Can You Solve These Vector Questions About Wind?

  • Thread starter Thread starter uniquegirl
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Vector Wind
Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
49 replies · 3K views
uniquegirl said:
But since Ve isn't given, would it be 25? or am I missing something?
Look at the triangle formed by the red arrow, the vertical blue arrow, and the dashed line across their tops. In relation to the 25°, the blue arrow is the adjacent, the dashed line is the opposite and the red arrow is the hypotenuse.
Which ratio do you want in order to find Vn from V? What is that ratio as a trig function of the 25°?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Lnewqban
Physics news on Phys.org
uniquegirl said:
But since Ve isn't given, would it be 25? or am I missing something?
Ve isn't given but is not equal 25. 25 is the hypotenuse. Ve is one of the vertical sides, the opposite to the angle of 25 degrees and the adjacent side is Vn .

If i give you a right triangle with the hypotenuse equal to 25 and one angle equal to 25 degrees, can you find the side adjacent to the angle of 25 degrees?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Lnewqban
Yup!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2
sin(25)= 0.4226...
0.4226... = d / 25
Swap sides:d / 25= 0.4226...
Multiply both sides by 30:d = 0.4226...x 25
Calculate: d = 10.56 to 2 decimal places
So opp would be 10.56?

Is this it?
 
  • Like
  • Love
Likes   Reactions: malawi_glenn and Delta2
Sin A= √(c^2-b^2)
SinA= √(25^2-10^2)
Sin= 22.91
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Lnewqban and Delta2
have you not worked with right-angled triangles and trigonometry before in basic math?

1657004962211.png


hyp = 25 (total velocity)
adj = vn (velocity component in the north direction)
opp = ve (velocity component in the east direction)

opp /hyp = sin25°
adj /hyp = cos25°

Or, perhaps this is easier
1657005051591.png


hyp = 25 (total velocity)
adj = ve (velocity component in the east direction)
opp = vn (velocity component in the north direction)

opp /hyp = sin65°
adj /hyp = cos65°
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Lnewqban and Delta2
uniquegirl said:
Sin A= √(c^2-b^2)
SinA= √(25^2-10^2)
Sin= 22.91
Yes ok you can use pythagorean theorem, but you could do it as 25*cos(25)
 
  • Informative
Likes   Reactions: uniquegirl
oh ok thank you! so 22.91 is the right answer? So the answer for Ve is the same as the answer for Vn, because they are same triangles?
 
Assuming Ve is 22.91,for question b this is what I did, feel free to correct me

Question b- A strong gust of wind from the west causes the skier to accelerate to the east at 2.0 m s-2 for 1.8 s. Calculate the new velocity in the easterly direction

vi=22.65ms-1 t= 1.8s a=2.0ms^2 vf=?

vf=vi+at
vf= 22.65+2.0x1.8
vf= 26.25
 
uniquegirl said:
oh ok thank you! so 22.91 is the right answer? So the answer for Ve is the same as the answer for Vn, because they are same triangles?
No Ve is the opposite site , Vn is the adjacent side, the answer for Ve you calculated it as 10.24.
 
uniquegirl said:
Assuming Ve is 22.91,for question b this is what I did, feel free to correct me

Question b- A strong gust of wind from the west causes the skier to accelerate to the east at 2.0 m s-2 for 1.8 s. Calculate the new velocity in the easterly direction

vi=22.65ms-1 t= 1.8s a=2.0ms^2 vf=?

vf=vi+at
vf= 22.65+2.0x1.8
vf= 26.25
this would have been correct if you had used as vi=25sin(25)=10.24.
 
Is this better? vf= 10.56+2.0x1.8 vf= 14.16
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2
C) Use your answer in (a) to calculate the size and direction of the new resultant velocity of the skier
so for direction I used tan-1=opp/hyp =10.56/25 = 0.4424 I think I did this wrong cause its such a low number but for the size, V^2= 25^2+10.56^2.
 
tan-1= opp/adj
= tan-1 10.56/22.91
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: malawi_glenn
For the size, I used v=(square root ) a^2+b^2
v= (square root)22.91^2+10.56^2
would this be right?
 
uniquegirl said:
For the size, I used v=(square root ) a^2+b^2
v= (square root)22.91^2+10.56^2
would this be right?
The 22.91 is inaccurate. That is because in post #37 you used ve=10 instead of 10.56. (Or, better, using vn=25cos(25).)

Assuming you are trying part c, using 10.56m/s as the Easterly velocity here just gets you back to a net speed of 25m/s. You need to be using the new Easterly velocity calculated in post #44.

Please try to change your way of working to be entirely algebraic as far as possible, only plugging in numbers at the end. This has many advantages, such as fewer errors, easier detection of errors, improved precision and greater readability. In multipart questions, that even means not immediately using the numerical answer to one part in the next part, instead resuming the algebraic form. Sometimes that let's you do some cancellation.

When you do plug in numbers, always include the units.

To illustrate:
Part a:
ve=v sin(25)=25m/s sin(25)= 10.56 m/s.
vn=v cos(25)=25m/s cos(25)= 22.66 m/s.
Part b:
ve'=ve+at=ve+(2m/s2)(1.8s)= 14.16 m/s.
Part c:
v'=√(ve'2+vn2)
etc.

Now, what about the last bit, the new direction?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: uniquegirl and Lnewqban
Cool, Thank you for all the help everyone, appreciate it:smile:
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Lnewqban