Current density in a wire that is being used to charge a capacitor

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the calculation of current density in a wire charging a capacitor, where the user questions the accuracy of their calculations involving charge and current. It is clarified that the equation I=Q/t is not applicable for instantaneous current, as it only applies to constant current or average values. The user also incorrectly described the wire's dimensions, which should be expressed in terms of cross-sectional area or diameter, not both. They ultimately resolved their confusion by applying derivatives to understand instantaneous rates of change. The conversation emphasizes the importance of precision in calculations and terminology.
Ugnius
Messages
54
Reaction score
10
Homework Statement
Wire, with diameter of 0.7 mm2, is used to charge a capacitor. Charge on the capacitor plate is described as: Q(t):=4*t^3+5*t+3 [C]. What is current density in a wire, at given time t=2s?
Relevant Equations
Q(t):=4*t^3+5*t+3 , j=I/A , I=Q/t
1634575431520.png

Somehow this answer is incorrect , but i realize that even numbers are hipothetical , 45 coulumbs is too much charge , what is wrong in my calculations?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
Q(t) is the total charge on the capacitor, including what has accumulated in the past. The current in the wire is the rate at which new charge is added/removed.
 
  • Like
Likes Ugnius
Okay , but I = Q/t so that's 12.5 A in the wire at the moment t=2, but why isn't the answer correct , is there some kind of a mistake in calculation?
 
As @DaveE pointed out, the current I in the wire at the instant t = 2 s is the instantaneous rate at which charge is flowing through a cross-section of the wire. This must equal the instantaneous rate at which charge is arriving at the plate of the capacitor at t = 2.

How do you calculate the instantaneous rate of change of some function of time?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes Ugnius
Ugnius said:
Homework Statement:: Wire, with diameter of 0.7 mm2,
A diameter could have units of mm, but not mm2.
 
  • Like
Likes Ugnius
Ugnius said:
what is wrong in my calculations?
The equation I=Q/t can’t be used here. This equation applies to situations where current is constant or we only want the average current. T help you understand your mistake, try this problem:

An object moves along a straight line so its distance (x) from a reference point (x=o) is given by:
x(t) = 4t³ + 5t + 3
Q1. What is the object’s average speed during the interval t=0 to t=2s?
Q2. What is the object’s speed at the instant t=2s?
_____________

Also note “Wire, with diameter of 0.7 mm2” doesn’t make sense. You probably mean:
“Wire, with cross-sectional area of of 0.7 mm²” or
“Wire, with diameter of 0.7 mm”
You need to be certain which one it is.

@Edit. @TSny beat me to it!
 
  • Like
Likes Ugnius
Thanks guys , I managed to solve it using derivatives , your help much appreciated.
1634582860819.png
 
  • Like
Likes Steve4Physics, DaveE and TSny
Congratulations, good work!
 
Ugnius said:
Thanks guys , I managed to solve it using derivatives , your help much appreciated.
View attachment 290868
Well done. But don't forget that 0.7mm² and 2s are each specified to only 1 significant figure.
 
Back
Top