Change in direction affecting velocity

In summary: In everyday speech, we usually talk about accelerating towards something or decelerating from something. But in physics, we usually talk about accelerating or decelerating without changing the magnitude of the velocity. So when you turn 20° to the left, the car is still going at the same speed, but the direction of the velocity has changed. This is called deceleration.
  • #1
Zack K
166
6
I just have a simple question to ask people of physics since I keep on forgetting to ask my physics teacher.
Does changing your direction while in motion affect your velocity? If so why? What forces cause it's velocity to decrease. Assuming that friction is present.(Also would it affect an objects velocity in a friction-less environment?).
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Zack K said:
I just have a simple question to ask people of physics since I keep on forgetting to ask my physics teacher
Does changing your direction while in motion affect your velocity? If so why? What forces cause it's velocity to decrease. Assuming that friction is present.(Also would it affect an objects velocity in a friction-less environment?).
Do you understand the defintions of "speed" and "velocity"? What are they and how do they apply to this question?
 
  • #3
phinds said:
Do you understand the defintions of "speed" and "velocity"? What are they and how do they apply to this question?
Speed is a scalar quantity which means that there is no direction involved and is used for simple situations. When you get into physics, you start using velocity which is a vector quantity and it has a direction. I know that if you are going forward at a certain velocity and suddenly decelerate and go backwards, your velocity changes in that time. But I wanted to know if that happens when you are driving a car and let's say turn 20° to the left. Would that count as deceleration?
 
Last edited:
  • #4
Zack K said:
Speed is a scalar quantity which means that there is no direction involved and is used for simple situations. When you get into physics, you start using velocity which is a vector quantity and it has a direction. I know that if you are going forward at a certain velocity and suddenly decelerate an go backwards, your velocity changes in that time. But I wanted to know if that happens when you are driving a car and let's say turn 20° to the left. Would that count a deceleration?
You first asked if it affected velocity. Does it?
 
  • #5
Zack K said:
Does changing your direction while in motion affect your velocity?
Here's an easy case: swing a weight on a string in a fast circle around your head. The weight is moving at a constant speed but changing its direction all the time. Is there a force on it? Is it accelerating? If it is, then its velocity must be changing, because that's what acceleration is.
What forces cause its velocity to decrease?
Velocity is a vector, and vectors can change without increasing or decreasing their magnitude... So you should not be assuming that the velocity is decreasing just because there's a force involved, nor that absence of increase/decrease implies that there's no force involved.
 
  • #6
Zack K said:
But I wanted to know if that happens when you are driving a car and let's say turn 20° to the left. Would that count as deceleration?
Why do you say "deceleration" and not "acceleration"?
 
  • #7
Nugatory said:
Here's an easy case: swing a weight on a string in a fast circle around your head. The weight is moving at a constant speed but changing its direction all the time. Is there a force on it? Is it accelerating? If it is, then its velocity must be changing, because that's what acceleration is.

Velocity is a vector, and vectors can change without increasing or decreasing their magnitude... So you should not be assuming that the velocity is decreasing just because there's a force involved, nor that absence of increase/decrease implies that there's no force involved.

Well I'm confused now since we just learned that forces cause acceleration. Hence the equation F=ma. So how is it possible for something to not accelerate if there is a force involved?
 
  • #8
jtbell said:
Why do you say "deceleration" and not "acceleration"?
I just use that instead of acceleration in the negative direction.
 
  • #9
Zack K said:
But I wanted to know if that happens when you are driving a car and let's say turn 20° to the left. Would that count as deceleration?
jtbell said:
Why do you say "deceleration" and not "acceleration"?
Zack K said:
just use that instead of acceleration in the negative direction.
What is the "negative direction" in your example, which implies two dimensions?
 
