Control System: Find the Transfer Function From Block Diagram

5 replies · 3K views · last reply
jaus tail
Messages
613
Reaction score
48

Homework Statement


Block diagram of a control system with two summing junctions, blocks G1, G2, H1 and H2, input signals Ra and Rb, output signals CA and CB, followed by four multiple-choice transfer function options (A) to (D).


Homework Equations


To find Ca / Rb we take Ra = 0 --- is this right?
I used mason's formula
P1 = -G2 G1 H1
Loop = G1, G2, -H1, -H2
Using Mason's Gain we get:
Delta1 = 1
Delta = 1 - G1G2H1H2
Using Mason's Gain
TF = -G1G2H1 Divided by ( 1 - G1G2H1H2)
But substituting the values I don't get the answer that matches any options.

The Attempt at a Solution


Substituting I get:
Handwritten notebook working on a control system transfer function: path and loop gain terms with (s/(s+1)), (50s+1), 20/s, Delta = 1 - {loop gains}, leading to a final expression (s^2+s - 20s(50s+1)(10s+1)) over s^2+s.

This gives answer in cube as second term of numerator will go in cube for s. None of options have s cube.Second Question:
Block diagram of two cascaded feedback loops with input R(s) and output C(s); left loop has gain 10 and feedback 1, right loop has gain 5 and feedback 0.5, with answer choices A 5, B 10, C 15, D 50 below.

I think the options are wrong.
For left TF we get C(s)/R(s) = 10/11
For Right we get C(s)/R(s) = 5/3.5
Multiplying them doesn't give the answer
 
Attachments
  • Block diagram of a control system with two summing junctions, blocks G1, G2, H1 and H2, input signals Ra and Rb, output signals CA and CB, followed by four multiple-choice transfer function options (A) to (D).
    upload_2017-12-7_17-15-7.png
    5.5 KB · Views: 1,609
  • Block diagram of two cascaded feedback loops with input R(s) and output C(s); left loop has gain 10 and feedback 1, right loop has gain 5 and feedback 0.5, with answer choices A 5, B 10, C 15, D 50 below.
    upload_2017-12-7_17-24-17.png
    4.3 KB · Views: 764
  • Handwritten working on lined paper showing transfer function derivations using Mason's gain formula, with terms such as G1, G2, H1, H2 and s-domain expressions.
    upload_2017-12-7_17-25-46.png
    34.5 KB · Views: 690
  • Handwritten notebook working on a control system transfer function: path and loop gain terms with (s/(s+1)), (50s+1), 20/s, Delta = 1 - {loop gains}, leading to a final expression (s^2+s - 20s(50s+1)(10s+1)) over s^2+s.
    upload_2017-12-7_17-26-30.png
    56.5 KB · Views: 745
It's been awhile since I've done these, but I got the same result as you, for the second one: C/R = 100/77. I haven't worked through the first one, yet.
 
jaus tail said:
To find Ca / Rb we take Ra = 0 --- is this right?
yes
I got the same thing as you for the second problem.

In problem number one you can dive both the top and bottom side by s...
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jaus tail
Not sure if that helps.
I'm getting: Ca/Rb = -G2 H1 G1 divided by (1 + ( -G2 H1 G1 H2 ) )
And that's not reducing to any of the options.
 
jaus tail said:
Not sure if that helps.
I'm getting: Ca/Rb = -G2 H1 G1 divided by (1 + ( -G2 H1 G1 H2 ) )
And that's not reducing to any of the options.
Sounds like the problem might be "hosed":eek:
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jaus tail
Could be. Even I think the question has some typo.