Calculating Voltage Source with R2 Voltage Known

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around calculating the voltage delivered by a voltage source in a circuit where the voltage across a resistor (R2) is known. Participants explore various methods, including Kirchhoff's laws, phasors, and mesh analysis, to derive the necessary equations and understand the relationships between circuit elements. The context includes theoretical and practical aspects of circuit analysis.

Discussion Character

  • Technical explanation
  • Mathematical reasoning
  • Debate/contested
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • One participant suggests using Kirchhoff's Voltage Law (KVL) to write equations for the circuit, questioning the reasonableness of their approach.
  • Another participant emphasizes the importance of not doing too much of the original poster's work, advocating for hints rather than full solutions.
  • There is a discussion about the use of phasors and complex impedance to simplify the analysis, with one participant noting the need for the angular frequency of the source.
  • Several participants propose equations for equivalent impedance and voltage division, with some expressing uncertainty about the correctness of their formulations.
  • One participant raises a question about calculating power delivered to a voltage source, leading to a discussion on energy absorbed or delivered by two-terminal components.
  • Another participant shares their calculations for complex power in the circuit, detailing the use of mesh analysis and providing specific results for currents and complex power.
  • There is a mention of the difference in currents when using sinusoidal versus cosinusoidal voltage sources, with a suggestion to multiply currents by "j" to align with cosine calculations.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express varying opinions on the methods to solve the circuit problem, with some advocating for KVL and others for mesh analysis. There is no clear consensus on the best approach, and multiple competing views remain throughout the discussion.

Contextual Notes

Some participants note the complexity of the algebra involved and the potential for errors in calculations, particularly regarding the application of formulas from textbooks. There are also mentions of missing assumptions and the need for clarity in notation.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for students and practitioners interested in circuit analysis, particularly those looking to understand different methods for calculating voltages and powers in electrical circuits.

James889
Messages
190
Reaction score
1
Hi,
I have the following circuit:
http://img35.imageshack.us/img35/6735/circuitac.png

My task is to calculate the voltage delivered by the voltage source Us
When the voltage over R2 is known, 8cos(100t + 45)

How would you do this?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
James889 said:
Hi,
I have the following circuit:
http://img35.imageshack.us/img35/6735/circuitac.png

My task is to calculate the voltage delivered by the voltage source Us
When the voltage over R2 is known, 8cos(100t + 45)

How would you do this?

You need to show us your attempts at solving this, before we can be of tutorial help. What have you tried? You can certainly use the KCL and differential equations to solve for that transfer function. Can you think of how to use Phasors to get the solution in an easier way?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hi,

Okay i'd try a writing KVL equation for the loop in terms of V.
[tex] Ri(t) + L(di/dt) -U_{s} = 0[/tex]
[tex]Ri(t) +(1/C)\int i(t)dt +8cos(100t + 45) -U_{s} = 0[/tex]


Does that look reasonable?
 
Last edited:
James889 said:
Hi,

Okay i'd try a writing KVL equation for the loop in terms of V.
[tex] Ri(t) + L(di/dt) -U_{s} = 0[/tex]

<< additional equation deleted by berkeman >>

Does it look reasonable?

Please don't do too much of the OP's work for them. It's fine to provide hints, but generally not good to post equations for the OP here in the Homework Help forums. Thanks.
 
berkeman said:
Please don't do too much of the OP's work for them. It's fine to provide hints, but generally not good to post equations for the OP here in the Homework Help forums. Thanks.

Hmm, why did you remove my second equation?
And why did i get a warning for a suggestion to my own problem?
 
James889 said:
Hmm, why did you remove my second equation?
And why did i get a warning for a suggestion to my own problem?

Because I'm an idiot. :redface: Sorry. Warning reversed.

Can you re-post your 2nd equation? I don't have a good copy of it in the queue. Thanks!
 
James889 said:
Hi,

Okay i'd try a writing KVL equation for the loop in terms of V.
[tex] Ri(t) + L(di/dt) -U_{s} = 0[/tex]
[tex]Ri(t) +(1/C)\int i(t)dt+8cos(100t + 45) -U_{s} = 0[/tex]


Does that look reasonable?

Oh hey, it's back after reversing the warning. Phew!

And yes, that's a good start.
 
So this is where things start to get tricky.
[tex]R(di(t)/dt) + L(di/dt) = 0[/tex]
[tex]R(di(t)/dt) + RC*(di/dt) + i(t) = 800sin(100t+45)[/tex]

Is that differentiation correct?
 
Can you show the intermediate steps instead of just the final result? It seems to me that there should be some second derivatives in there, but I don't see any; check your notation.

Solving simple networks like this with differential equations is really painful; haven't you studied phasors yet?
 
  • #10
The Electrician said:
Solving simple networks like this with differential equations is really painful; haven't you studied phasors yet?

we have.
So here's then another suggestion.
Replace the respective element in the circuit with its corresponding complex impedance.

The problem however seems to be that you need the angular frequency of the source(int the formula [tex]-j(1/\omega L)[/tex], which you don't have.
 
