Can a World with No Limits to Physics Exist?

  • Thread starter Thread starter flashprogram
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion explores the concept of a hypothetical world with no limits to physics, questioning whether parameters such as speed, time, and spatial divisions could be unlimited. It suggests that if an unlimited past is conceivable, other aspects like maximum speed and temporal divisions could also be unlimited, leading to a "root world" with infinite computational capacity. The idea of stable structures at infinitely small dimensions and the absence of a smallest interval is compared to the infinite nature of real numbers. However, challenges arise, such as the potential for infinite regress and the implications of altering fundamental constants on the nature of particles and spacetime. The conversation ultimately raises questions about the feasibility of such a world and the fundamental properties that govern all conceivable particles.
flashprogram
Messages
66
Reaction score
0
Right now when physicists talk of other alternate universes they mostly talk of varying the laws of physics, changing a few parameters, but I've not heard of the possible existence of an unlimited world.

When it comes to a beginning, a first moment, some models have suggested the possibility of an unlimited past, that is an eternal line of events preceding the present with no first moment. This is one aspect that's been considered as possibly unlimited.

But what about the other aspects? What about speed? time and spatial divisions, and rate of change in matter? Could there not be a world where the maximum speed is unlimited? That is there is no maximum speed. What about a world where there are stable structures of smaller and smaller dimensions and also no limit to the magnification that could be obtained?

Also a world were temporal divisions could be carried unlimited meaningfully , there being no smallest interval? It would be similar to the case with the real numbers were between any two numbers there are an infinity of numbers.

If such a world could exist, it could be considered a root world, in a sense. As it could possibly provide infinite computational capacity and storage to its inhabitants. The inhabitants of said world could simulate all the possible finite universes with limited variables and store them in their unlimited universe.

The only thing that might make such a world impossible is if there's some reason why making so many parameters unlimited is fundamentally impossible. But being as some have considered making the past unlimited in extent, without this being somehow indefensible, it seems safe to suggest that doing the same with the other parameters should not bring problems different from those already brought by making the past unlimited.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
flashprogram said:
Right now when physicists talk of other alternate universes they mostly talk of varying the laws of physics, changing a few parameters, but I've not heard of the possible existence of an unlimited world.

When it comes to a beginning, a first moment, some models have suggested the possibility of an unlimited past, that is an eternal line of events preceding the present with no first moment. This is one aspect that's been considered as possibly unlimited.

But what about the other aspects? What about speed? time and spatial divisions, and rate of change in matter? Could there not be a world where the maximum speed is unlimited? That is there is no maximum speed. What about a world where there are stable structures of smaller and smaller dimensions and also no limit to the magnification that could be obtained?

Also a world were temporal divisions could be carried unlimited meaningfully , there being no smallest interval? It would be similar to the case with the real numbers were between any two numbers there are an infinity of numbers.

If such a world could exist, it could be considered a root world, in a sense. As it could possibly provide infinite computational capacity and storage to its inhabitants. The inhabitants of said world could simulate all the possible finite universes with limited variables and store them in their unlimited universe.

The only thing that might make such a world impossible is if there's some reason why making so many parameters unlimited is fundamentally impossible. But being as some have considered making the past unlimited in extent, without this being somehow indefensible, it seems safe to suggest that doing the same with the other parameters should not bring problems different from those already brought by making the past unlimited.

That doesn't sound like a world, but rather a cloud of radiation behaving in ways physics has no capacity to predict.
 
IcedEcliptic said:
That doesn't sound like a world, but rather a cloud of radiation behaving in ways physics has no capacity to predict.

Radiation?

There is physical structure in this hypothetical world, it just so happens that like the old 'homunculus', there's usable 'matter-like' structure all the way down. The physical structure would be like an infinite 'Matryoshka doll'. It does bring a similar problem, to that of an unlimited past, namely infinite regress.

Remember that there being no 'maximal speed', while in our world would pose a problem due to light instantly having 'max' speed, thus arriving instantly from all directions and distances, need not behave the same way in this hypothetical world. Light in this hypothetical world might not necessarily go at the maximum speed possible in an unlimited world's vacuum, nor need it have to interact the same way with the particles of this world.
 
Last edited:
flashprogram said:
Radiation?

There is physical structure in this hypothetical world, it just so happens that like the old 'homunculus', there's usable 'matter-like' structure all the way down. The physical structure would be like an infinite 'Matryoshka doll'. It does bring a similar problem, to that of an unlimited past, namely infinite regress.

Remember that there being no 'maximal speed', while in our world would pose a problem due to light instantly having 'max' speed, thus arriving instantly from all directions and distances, need not behave the same way in this hypothetical world. Light in this hypothetical world might not necessarily go at the maximum speed possible in an unlimited world's vacuum, nor need it have to interact the same way with the particles of this world.

Alter constants in such a way, and the notion of a geometric spacetime with relativistic effects dies. In such a radically altered universe, the likely outcome would be that there was not nucleosynthesis as in this universe.
 
IcedEcliptic said:
Alter constants in such a way, and the notion of a geometric spacetime with relativistic effects dies. In such a radically altered universe, the likely outcome would be that there was not nucleosynthesis as in this universe.

In such a universe why would particles even require an origin? While they may or may not have it, it is conceivable that they could be eternal, without a beginning. In any case, since we're dealing with hypothetical particles, that have infinite structure inside them, I'm not entirely sure the concepts that apply to our particles need apply to them, unless there's some sort of fundamental properties that have been found to apply to all conceivable particles.
 
Similar to the 2024 thread, here I start the 2025 thread. As always it is getting increasingly difficult to predict, so I will make a list based on other article predictions. You can also leave your prediction here. Here are the predictions of 2024 that did not make it: Peter Shor, David Deutsch and all the rest of the quantum computing community (various sources) Pablo Jarrillo Herrero, Allan McDonald and Rafi Bistritzer for magic angle in twisted graphene (various sources) Christoph...
Thread 'My experience as a hostage'
I believe it was the summer of 2001 that I made a trip to Peru for my work. I was a private contractor doing automation engineering and programming for various companies, including Frito Lay. Frito had purchased a snack food plant near Lima, Peru, and sent me down to oversee the upgrades to the systems and the startup. Peru was still suffering the ills of a recent civil war and I knew it was dicey, but the money was too good to pass up. It was a long trip to Lima; about 14 hours of airtime...
Back
Top