Correct relation is F^{ij} = - epsilon^{ijk} B^k.

3 replies · 3K views · last reply
Zohaib_aarfi
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
When I tried to derive this relation I got the wrong sign. Please check the pic and tell me my mistakes.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten derivation on lined paper, tracing F^{ij} = ∂^i A^j − ∂^j A^i through epsilon identities to ε^{ijm} B_m, with B_m = ε_{mlk} ∂^l A^k noted at the bottom right.
    20170506_174023.jpg
    23.7 KB · Views: 483
  • Handwritten derivation on lined paper, six lines: F^{ij} = ∂^i A^j − ∂^j A^i, then expanded with Kronecker deltas, then ∂^l ε_{lkm} ε^{ijm} A^k, then ε^{ijm} ε_{lkm} ∂^l A^k, then ε^{ijm} ε_{mlk} ∂^l A^k, ending ε^{ijm} B_m with B_m = ε_{mlk} ∂^l A^k.
    20170506_174023.jpg
    23.7 KB · Views: 507
If you use the west-coast convention you have ##\partial^l=-\partial_l##, and thus
$$B^i=-\epsilon_{ijk} \partial_j A^k.$$
Note that
$$\partial_j=\frac{\partial}{\partial x^j}.$$
 
Thank you for your response. I am using metric [tex]diag(1,-1)[/tex] and the expression you gave [tex]B^i = - \epsilon_{ijk} \partial_j A^k[/tex] contains also [tex]A^i = - A_i[/tex], so I think it does not make any difference. Could you do it for me in complete and explicit steps?