- #141
Frabjous
Gold Member
- 1,600
- 1,927
Nena’s take
Scrambling fighter jets
On January 28, when the balloon entered US airspace near Alaska, the North American Aerospace Defense Command, or NORAD, sent up fighter jets to make a positive identification, according to defense officials, reflecting a subtle shift in urgency.
Still, officials tracking the balloon saw little reason to be alarmed. At the time, according to US officials, this balloon was expected to sail over Alaska and continue on a northern trajectory that intelligence and military officials could track and study.
Instead, shortly after the balloon crossed over land, it alarmed officials by making its unexpected turn south.
On January 31, the balloon had crossed out of Canada and into the Lower 48. And concerns that the balloon had been sent by Beijing explicitly to spy on the mainland US were confirmed when NORAD observed the balloon “loitering” over sensitive military facilities, multiple sources familiar with the intelligence told CNN.
How much control China exerted over the balloon’s path remains a matter of debate. Although the balloon was equipped with propellers and a rudder that allowed it to turn “like a sailboat,” according to the senior US official, it largely rode the jet stream – one of the reasons US officials were able to predict its path across the US in advance.
Chines people are not stupid to send their spy equipment on such a voyage. Too risky if it gets off course. Besides, they have over 300 satellites, so they have surely scanned the whole US territory by now. Many times over. And what do you thing US equipment (i.e. satellites) are doing up there ? Having parties ? Come on... Everybody is spying on everyone. Just a fact.WWGD said:BHow do you know it's all it was? Nations don't usually fly " weather "balloons ( how do you know what was actually inside of the balloon) incognito past each other.
Reminds me of the old joke about peeing in the swimming pool.discoversci said:Everybody is spying on everyone. Just a fact.
A lot of bad can be justified with this class of argument.discoversci said:Come on... Everybody is spying on everyone. Just a fact.
I hope the Americans are thinking like that but I really doubt it.discoversci said:Chines people are not stupid to send their spy equipment on such a voyage. Too risky if it gets off course. Besides, they have over 300 satellites, so they have surely scanned the whole US territory by now. Many times over. And what do you thing US equipment (i.e. satellites) are doing up there ? Having parties ? Come on... Everybody is spying on everyone. Just a fact.
They already released the preliminary findings. Just like they thought, tons of SIGINT equipment for measuring and triangulating signals. A propeller with a rudder. It's a spy balloon.pinball1970 said:I hope the Americans are thinking like that but I really doubt it.
A satellite orbiting the earth is not in US air space, checkout the US list here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prohibited_airspace
Also lots of Chinese Satellites yes but they cannot hold a position over one spot like a balloon can is what has been pointed out.
The debris from the balloon has been recovered now so lets see.
Remember Lockheed U-2 spy plane ? I guess Soviets found a way at that time. They've used urine-indicator dye and hence located the perpetrator (wee-wee master) as well as being able to measure the exact height of the jump board. And what's with that (almost) everyday violation of "one China" principle ? Somebody is obviously violating the airspace of China on a daily basisRive said:Reminds me of the old joke about peeing in the swimming pool.
You know, even if it's a bit fuzzy thing, doing it from the jump board is kind of different...
I'm not justifying anything. I'm just saying it's a factFrabjous said:A lot of bad can be justified with this class of argument.
If you say so. And if the US gov says soboneh3ad said:They already released the preliminary findings. Just like they thought, tons of SIGINT equipment for measuring and triangulating signals. A propeller with a rudder. It's a spy balloon.
(last reminder to avoid heading too much into politics, or this thread will be done. Thank you)discoversci said:If you say so. And if the US gov says so
This is quite recent.boneh3ad said:They already released the preliminary findings. Just like they thought, tons of SIGINT equipment for measuring and triangulating signals. A propeller with a rudder. It's a spy balloon.
Since my daughter is a pilot, I'm glad they shot the damned thing down.berkeman said:It was at 40,000 feet, so deemed a threat to civilian aircraft...
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news...tude-object-shot-own-over-alaska/11229937002/WASHINGTON — The U.S. shot down an unidentified object Friday over frozen waters near Alaska at the order of President Joe Biden, less than one week after shooting down a Chinese spy balloon off the East Coast.
Just an update -- Cindy's dad was wearing a parachute and was able to bail out as the F22s approached...Ivan Seeking said:This balloon is thought to have originated at little Cindy Davis's birthday party. Cindy and her friends have no comment so far.
Looks like a hydra balloon. Shoot 1 balloon and n more will appear.berkeman said:Just an update -- Cindy's dad was wearing a parachute and was able to bail out as the F22s approached...
View attachment 322071
https://tilln.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/lawn-chair-larry_copycat.jpg
LOL! I remember the original! And yes, it really did happen - Lawn-chair Larry. I listened to live coverage as he got too close to an airport.berkeman said:Just an update -- Cindy's dad was wearing a parachute and was able to bail out as the F22s approached...
View attachment 322071
https://tilln.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/lawn-chair-larry_copycat.jpg
That was my point earlier. It may seem harmless enough, but it could be a prelude to nuclear war. They are apparently probing some of our most sensitive nuclear installations.Jarvis323 said:In this context, the balloon incident can be a signal. By flying a blatantly visible spy balloon over the US nuclear missile silos, it sends the message that China is preparing, or prepared, to engage the US in a nuclear war if it comes to it. By showing they are serious about this possibility, it can potentially help deter the US from taking the risk to defend Taiwan.
I believe he shot his own balloons too.Ivan Seeking said:LOL! I remember the original! And yes, it really did happen - Lawn-chair Larry. I listened to live coverage as he got too close to an airport.
IIRC, he dropped his BB gun. But he did come down eventually.BillTre said:I believe he shot his own balloons too.
Doh!Ivan Seeking said:IIRC, he dropped his BB gun.
Ivan Seeking said:The government and media are officially calling the second object, unidentified, and not definitively a balloon. And of course, this is already being cited as one of those UAPs [UFOs] the government was talking about.
strangerep said:The comedians seem surprisingly slow. I would have expected to see various cartoons involving Winnie the Pooh hanging from a balloon...