  • #10
jtbell said:
What is the "negative direction" in your example, which implies two dimensions?
Well it's all relative. But on a graph, negative direction is usually left or down. Like if you throw a ball in the air. It's experiencing negative acceleration since gravity is forcing it downwards. Usually in equations we also put -9.8 m/s2
 
  • #11
Zack K said:
Well it's all relative. But on a graph, negative direction is usually left or down. Like if you throw a ball in the air. It's experiencing negative acceleration since gravity is forcing it downwards. Usually in equations we also put -9.8 m/s2

There is a distinction between "acceleration/deceleration" in everyday speech and the formal physics term "acceleration". The definition of "acceleration" in physics is any change in velocity, be it speeding up, slowing down and/or changing direction. And any such change must be caused by a force. So, you have:

##F = ma##

This is for motion in one dimension (along a single straight line) and here ##a## can be positive or negative. It's still possible to talk about "deceleration" when something is slowing down, but slowing down is still, formally, acceleration.

You also have:

##\vec{F} = m\vec{a}##

Which is a vector equation and applies in 1, 2 or 3 dimensions. In this case, you are best simply to talk about the acceleration ##\vec{a}##.

In particular, you should start to think of "acceleration" not as a "speeding up", but as any change in velocity.
 
  • #12
Right, in everyday language, "acceleration" (increasing speed) and "deceleration" (decreasing speed) are considered as opposites. In physics language, "deceleration", when it is used at all, means "decreasing speed", the same as in everyday language, and is simply one kind of "acceleration" (any change of velocity, whether it is by changing speed or changing direction).

In everyday language, as far as I know in English, the term for "changing direction while keeping speed constant" is simply "turning" which is separate from both "acceleration" and "deceleration" (again, in everyday language).
 
  • #13
The key is to understand that velocity has components speed and direction and that a change to either component implies a change in velocity which by definition is an acceleration. So objects moving in a circle or changing direction in some other way are accelerating.

It can be confusing to talk about decelerating. For example a car accelerating at say -1m/s2 is not necessarily decelerating.

Velocity and acceleration vectors don't always point in the same direction.
 
  • #14
Zack K said:
Well I'm confused now since we just learned that forces cause acceleration. Hence the equation F=ma. So how is it possible for something to not accelerate if there is a force involved?
If there's a net force, then there will be acceleration. But acceleration does not necessarily imply a changing speed.

When Nugatory made this statement, I think he meant to say that you should not assume that the speed is increasing or decreasing when there is acceleration:
Nugatory said:
So you should not be assuming that the velocity is decreasing just because there's a force involved, nor that absence of increase/decrease implies that there's no force involved.
 
  • Like
Likes Nugatory

1. How does a change in direction affect an object's velocity?

A change in direction will affect an object's velocity by altering its speed and/or direction of motion. This change can be achieved through forces such as acceleration, deceleration, or a change in the object's path.

2. Is there a difference between a change in direction and a change in velocity?

Yes, there is a difference between a change in direction and a change in velocity. A change in direction refers to a shift in the path of an object, while a change in velocity refers to a change in the object's speed. Both can occur simultaneously, but they are distinct concepts.

3. How does a change in direction affect the momentum of an object?

A change in direction will affect the momentum of an object by altering its velocity. Momentum is a product of an object's mass and velocity, so a change in either of these factors will result in a change in momentum. This change in momentum can be in the same direction as the change in velocity or in the opposite direction.

4. Can a change in direction occur without a change in velocity?

Yes, a change in direction can occur without a change in velocity. This is possible when the object's speed remains constant, but its direction of motion changes. For example, a car turning around a corner at a constant speed will experience a change in direction without a change in velocity.

5. How can we calculate the change in velocity caused by a change in direction?

The change in velocity caused by a change in direction can be calculated using the law of conservation of momentum. This law states that the total momentum of a system remains constant unless acted upon by an external force. By applying this law and considering the initial and final velocities of the object, we can calculate the change in velocity caused by a change in direction.

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
31
Views
1K
  • Mechanics
Replies
11
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
11K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
22
Views
1K
Back
Top