Confused About Weird Acceleration Problem in Physics: mA=14kg, mB=11kg, mC=50kg

  • Thread starter Thread starter Hafid Iqbal
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Weird
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a physics problem involving three blocks with different masses and their accelerations. The user is confused about the correct relationships between the accelerations of the blocks, specifically questioning the provided answer that states a_{By} = -3a_{Ay}. Despite attempts to derive the equations, the user consistently arrives at a_{By} = -2a_{Ay}, leading to discrepancies in the calculated accelerations. Other participants suggest that the user needs to account for the movement of block C and clarify the diagram to accurately determine the relationships between the blocks' accelerations. The conversation emphasizes the importance of understanding the constraints of the system and the constant length of the string in solving the problem.
Hafid Iqbal
Messages
15
Reaction score
0
http://img849.imageshack.us/img849/9697/physicsy.jpg


The system bodies shown in the figure is released from rest. Assuming all the contacts to be smooth, find the acceleration of each block (mA = 14 kg, mB = 11 kg, mC = 50 kg)



This problem from Problems In Physics by Abhay K. Singh
I really confused about the answer, it said the acceleration in y-axis for B is a_{By}=-3a_{Ay} which acceleration of each block is a_A = \sqrt{2}, \ a_B = \sqrt{10}, \ a_C = 1

I have tried to figure it out and still find a_{By}=-2a_{Ay} and all of my answer didn't match with the answer by the author

I have had :
a_{Ay}=\frac{(2m_B-m_a)g}{4m_B+m_a},

a_{By}=\frac{(4m_B-2m_a)g}{4m_B+m_a},

a_{C} = \frac{3m_A.m_B.g}{(4m_B+m_A)(m_C+m_B)}

One more thing, is it true that normal force for A is zero?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
Welcome to PF!

Hi Hafid! Welcome to PF! :smile:

(try using the X2 icon just above the Reply box :wink:)

Your aBy = -2aAy would be correct if block C were not moving.

You'll need to add aCx to your aBy and aAy equation.

Try again (and if you still can't get it, please show your actual calculations :wink:).​
One more thing, is it true that normal force for A is zero?

hmm … if the diagram is correct, then A is accelerating to the right, so the normal force would have to be negative! :rolleyes: Unless A is constrained to move in a slot, A must be hanging at an angle. :redface:
 


tiny-tim said:
Hi Hafid! Welcome to PF! :smile:

(try using the X2 icon just above the Reply box :wink:)

Your aBy = -2aAy would be correct if block C were not moving.

You'll need to add aCx to your aBy and aAy equation.

Try again (and if you still can't get it, please show your actual calculations :wink:).​


hmm … if the diagram is correct, then A is accelerating to the right, so the normal force would have to be negative! :rolleyes: Unless A is constrained to move in a slot, A must be hanging at an angle. :redface:


Hi tiny-tim, thanks for your reply! But I'm still stuck :(
Here's my complete paper work


Phewww... And you know what, it is still wrong :cry:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Wow so neat!:cool: Handwriting that is. And the colours!
 
oooh, I like the colours! :-p

But you're still using aBy = 2aAy. :redface:

You need to mark your diagram with something to show how far across C the middle pulley is. :wink:
 
Iclaudius said:
Wow so neat!:cool: Handwriting that is. And the colours!
Hehe... Thanks Iclaudius... :)
tiny-tim said:
oooh, I like the colours! :-p

But you're still using aBy = 2aAy. :redface:

You need to mark your diagram with something to show how far across C the middle pulley is. :wink:

Hmmm... So, what is the right equation for the acceleration?
And, is my equation for mass C true?
 
Hafid Iqbal said:
Hmmm... So, what is the right equation for the acceleration?

dunno, I haven't worked it out, I was going to let you do it, and then criticise. :wink:

(i'm good at that o:))
And, is my equation for mass C true?

Doing mass C on its own is not a good idea, since you need to know the reaction forces from A and B.

Do the (horizontal) equation for masses A B and C together. :smile:
 
I have tried it all over, and still can't solve it, please if anyone here know the right equation for acceleration and net force on mass C help me...
 
The way to find the equation relating the accelerations is to find the equation relating the positions first, and then differentiate.

So call the distance from the middle pulley to the wall p, and the distance from the middle pulley to the right-hand pulley q …

then what are the x component of C, and the y components of A and B (in terms of p and q)? :smile:
 
  • #10
Weird problem and answer but some crazy fun diagram. Never seen someone solve physics question so colorfully.
For the problems regarding acceleration use this hint: The length of string is constant irrespective of the motion.
 

Similar threads

Pulley and Work Energy problems
Replies
6
Views
7K

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top