Can We Store AC Power Like DC?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the question of whether AC power can be stored similarly to DC power. Participants explore various methods of energy storage, particularly in the context of renewable energy sources like wind power, and the challenges associated with storing electrical energy in different forms.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants clarify that while power itself cannot be stored, energy can be stored, and AC energy can be converted to a storable form using rectifiers.
  • There are suggestions that motors can function as generators to store energy in flywheels, and that compressed air systems could also be used for energy storage.
  • One participant proposes using windmill-generated AC power in conjunction with hydroelectric plants to store energy as potential energy in water.
  • Concerns are raised about the efficiency of energy storage methods, particularly the energy losses involved in converting AC to DC and back to AC.
  • Some participants mention the use of pumped storage as a viable method for large-scale energy storage, while others question the reliability of windmills and the technology used in them.
  • There is a discussion about the role of induction generators in wind power, noting that they maintain a constant frequency despite variations in wind speed.
  • One participant references a past conversation with an R&D director suggesting that DC is preferred for certain applications, highlighting differing opinions on the best approach to energy storage.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a mix of viewpoints, with some agreeing on the feasibility of storing AC energy through conversion processes, while others emphasize the challenges and inefficiencies involved. There is no clear consensus on the best methods for storing AC power or the reliability of wind energy systems.

Contextual Notes

Participants note limitations in energy storage methods, including energy losses during conversion and the high costs associated with large-scale storage solutions. The discussion also reflects varying assumptions about the efficiency and reliability of different technologies.

Dilip Y
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
I simply wanted to know, whether we can store AC power like DC?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
If you're referring to storing it in a battery or capacitors, no.
However, we can use motors that also function like generators to store relatively small amounts of energy in a flywheel and extract it should there be a power failure. This is used on some generators allowing time for the engine to start.

There has been much consideration for compressing vast volumes of air using electric motors and then recovering the energy using generators (which may again be the same part). These machines could run/deliver AC.

We can always convert AC to DC and DC to AC, though the latter becomes more complicated. Thus, you can store energy in batteries using a rectifier (AC-DC) and then return the energy using an inverter (DC-AC).

There are difficulties with storing any great amount of electricity in that you lose some energy in the process and for things like pumps and compressors that loss can be very large (i.e. more than half) of what you're attempting to store. In addition, amounts of electricity that a home commonly use through a day require a large investment in equipment. i.e. $30,000 to $40,000 to store a day's worth of energy.
 
Welcome to PF;
It's not clear what you are asking - I'll explain:

In general you cannot store power - physically, power is the rate of change of energy while a stored object does not change, that's what the word "store" implies in this context.

We can store energy, and the energy carried by an AC electric current can, indeed, be stored.
It is stored whenever it is asked to do mechanical work: for example, driving a motor to lift a weight.

We store energy by converting it into a store-able form.

But you may be asking - "can we get AC electricity to charge a battery or a capacitor?" - and we can: if we use a rectifier first.
 
Generally, storing a decent amount of electrical energy is a difficult problem. It is easier and technically more feasible to store it in a DC form.
 
Dilip Y said:
I simply wanted to know, whether we can store AC power like DC?

This question has suddenly become more important when electric companies started using windmills. Wind is seldom constant, so if the windmills produce AC, the frequency will vary with the speed of the windmill and cannot therefore be added directly into the power grid which has a fixed frequency. One solution is to convert to DC and use the DC to create AC with the correct frequency and phase. My take on it was to use the power from the windmills in conjunction with a hydroelectric plant - use the windmill power to pump some of the water from the downside of the hydroelectric plant up to the input dam - to be used again. In this case we are storing the inconvenient AC from the windmills as potential energy in the water.
 
Svein said:
This question has suddenly become more important when electric companies started using windmills. Wind is seldom constant, so if the windmills produce AC, the frequency will vary with the speed of the windmill and cannot therefore be added directly into the power grid which has a fixed frequency. One solution is to convert to DC and use the DC to create AC with the correct frequency and phase. My take on it was to use the power from the windmills in conjunction with a hydroelectric plant - use the windmill power to pump some of the water from the downside of the hydroelectric plant up to the input dam - to be used again. In this case we are storing the inconvenient AC from the windmills as potential energy in the water.
With ac induction generators, the frequency does not change with rotor speed, hence induction generators are commonly employed for windmill generators connected to the grid. The slip frequency between the rotor and stator changes with wind speed and rotor speed, but the frequency generated stays constant. If you search using the key words "induction generator frequency" you should get some detailed info. BR.

Claude
 
Simon Bridge said:
We can store energy, and the energy carried by an AC electric current can, indeed, be stored.
Exactly. And http://www.hydro.org/tech-and-policy/technology/pumped-storage/ is a good way.

Pumped storage is an essential solution for grid reliability, providing one of the few large-scale, affordable means of storing and deploying electricity.

Pumpstor_racoon_mtn.jpg
 
Exactly. And http://www.hydro.org/tech-and-policy/technology/pumped-storage/ is a good way.
It is certainly one way - whether it is a "good" way depends on the circumstances... which are not present in the original question, which has been answered.
 
cabraham said:
With ac induction generators, the frequency does not change with rotor speed, hence induction generators are commonly employed for windmill generators connected to the grid. The slip frequency between the rotor and stator changes with wind speed and rotor speed, but the frequency generated stays constant. If you search using the key words "induction generator frequency" you should get some detailed info. BR.
I do not doubt that, but back when I was working as a consultant for ABB, I put the question to the local R&D director. His answer: "They use DC".

Another thing about windmills - They seem to have poor longtime reliability. In all windmill parks I have seen, there are several just standing still - and the neighboring windmills are spinning. I think Siemens blamed the gearboxes - anybody have better information?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
1K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 31 ·
2
Replies
31
Views
4K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
21
Views
3K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
5K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
3K