Dangers of FTL Space Drives: AIAA/NASA Report Analysis

  • Context: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Thread starter integral_83
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Ftl
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion centers on the analysis of the AIAA/NASA paper regarding hypothetical Faster-Than-Light (FTL) space drives and their potential implications on gravitational dynamics within a solar system. Participants explore the effects of artificial spacetime curvature induced by such drives, specifically questioning whether this would generate significant gravitational waves capable of altering planetary orbits. The conversation highlights the distinction between minor disturbances, akin to ripples on a pond, versus substantial gravitational impacts, suggesting that while the theoretical models are intriguing, the practical effects may be negligible over vast distances.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of general relativity
  • Familiarity with differential geometry
  • Knowledge of gravitational wave propagation
  • Basic concepts of the N-Body problem in physics
NEXT STEPS
  • Research the Alcubierre warp drive theory and its implications on spacetime
  • Study gravitational wave detection methods and their limitations
  • Explore numerical modeling techniques for N-Body gravitational dynamics
  • Investigate the effects of spacetime curvature on planetary orbits
USEFUL FOR

Aerospace engineers, physicists, and researchers interested in theoretical physics, particularly those exploring the implications of advanced propulsion systems and gravitational dynamics.

integral_83
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
For kicks, I have been reading the following AIAA/NASA paper on hypothetical space drives:

http://www.grc.nasa.gov/WWW/bpp/1997-J_AIAA_SpaceDr.pdf

Now, I have to admit that I only have a cursory understanding of general relativity & differential geometry.

But assume for a moment the unlikely possibility that one or more of these concepts is feasible and engineer-able. Imagine that such a drive was activated within our solar system, with an extra-solar destination. Given the sharp instantaneous S-T curvature implied by these designs and the instability of the N-Body (N>2) problem, wouldn't such a technology pose a serious threat to an inhabited system?

Specifically, wouldn't the artificial curvature induce changes in the Christoffel symbols in S-T; ultimately propagating outward as a gravitational wavefront as S-T returned to it's original shape? If so, would it seem likely that these field gradients might stabilize a gravitational system?

Thanks in advance for everyone's time/help/explanations/corrections!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Unless I'm mistaken, you're asking if a hypothetical FTL drive would create gravity waves. And would they be big enough to affect planetary orbits.

Of course, this is all fantasy, but...

Just because they create waves that ripple across the solar sytem, doesn't mean it will destabilize anything.

To resort to the waves-on-a-pond analogy, you're imagining the drive creating a whirlpool funnel in the lake big enough to alter the courses of vessels, I'm imagining it would merely make ripples on the surface.
 
Yep; that's what I was asking. I imagine that you may be right; but given the magnitude of the disturbance needed to warp space in the needed way, it just seems intuitive that the ancillary effects of a warp field would be non-negligible.

The analogy that I guess put this in my mind was propagation of waves from shocks in fluid dynamics. Of course, I don't imagine that S-T is completely analogous to a fluid continuum, but I can't help but think that gravitational waves would emanate from a shock in an exponentially decreasing manner with respect to distance (although I am not sure if that's the conventional model). In this way, gravitational waves would carry very large amounts of momentum close to the warp bubble, but would be minuscule over stellar distances (and thus hard to detect). As I understand it, this is similar to how interaction between black holes are conceptually modeled.

I wonder if anyone has tried to numerically model the theoretical local effects of an alcubierre warp event (with all hypothetical hand-waving assumptions of practicality and energy requirements allowed) on the gravitational dynamics of, say, a 2 or 3 body problem.

Anyways, I appreciate the input, given how contrived the question really is to begin with! :)
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K