Combination/probability question (High School level)

  • Topic:
  • Thread starter Micky1964
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    School
6 replies · 2K views · last reply
Micky1964
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Hi all. I'm doing a counting/probability problem here.
I can see how the correct answer for part b is arrived at by counting the number of combinations for "2 girls" then counting the number of combinations for "3 girls" , and adding these results.
But I've attached my first way of approaching it, which is wrong. Wondering if anyone can tell me why my approach doesn't give the correct answer. I know it's probably something obvious that I'm missing.
Thanks
 
Attachments
  • Textbook page showing Example 16: a probability problem about choosing 3 students from 6 boys and 4 girls, with worked solutions for exactly one girl (60/120 = 0.5) and at least two girls (40/120 = 1/3).
    IMG_2899.JPG
    639.7 KB · Views: 162
  • Handwritten working on lined paper for question 16(b): number of possible teams = 10C3 = 120; number of teams with at least 2 girls = 4C2 x 8C1 = 4!/(2!) x 8 = 48; so Pr(at least 2 girls) = 48/120, followed by a handwritten explanation of the reasoning.
    IMG_2900.JPG
    592.8 KB · Views: 170
With your method groups with 3 girls get counted 3 times each rather than once each.
 
romsek said:
With your method groups with 3 girls get counted 3 times each rather than once each.
Thank you for replying. I can see that makes sense now.

So the best approach with these types of problems is to treat each situation separately? ie. find how many ways you can have 2 girls and 1 boy, then find how many ways you can have 3 girls and 0 boys, then add the 2 figures?

Mick
 
Micky1964 said:
Thank you for replying. I can see that makes sense now.

So the best approach with these types of problems is to treat each situation separately? ie. find how many ways you can have 2 girls and 1 boy, then find how many ways you can have 3 girls and 0 boys, then add the 2 figures?

Mick

It's a bit difficult to cite any approach as "best" given the variety of problems that exist but generally separating the cases helps ensure you won't multiply count specific situations.
 
I think it odd that choosing students "to represent the class in a debate" would be done at random!
 
Country Boy said:
I think it odd that choosing students "to represent the class in a debate" would be done at random!
You clearly never went to my High School.

-Dan