Calculating tensions and acceleration

10 replies · 3K views · last reply
shepherd882
Messages
12
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


A mass M1 is sliding across a table with coefficient of kinetic friction μk. A string is tied to this mass and runs over a pulley, drops vertically and is tied to another mass M2 which is falling. The pulley is connected to the table by a support. The pulley is a solid cylinder of mass M3, radius R. See figure. As the figure indicates, you may assume that the string is tied to the midpoint of both masses, that it runs horizontally from M1 to the pulley and vertically from the pulley to M2. You may also assume that the mass M1 is not tipping over as it slides.
Diagram of two masses connected by a string over a pulley: M1 on a horizontal table, string running horizontally to a circular pulley M3 labelled 2R, then vertically down to hanging mass M2.

a) Assume the string slips over the pulley with zero friction, and that the pulley is not rotating. Calculate the magnitude of the acceleration of M1 and M2. (This is the same for both masses.) Also find the tensions T1 in the string attached to M1 and T2 in the string attached to M2. Express your answers in terms of g and the various parameters given in the question.
b) Now assume that the string runs over the pulley without slipping, making the pulley rotate with increasing angular speed. Assume the pulley is attached to the table by a support which allows it to rotate on an axle with no friction between the pulley and axle. Calculate the magnitude of the acceleration of the masses M1 and M2 in this case. Also calculate the tensions T1 and T2 in this case.

Thanks for you help!

Homework Equations


Fnet = ma
Torque net = I*a
I = (MR^2)/2
Ff = uFn

The Attempt at a Solution


a) [/B]Fnet = ma
Fg2-T2+T1-Ff1 = (M1+M2)a
Fg2 - Ff1 = (M1+M2)a
M2g-uM1g = (M1+M2)a
(M2g-uM1g)/(M1+M2) = a

Fnet1 = T1-Ff1 = M1a
T1 = M1a + Ff1
T1 = M1a + uM1g
Fnet2 = Fg2 - T2 = M2a
T2 = Fg2 - M2a
T2 = M2g - M2a

b) Torque = I*a
T2R-T1R = Ia
a = [R^2/(M3R^2)]*(T2-T1)
a = (T2-T1)(2/M3)

T1 and T2 same as part a)?
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of two masses connected by a string over a pulley: M1 on a horizontal table, string running horizontally to a circular pulley M3 labelled 2R, then vertically down to hanging mass M2.
    pulley.jpg
    8.1 KB · Views: 925
T1 and T2 same as part a)?
Simple answer: no. Some difference is needed for ... (fill it in)

[edit] by the way, part a) isn't finished yet !
 
In the first part of your analysis for part (a), the tensions should not be included in the overall tangential force balance because they are internal to the system.
 
BvU said:
Simple answer: no. Some difference is needed for ... (fill it in)

[edit] by the way, part a) isn't finished yet !

for part a), would i just substitute acceleration into each of the tension equations then simplify?
also for part b), the difference would be that mass 3 has the normal force at an angle which would add to the fnetx component. am i on the right track?
 
shepherd882 said:
for part a), would i just substitute acceleration into each of the tension equations then simplify?
Yes. You should get the same answer for both tensions. Do you?
also for part b), the difference would be that mass 3 has the normal force at an angle which would add to the fnetx component. am i on the right track?
No. This is not the right approach. You should start by doing a moment balance on the pulley. In part (b), you should have 3 separate balance equations: one for each mass, and one for the pulley.
 
Chestermiller said:
Yes. You should get the same answer for both tensions. Do you?
No. This is not the right approach. You should start by doing a moment balance on the pulley. In part (b), you should have 3 separate balance equations: one for each mass, and one for the pulley.

Handwritten derivation on lined paper of tensions T1 and T2 for two masses M1 and M2 with kinetic friction, showing Newton's second law equations and the final expressions for each tension.

That's what I got for T1 and T2 for part a) ...
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten derivation on lined paper of tensions T1 and T2 for two masses M1 and M2 with kinetic friction, showing Newton's second law equations and the final expressions for each tension.
    46008188_1032680056921313_5955096860279439360_n.jpg?_nc_cat=109&_nc_ht=scontent.fyvr3-1.jpg
    12.4 KB · Views: 784
Chestermiller said:
Yes. You should get the same answer for both tensions. Do you?
No. This is not the right approach. You should start by doing a moment balance on the pulley. In part (b), you should have 3 separate balance equations: one for each mass, and one for the pulley.

Handwritten free-body diagrams for a pulley system with masses M1 and M2, followed by net force equations for the pulley, mass 1 and mass 2, such as Fnet x = FN3 x - T1 - ma.

Is this correct?
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten free-body diagrams for a pulley system with masses M1 and M2, followed by net force equations for the pulley, mass 1 and mass 2, such as Fnet x = FN3 x - T1 - ma.
    46043809_183818689223175_8685283553165967360_n.jpg?_nc_cat=108&_nc_ht=scontent.fyvr3-1.jpg
    11.3 KB · Views: 859
shepherd882 said:
View attachment 233904
That's what I got for T1 and T2 for part a) ...
That's not what I get. For part (a), I get ##T_1=T_2=T## with $$T=\frac{m_1m_2(1+\mu_k)}{(m_1+m_2)}g$$
This is equivalent to your result for ##T_2## but not for ##T_1##
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: shepherd882
shepherd882 said:
View attachment 233905
Is this correct?
I can't read your handwriting, but the equations should read:
$$T_1-m_1g\mu_k=m_1a$$
$$m_2g-T_2=m_2a$$and, for the moment balance on the pulley:
$$T_2R-T_1R=I\frac{a}{R}$$
This gives you 3 equations in the three unknowns ##T_1##, ##T_2##, and a
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: shepherd882 and Delta2
Chestermiller said:
I can't read your handwriting, but the equations should read:
$$T_1-m_1g\mu_k=m_1a$$
$$m_2g-T_2=m_2a$$and, for the moment balance on the pulley:
$$T_2R-T_1R=I\frac{a}{R}$$
This gives you 3 equations in the three unknowns ##T_1##, ##T_2##, and a
I got those equations
Handwritten derivation on lined paper: R(T2R - T1R)/I = a, then R^2(T2 - T1)/I = a, then R^2/I [(M2g - M2a) - (M1a + M1g mu_k)] = a, then R^2/I [M2g - M2a - M1a - M1g mu_k] = a with I = MR^2/2, and finally 2/M [M2g - M2a - M1a - M1g mu_k] = a.

How do you simplify this...?
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten derivation on lined paper: R(T2R - T1R)/I = a, then R^2(T2 - T1)/I = a, then R^2/I [(M2g - M2a) - (M1a + M1g mu_k)] = a, then R^2/I [M2g - M2a - M1a - M1g mu_k] = a with I = MR^2/2, and finally 2/M [M2g - M2a - M1a - M1g mu_k] = a.
    45885830_521481118367409_8579983341753729024_n.jpg?_nc_cat=108&_nc_ht=scontent.fyvr3-1.jpg
    12.8 KB · Views: 781
shepherd882 said:
I got those equations
View attachment 233909
How do you simplify this...?
You have one linear algebraic equation in one unknown ("a"); are you really saying that you don't know how to solve this equation for the unknown?