Discussion Overview
The discussion focuses on calculating the phonon self energy for electron-phonon interactions in graphene, specifically referencing a paper by T. Ando. Participants seek detailed calculations and methods, including the use of perturbation theory and Matsubara Green's functions.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation
- Mathematical reasoning
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant requests access to a specific journal article to find a detailed calculation of phonon self energy.
- Another participant provides a general expression for self energy in the lowest order of the coupling constant, involving the annihilation of a phonon and excitation of an electron.
- A participant shares a specific formula for self energy in graphene, including Fermi-Dirac statistics and constants, but expresses difficulty in obtaining the correct Green's functions.
- One participant suggests that the electronic Green's functions should be of a certain form and discusses the need for partial fraction decomposition in calculations.
- Another participant reports progress in obtaining Green's functions and drawing Feynman diagrams, but struggles with the Fourier transform to Matsubara frequency.
- A suggestion is made to work directly with Green's functions in frequency space, emphasizing the time dependence of the phonon interaction.
- One participant references a textbook for guidance on calculating self energy using Matsubara Green's functions and discusses the need for convergence factors in sums over frequencies.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express various approaches and methods to calculate phonon self energy, but there is no consensus on the best method or resolution of the challenges faced, indicating multiple competing views and unresolved issues.
Contextual Notes
Participants mention specific mathematical techniques and expressions, but there are unresolved steps in the calculations and dependencies on definitions of Green's functions and frequency transformations.