  • #11
The angular frequency of the source is the same as the frequency of the voltage across R2, because there aren't any non-linear circuit elements. Does that help you?
 
  • #12
Yes, thank you
 
  • #13
The equivalent impedance of the inductance, capacitance and the resistor R2 should be:
[tex]\frac{j\omega L (1/j\omega c + R_{2})}{j\omega L + (1/j \omega c + R_{2})} = 2+2j[/tex]

And now voltage division:
[tex]U_{L} = (2+2j)/(2+2j+R_{1}) * U_{s}[/tex]
[tex]U_{r} = (R_{2}/(R_{2} + (1/j\omgea L)) * U_{s}[/tex]

And we have a Catch 22...
 
  • #14
James889 said:
The equivalent impedance of the inductance, capacitance and the resistor R2 should be:
[tex]\frac{j\omega L (1/j\omega c + R_{2})}{j\omega L + (1/j \omega c + R_{2})} = 2+2j[/tex]

And now voltage division:
[tex]U_{L} = (2+2j)/(2+2j+R_{1}) * U_{s}[/tex]
[tex]U_{r} = (R_{2}/(R_{2} + (1/j\omgea L)) * U_{s}[/tex]

And we have a Catch 22...

This part looks right:
[tex]U_{L} = (2+2j)/(2+2j+R_{1}) * U_{s}[/tex]

But shouldn't the next part be:

[tex]U_{R} = (R_{2}/(R_{2} + 1/j\omega c) * U_{L}[/tex]

When you get done with all this algebra, you should have something of the form:


[tex]U_{R} = TFR * U_{s}[/tex]

where TFR is a transfer function, a complicated algebraic expression.

Then:

[tex]U_{s} = U_{R} / TFR[/tex]
 
  • #15
Okay, thanks!

One last question though.
Calculating the power delivered to a resistance is pretty simple.
But what is the formula for the power delivered to a current/voltage source?
 
  • #16
For any 2-terminal component, be it a resistor, inductor, capacitor, voltage source, current source, or whatever (or a combination of these between two terminals), the energy absorbed or delivered can be computed by:

[tex]\int e(t)i(t)dt[/tex]

where e(t) is the instantaneous voltage across the terminals, i(t) is the instantaneous current through the terminals, and the limits of the integration are the time period for which you want to know the energy absorbed or delivered. If you divide this energy by the time period involved, then you will get the average power for that time interval.

Typically, for steady state AC problems, the integration is over one cycle. Since for a steady state situation, the average power for anyone cycle is the same as for any other cycle, this will be the average power for many cycles, also; it's the steady state average power.
 
  • #17
The Electrician said:
For any 2-terminal component, be it a resistor, inductor, capacitor, voltage source, current source, or whatever (or a combination of these between two terminals), the energy absorbed or delivered can be computed by:

[tex]\int e(t)i(t)dt[/tex]

Hi again, about that.

I have the following forumula in my book:
[tex]P = \frac{V_{m} * I_{m}}{2} * \frac{R}{|Z|}[/tex]

I tried to calculate the complex powered delivered to the [tex]V_{1}[/tex] source, but it yield the wrong result.
|Z| = [tex]\sqrt{8^2 + 3.5^2} = 8.73[/tex]

[tex]I_{m} = \frac {V}{|Z|} = \frac{40}{8.73} = 4.58[/tex]
And i already have [tex]V_{m} = 40[/tex]

So consequently i have [tex]\frac{4.58 * 40}{2} * \frac{8}{3.5} = 209[/tex] Which is incorrect.
http://img34.imageshack.us/img34/859/accircuitpng.png
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #18
To be sure of getting the right answer, rather than using formulas from the book whose applicability is uncertain, I would solve the network. Using the mesh method establish two currents flowing clockwise; I1 in the left mesh and I2 in the right mesh. We then get two equations:

(8 - j*.5)*I1 + (j*.5)*I2 = 40

(j*.5)*I1 + (j*4-j*.5)*I2 = -j*20

Solving, I get:

I1 = 4.9492 + j*.71066 = 5 < 8.17 degrees

I2 = -6.4213 - j*.10152 = 6.422 < -179.09 degrees

So the complex power in V1 is V1 * conjugate(I1) = 197.97 - j*28.43

The complex power in V2 is V2 * conjugate(I2) = 2.0305 + j*128.43

If you add the complex power in V1 and V2 you get 200 + j*100

If you calculate the power dissipated in the 8 ohm resistor you get I12*8 = 200 watts, the same as the real part of the sum of the complex powers from V1 and V2.
 
  • #19
By the way, when I solved the network, I allowed the voltage sources to be sinusoids rather than co-sinusoids, knowing that it wouldn't affect the power calculations. The currents are different, however. To get the currents as you would obtain with cosines of voltage, just multiply the currents I got by "j".
 
  • #20
Nice, i didn't know you could use the mesh method for calculating power.
 

Similar threads

Replies
15
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
6K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K