MHB Calculating Element Count in Disjoint Volumes Using Venn Diagram

Petrus
Messages
702
Reaction score
0
Calculate the number of elements in A1 U A2 U A3 if there are 97 elements in A1, 997 elements in A2 and 10098 elements in A3 in each of the following situations:
(a) The amounts are pairwise disjoint, i.e.
c3939de84ef91f8e6d3d9088938ee01.png
, too
ea477786ed42b36a173e5f8918b58a1.png
.

(b)
0a0762b1e265e781e6409e400e5f951.png
.

(c) there are 10 elements in common for each pair of volumes and 4 elements common to all three sets.

(a)I get answer 997+97+10098
(b)10098
(c) is the part I think I do wrong, will attach a picture of my venn diagram.
for some reason I get problem to attaché the picture but i get a1= 73, a2= 973, A3=10074 so the answer is (that is wrong I think) 73+10+10+10+4+10074+973
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Petrus said:
Calculate the number of elements in A1 U A2 U A3 if there are 97 elements in A1, 997 elements in A2 and 10098 elements in A3 in each of the following situations:
(a) The amounts are pairwise disjoint, i.e.
c3939de84ef91f8e6d3d9088938ee01.png
, too
ea477786ed42b36a173e5f8918b58a1.png
.

(b)
0a0762b1e265e781e6409e400e5f951.png
.

(c) there are 10 elements in common for each pair of volumes and 4 elements common to all three sets.

(a)I get answer 997+97+10098
(b)10098
(c) is the part I think I do wrong, will attach a picture of my venn diagram.
for some reason I get problem to attaché the picture but i get a1= 73, a2= 973, A3=10074 so the answer is (that is wrong I think) 73+10+10+10+4+10074+973

Hi Petrus!

Well, your (a) and (b) are right.
... so I guess we'll be waiting for your venn diagram...
 
I like Serena said:
Hi Petrus!

Well, your (a) and (b) are right.
... so I guess we'll be waiting for your venn diagram...
Hello Serena,
I can't uppload my picture but I explained how it looks like
 
Petrus said:
Hello Serena,
I can't uppload my picture but I explained how it looks like

Okay. Let me upload then.
A and B overlap with 10 elements in common.
The 3 sets together have 4 elements in common.

View attachment 706

This doesn't quite seem to match what you have...
 

Attachments

  • venn.png
    venn.png
    2.6 KB · Views: 90
I like Serena said:
Okay. Let me upload then.
A and B overlap with 10 elements in common.
The 3 sets together have 4 elements in common.

View attachment 706

This doesn't quite seem to match what you have...
Will it also be 6 on that A and C that you have not painted?
 
Petrus said:
Will it also be 6 on that A and C that you have not painted?

Well, A and C would overlap in 10 elements and 4 of those elements are shared by all three.
So yes, it will also be 6 in the remaining overlap of A and C.
 
I like Serena said:
Well, A and C would overlap in 10 elements and 4 of those elements are shared by all three.
So yes, it will also be 6 in the remaining overlap of A and C.
Basicly I have missunderstand the problem:( I thought it was 4 on a and b and c(that is correct) BUT its 10 on a and b... Thanks Sirena for help!:) I get the answer that is 11172

edit: after reading this again I notice how bad I explained. Basicly it was suposted to be 4 on a and b, when I calculated i calculated with 10 :P Unfortently I am not a verry good explainer soo I hope this explain ok:)
 
Last edited:
Petrus said:
Basicly I have missunderstand the problem:( I thought it was 4 on a and b and c(that is correct) BUT its 10 on a and b... Thanks Sirena for help!:) I get the answer that is 11172

Hmm, I get a different answer.
How did you find yours?
 
I like Serena said:
Hmm, I get a different answer.
How did you find yours?
I get the rest 6 I can't uppload picture so I will just type what I get
10082+987+81+6+6+6+4=11172

97-6-4-6=81
997-6-4-4=987
10098-6-4-4=10082

Hope this give you a clue :P Thanks for the help as well Serena!:)
 
  • #10
Petrus said:
997-6-4-4=987

This one doesn't seem quite right.

- - - Updated - - -

Petrus said:
10098-6-4-4=10082

And this one has the right result, but a wrong number on the left hand side.
 
  • #11
I like Serena said:
This one doesn't seem quite right.

- - - Updated - - -
And this one has the right result, but a wrong number on the left hand side.

hmm? How can I get correct?:S (its a problem that you answer through internet and if you answer correct it says 'correct' and I got correct:S?)
 
  • #12
Petrus said:
I get the rest 6 I can't uppload picture so I will just type what I get
10082+987+81+6+6+6+4=11172

97-6-4-6=81
997-6-4-4=987
10098-6-4-4=10082

Hope this give you a clue :P Thanks for the help as well Serena!:)

Petrus said:
hmm? How can I get correct?:S (its a problem that you answer through internet and if you answer correct it says 'correct' and I got correct:S?)

They should be like this:
97-6-4-6=81
997-6-4-6=981
10098-6-4-6=10082
 
  • #13
I like Serena said:
They should be like this:
97-6-4-6=81
997-6-4-6=981
10098-6-4-6=10082
That give me also correct?! Are you serious? This is bad that I can get correct from both...? I will talk to my teacher about this because its not good if I get correct from miss calculated + doing a wrong step
 
  • #14
Petrus said:
I get the rest 6 I can't uppload picture so I will just type what I get
10082+987+81+6+6+6+4=11172

97-6-4-6=81
997-6-4-4=987
10098-6-4-4=10082

Hope this give you a clue :P Thanks for the help as well Serena!:)

Petrus said:
That give me also correct?! Are you serious? This is bad that I can get correct from both...? I will talk to my teacher about this because its not good if I get correct from miss calculated + doing a wrong step

I don't understand what you mean, but your end result should be:
10082+981+81+6+6+6+4=11166
 
  • #15
I like Serena said:
I don't understand what you mean, but your end result should be:
10082+981+81+6+6+6+4=11166
What I mean is that this is a problem I get from a program. We are supposed to write the answer and it says if its correct or wrong, I get correct from my 'wrong answer' and the correct answer. Thanks to you I know what I did wrong and the correct answer...
 
Back
Top