Confused about forces - can anyone help?

  • Thread starter peanutaxis
  • Start date
  • #1
14
1

Main Question or Discussion Point

In the first diagram below, there is a horizontal board and it is attached to a vertical board via a pivot, P, but is also hooked via a nail (red), and the vertical board is resting on the ground.

If I am pulling on the horizontal board with force Fp, and the whole setup doesn't move, then the forces on the vertical board are Fp, Ff, and F?. Since it is not moving Fp + Ff + F? = 0, and also the torques on the vertical board - due to Ff and F? - about P are equal and opposite (I should have made Ff look smaller).

In the second diagram (also nothing is moving) the nail and hook are now moved to the bottom. Fp is still the same, and Ff is also the same since the weight of the system and the frictioned ground are the same. Even F? is the same since the vertical board is still not rotating so the torques due to Ff and F? will still add to zero. But now F? is in the same direction as Fp, and so the horizontal forces aren't going to sum to zero anymore.

Intuitively, it shouldn't make any difference where you place the nail and hook. Wherever you place them, they will create the same torque about P, but all of a sudden it doesn't make sense in the second diagram.

What the heck is going on?:huh::huh::confused:


w9ywyw.jpg

2rw880o.jpg
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
Yea who made this diagram? It dosen't seem consistent.
 
  • #3
14
1
What's not consistent about it? In the first the vertical board experiences F? to the right, where the nail is. And in the second the vertical board experiences a F? to the left where the nail is.
 
  • #4
Drakkith
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
20,717
4,423
How is there any torque around P if you are just pulling it straight on?
 
  • #5
14
1
How is there any torque around P if you are just pulling it straight on?
Without the nail and hook, there would be a torque on the vertical plank - due to Ff - and it would rotate CCW.

With the nail and hook the torque due to Ff is balanced by the torque due to F?

The question is, how on earth to balance the horizontal forces overall, given that it shouldn't matter where the nail and hook is.
 
  • #6
Nugatory
Mentor
12,539
5,047
What the heck is going on?:huh::huh::confused:
You've made a subtle error in your interpretation of Fp. (It might be easier to think of the hook and the pivot as two pins holding the two boards together and analyzing the forces on them, rather than thinking of a pivot and a hook).

I grab on to the horizontal board and tug on it with some force - let's call it Fh where the h stands for "handle", as if there's a handle on the horizontal board that I'm pulling on. Note that Fh and Ff are the external forces on the two-board system; if they are balanced the two boards won't move.

Now the important part: Fh is NOT the force at the pivot, Fp. Instead, the forces are related by (using the convention that left is the positive direction):
Fh = -(Fp + F?). Depending on where the hook is relative to the pivot, F? can be positive or negative, whatever is needed to generate a torque around the pivot that cancels the torque from Ff and then Fp will be whatever value is needed to make Fh come out to the the known horizontal force you're applying.
 

Related Threads for: Confused about forces - can anyone help?

Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
323
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
4K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
10K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
15
Views
868
Top