Can Rock, Paper, Scissors Be Reinvented with New Rules?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DaveC426913
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Paper Rock
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around a reimagined version of the game Rock, Paper, Scissors, where participants propose objects that "beat" the previous object in a creative and humorous manner. The scope includes playful interactions and imaginative reasoning, with specific rules set to guide the responses.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant suggests starting a new game with boundaries, emphasizing that responses must follow a specific format and cannot include certain disallowed elements.
  • Another participant introduces thermite as an object that can burn through a computer and other materials, challenging others to beat it.
  • Several participants engage in playful banter about the rules, with some questioning the validity of previous responses and others attempting to clarify the game's mechanics.
  • Multiple objects are proposed as responses, including sulfuric acid, lye, and various animals, each claiming to defeat the previous object in a humorous manner.
  • Participants express confusion over the implications of time travel and the paradoxes that arise from the game's rules, particularly regarding the sequence of actions.
  • Some participants suggest restarting the game from specific points due to perceived violations of the established rules.
  • There are instances of off-topic comments and humorous exchanges that contribute to the playful nature of the discussion.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally do not reach consensus on the validity of certain responses and the interpretation of the rules, leading to multiple competing views and ongoing debate.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include unresolved paradoxes regarding the sequence of actions and the implications of the rules, particularly concerning time travel and the definition of "beating" an object.

  • #481
Mad scientist genetically engineers a new virus resistant dragon and beats the virus.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #482
You may not believe this but there is an actual Rock, Paper, Scissors league. They sent representatives to all the college bars in my town to get people to compete. The best 'players' of the evening had their names taken for a chance to win a free trip to Las Vegas to compete on ESPN. I kid you not.
 
  • #483
I'll bet we could take them. Do they have immortal's, dragons, black holes, supernovas and tidal waves on their side? And that's only our most recent uses.
Really, who would watch rock, paper, scissors on ESPN?
 
  • #484
Nuclear warhead vaporises virus resistant dragon
 
  • #485
Hippie beats a Nuclear warhead.
 
  • #486
Warhead remains un-damaged by hippie with stick.
 
  • #487
zanazzi78 said:
Warhead remains un-damaged by hippie with stick.
Sorry, but that's rule breaking. Once something is beaten it is gone: you can't go back and change a previous event. If you have contention with the fact that a hippie could beat a nuke, then consider if they managed to lobby the congress to remove all nukes.
 
  • #488
hippie gets beaten by the Establishment.
 
  • #489
subversion defeats establishment.
 
  • #490
The rebels lack of estlabshiment of effective and proper government and causes them to go into civil war beats subversion.
 
  • #491
scott1 said:
The rebels lack of estlabshiment of effective and proper government and causes them to go into civil war beats subversion.

Cannibals eat rebels.

-Dan
 
  • #492
topsquark said:
Cannibals eat rebels.

-Dan
Food poisoning beats cannibals.
 
  • #493
Dawguard said:
Food poisoning beats cannibals.

(Hmmmmmmm...If you wanted to "food poison" cannibals, wouldn't you have to have taken the poison yourself?? Kind of a lose-lose situation, isn't it? )

Proper handling and storage beats food poisoning.

-Dan
 
  • #494
Avian bird flu that causes the workers to contamint the food beats proper handling of food
 
  • #495
scott1 said:
Avian bird flu that causes the workers to contamint the food beats proper handling of food

A traditional, environmentally friendly, English bird shoot wipes out the entire avian population on Earth, beating avian bird flu.

-Dan
 
  • #496
topsquark said:
A traditional, environmentally friendly, English bird shoot wipes out the entire avian population on Earth, beating avian bird flu.

-Dan
Gun banning beat English bird hunt.
 
  • #497
Dick Cheny and his favorit http://cbs11tv.com/topstories/topstories_story_048114947.html" beats gun banning
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #498
scott1 said:
Dick Cheny and his favorit http://cbs11tv.com/topstories/topstories_story_048114947.html" beats gun banning
Foaming mad liberals beat Cheney.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #499
Rabies vaccine beats the foaming liberals
 
  • #500
Mk said:
Rabies vaccine beats the foaming liberals

PETA beats rabies vaccine due to animal testing.

-Dan

(And here I though PETA would never be useful! :biggrin: Please don't track me down for saying that...)
 
  • #501
topsquark said:
PETA beats rabies vaccine due to animal testing.

-Dan

(And here I though PETA would never be useful! :biggrin: Please don't track me down for saying that...)
Bloody, gruesome civil war between trial lawers beats PETA.
 
  • #502
Dawguard said:
Bloody, gruesome civil war between trial lawers beats PETA.

Samuel L. Jackson beats trial lawyers. (Go Shaft!)

-Dan
 
  • #503
Peacemaker missile beats Samuel L. Jackson.
 
  • #504
anti gun activist beats colt 45 peacemaker
 
  • #505
gun beats anti-gun activist
 
  • #506
Shoddy ammo creates carbon build-up and jams the gun
 
  • #507
Hungry armadillo eats shoddy ammo.
 
  • #508
arildno said:
Hungry armadillo eats shoddy ammo.

Shoddy ammo blows up and kills armadillo. End of contest!

Just kidding!

Redneck shoots, stuffs, and "mounts" armadillo.

-Dan
 
  • #509
A gang of gay gigolos beats up redneck
 
  • #510
arildno said:
A gang of gay gigolos beats up redneck
Motorcycle gang laughs at the gay gigilos' pathetic attempt to beat someone up, and procedes to kill them all.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
Replies
17
Views
7K