Suggestion Break Quote Button: A Handy Feature

[Ibix]

Something I want to do quite often is quote a post in chunks with my own comments interspersed. A button in the editor that inserts a close quote tag followed by an open quote tag (possibly with the user/post metadata) would be a helpful feature for this.

 

[Bystander]

Hear, hear.

 

[Greg Bernhardt]

Hmmm not sure I understand. How does multi quote or highlight quote not work for this?

 

[DrClaude]

Hmmm not sure I understand.

Let me see if I can explain.

How does multi quote or highlight quote not work for this?

It does, but it's not the same!

To do the above, I simply clicked on Reply, then had to insert manually a [/QUOTE] at the end of your first sentence, then copy-paste

to get the second quote.

The same result is achieved by highlighting, but one has to select the original post one part at a time. I guess @Ibix and @Bystander where either not aware of that or think it is too much work

 

[Ibix]

I was aware of the techniques Dr Claude describes, and use them on my laptop. But highlighting is an extreme pain to get right on my phone (possibly I'm just clumsy). It is a lot easier to quote an entire post and delete the parts I don't want. But if I want to break a quote I either have to cut and paste (again with the highlighting), manually add the quote tags (square brackets and slashes are annoyingly difficult on my phone keyboard), or quote-and-delete repeatedly.

I understand if it's not something you want to do. I'd find it a useful feature, however.

 

[Nugatory]

The closest we have today is the multiquote feature: Select a portion of the post you're replying to, add it to multiquote, select the next portion, repeat as necessary, then click the "Insert Quotes" button to drop each portion into the reply with the appropriate opening and closing quote tags.

I don't find this technique very satisfying, as it requires me to decide exactly how I'm going to cut up the original post before I start composing any of my own text, and that's just not how I work. We used to have a button that would a piece of selected text in quote tags, and that came pretty close and I used it a fair amount.

 

[dlgoff]

I don't find this technique very satisfying, as it requires me to decide exactly how I'm going to cut up the original post before I start composing any of my own text, and that's just not how I work.

I hear you. Thank goodness for multiple browser tabs.

 

[A. Neumaier]

We used to have a button that would a piece of selected text in quote tags, and that came pretty close and I used it a fair amount.

You can mark a piece of text and select reply; then it starts a reply with the quoted text or adds the text with the quote at the position of the cursor in the current partially composed reply. Unfortunately it works only when the text is on the same page as the partial reply.