Comparison of sound waves in air and underwater

In summary: Check the graph of the response of the ear. It shows a dip around 3000 Hz and a peak at around 20,000 Hz.The ear is not equally sensitive to all frequencies. In fact, the lowest threshold of hearing is at 4000 Hz. So, we are more sensitive to frequencies around 4000 Hz than, say, 1000 Hz.You are right. Lower frequencies around 1000 Hz (and down) would produce lower overtones 'between nodes', which should still make the sound audible. But they would be less intense and less 'obvious' to the ear than the fundamental tone at 4000 Hz.One more thing that should interest you is that the fundamental frequency is not the
  • #1
slakedlime
76
2
[SOLVED] Comparison of sound waves in air and underwater

Homework Statement


In air, the human ear is most sensitive to sound waves of 3300Hz. The auditory canal is part of the human ear. It is a tube of length 0.025m, i.e. 1/4 the wavelength of sound with frequency 3300Hz.

When under water, the speed of sound is 1500m/s. The human ear becomes most sensitive to sounds with a frequency greater than that of the 3300Hz in air. Explain why this is.


2. Homework Equations and data
Wavelength of sound in air
= 4 x 0.025m
= 0.1m

Speed of sound = wavelength x frequency


The Attempt at a Solution


The auditory canal is a closed tube, the eardrum being the closed end. Thus, the ear is most sensitive to sounds that strike the eardrum at a node:

auditory.jpg

Under water, the ear will still be most sensitive to sounds of wavelength 4 times the length of the auditory canal, i.e. sound of wavelength 0.1m. However, speed of sound under water is greater so the frequency of the sound the ear is most sensitive to must be greater than 3300 Hz.

Frequency x 0.1m = 1500m/s
Frequency = 15000Hz
The ear is thus most sensitive to frequencies of 15000Hz.

------------------------------------
This solution seems to go with the data provided. However, if the sound waves strike the eardrum at a node, shouldn't destructive interference occur? How is the person able to hear anything at all?

Any light into this matter would be really appreciated. :smile:
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The ear canal can be treated as open pipe resonating at the most sensitive frequency, and the relationship between length L and f can be roughly estimated by f=v/(2L).

Since v of sound is more in water, f is more, since L is the same.

(EDIT: should be half-open.)
 
Last edited:
  • #3
Speed in air
= 0.1m x 3300Hz
= 330m/s

Using your equation:
Frequency
= v/(2L)
= (330m/s)/(2x 0.025m)
= 6600Hz

It doesn't match the frequency provided by the question. :frown: L is the length of the auditory canal, right? And even if I used wavelength as L, it wouldn't match:

Frequency
= v/(2L)
= (330m/s)/(2x 0.1m)
= 1650Hz

Can we really assume the ear canal to be a open-ended pipe? According to my Barron's SAT book:

Wavelength = 2 x length of open-ended pipe

This contradicts the instructions provided by the question, although if the ear canal were an open-ended pipe the sound waves would strike the eardrum at an antinode (loudest amplitude).

I'm confused.
 
Last edited:
  • #4
Even if you model the ear canal as a closed tube, then the formula will change to f = v/4L. The point is that f_water/f_air = v_water/v_air => f_water = 15000 Hz, as you had found.

(Your formula from Barron's SAT is identical with what I'd given -- f*lambda=v)

But coming back to your conceptual question, nodes are point of minimal disturbance, not zero disturbance, at least not as far as real sound waves are concerned.
 
  • #5
I'm still a little confused. If the ear is a closed tube and we apply the formula as such (wavelength = 4 x length of ear canal), then do all sound waves strike it at a node or do some (with a different wavelength) strike it at antinodes? I suppose if some did strike it at an antinode then the ear would be more sensitive to that?

I'm also wondering about the open tube theory. Can I model the ear as a open tube like you suggested without the formula messing up the frequency like I calculated? What's the difference between modelling it as a closed/open tube?
 
  • #6
Actually, it's called a half-open tube, I believe. I would think that the ear canal would behave like a half-open tube, seeing that one side is actually open. In a closed tube, nodes are formed at both ends. In a half-open tube, the node is at one end (the eardrum).

You are quite correct, and the ear is sensitive to other resonant frequencies when a node is formed at the eardrum, and an antinode at the other.
 
  • #7
Ah, yes... it's a half-open tube. I keep getting my physics vocabulary mixed up. When you said open-ended tube I suppose you meant that the ear canal was actually open at one end but I misunderstood thinking you meant it was open at both ends.

On this vein, do all sound waves strike the eardrum at a node? I suppose that sound of higher resonant frequency and smaller wavelength than the one the ear is most sensitive to must produce overtones, but still strike the eardrum at a node. But what about sound of lower resonant frequency and greater wavelength. Do they strike the eardrum at a position somewhere between a node and an antinode? If so, this sound should be louder than that which strikes the eardrum at a node. Why isn't the ear more sensitive to this?

I'm really sorry if this is off-topic but it seemed interesting and I couldn't find anything helpful on google or my books. Plus my teacher has no idea.
 
  • #8
The question of node and antinode comes up only when there are standing waves. Standing waves would be formed only for selected frequencies, viz., f = nv/(2L). At these frequencies, the ear would be more sensitive.

But you are quite perceptive in saying that below 3300 Hz, there wouldn't be any standing waves. Perhaps that's why we are not so sensitive to frequencies below that. But there are higher frequencies to which we are sensitive.

Here's something that should delight you:

http://www.kemt.fei.tuke.sk/Predmety/KEMT320_EA/_web/Online_Course_on_Acoustics/hearing.html [Broken]
 
Last edited by a moderator:

1. How do sound waves travel through air and water?

Sound waves travel through air and water in a similar manner, through a series of compressions and rarefactions. In air, sound waves travel by vibrating air molecules, while in water, sound waves travel by vibrating water molecules.

2. What is the speed of sound in air and water?

The speed of sound in air is approximately 343 meters per second, while the speed of sound in water is approximately 1498 meters per second. This difference in speed is due to the difference in density and elasticity of air and water.

3. How does the medium affect the propagation of sound waves?

The medium through which sound waves travel can greatly affect their propagation. In air, sound waves can travel long distances, but are easily absorbed by obstacles. In water, sound waves can travel even further, but can also be affected by changes in temperature and salinity.

4. How do the properties of air and water impact the transmission of sound?

The properties of air and water, such as density, temperature, and pressure, can greatly impact the transmission of sound waves. For example, sound travels faster in warmer water and slower in colder water. Similarly, sound travels faster in denser air and slower in less dense air.

5. Can sound waves be heard underwater from above the surface?

Yes, sound waves can be heard underwater from above the surface, and vice versa. However, the further the sound has to travel between the two media, the more it will be affected by factors such as absorption and reflection, which may affect its clarity and loudness.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
30
Views
511
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
4K
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Mechanics
Replies
19
Views
6K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
1K
Back
Top