The discussion revolves around a scenario involving a man inside a wheeled box and whether he can move the box while remaining inside it. The original poster challenges a teacher's assertion that this is impossible, expressing confidence in their position but seeking proof.
The conversation has evolved with some participants providing insights into the physics of motion, particularly regarding friction and the center of mass. There is recognition of differing perspectives on "real world" versus "ideal world" scenarios, indicating a productive exploration of the topic.
Participants note the importance of friction in the discussion, with some suggesting that the original poster's understanding may need to consider real-world conditions versus idealized physics.
Then how do you know you're right? Why do you think you're right?cagdassalur said:i know I am right but i can't prove. can you help me?
cagdassalur said:there is a box with wheels and man inside it.my teacher is said there is no way to man move the box while his inside. i said opposite. i know I am right but i can't prove. can you help me?
sry for bad eng.(not my natural lang.)
Right. Assuming no friction, there is no external force available to move the center of mass. (Note that you cannot ignore friction in your example of you and your chair.)cagdassalur said:there is no external force as far as i know.