematic with terminals a and b: an 8mA current source in parallel with a 20kΩ resistor, then a 30V voltage source, then a 15kΩ resistor in series, with a 10mA current source and a 30kΩ resistor in parallel across terminals a and b.
    Fig1.gif
    4.2 KB · Views: 557
Ya same picture except the 8mA is pointing downward..

Allright you so since it has to be 30V on the upper and lower nodes nothing can change that. And you can find the current though the 20kohm resistor to be 1.5mA.

Doing KCL on the lower node 6.5mA is moving to the right in the lower node. That 6.5 A will move through the voltage source since they are modeled as having 0 Resistance.

So all the current will stay on the left to satisfy KCL and there is no way 30V is going to change therefore you can throw the stuff on the left out.