Pjpic
- 235
- 1
Can there be an area without gravity? Are branes the only places with gravity?
The discussion revolves around the concept of gravity, specifically whether there can be areas without gravity and the implications of branes in this context. Participants explore theoretical frameworks, including general relativity (GR), and consider the nuances of gravitational effects in various scenarios.
Participants express differing views on the existence of gravity in various contexts, with no consensus reached on the implications of spacetime curvature or the relevance of branes. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the definitions and conditions under which gravity may be considered absent.
Participants highlight the complexity of defining gravity and its dependence on theoretical frameworks, such as general relativity. There are also unresolved questions about the implications of spacetime expansion and the conditions necessary for gravity to be considered absent.
It depends on what you mean by "gravity". People usually think of "gravity" in GR in terms of the Riemann tensor, the connection coefficients, or the metric. (Maybe more, that is what first comes to mind). You could have a region where the Riemann tensor was zero or the connection components ##\Gamma^{ij}_k## were all zero. There isn't any way I can think of to have no metric, or a zero metric, though you could have a flat metric. Test particles in any such region would move in straight lines. Sorry to be so technical, but I am not sure I understand the point of the question. Branes are not part of GR, I am not sure of how to relate them to your question.Pjpic said:Can there be an area without gravity? Are branes the only places with gravity?
Does that mean if space is not curved there is no gravity?pervect said:It depends on what you mean by "gravity". People usually think of "gravity" in GR in terms of the Riemann tensor, the connection coefficients, or the metric. (Maybe more, that is what first comes to mind). You could have a region where the Riemann tensor was zero or the connection components ##\Gamma^{ij}_k## were all zero. There isn't any way I can think of to have no metric, or a zero metric, though you could have a flat metric. Test particles in any such region would move in straight lines. Sorry to be so technical, but I am not sure I understand the point of the question. Branes are not part of GR, I am not sure of how to relate them to your question.
Pjpic said:Does that mean if space is not curved there is no gravity?
Pjpic said:Does that mean if space is not curved there is no gravity?
William Donald said:with space-time expansion and such; you might not ever even fall into the star.