1. Limited time only! Sign up for a free 30min personal tutor trial with Chegg Tutors
    Dismiss Notice
Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Homework Help: Derivative and Integral question

  1. Dec 16, 2007 #1
    I have two problem relating to integrals and derivatives.

    Integrals: I can do but I am confused about the limit
    Derivative: I am having problem. Need some help with that. I have a solution but I think it is wrong.

    For each problem I have posted step by step what I am doing. Hopefully it will be easier in answering.

    Problem 1: Integral

    What is [tex]\int e ^{-t}[/tex] (limit is from 0 (on bottom) to 1 (on top))

    Problem 1: My solution

    My issue is step 6

    1. Take u = -t
    2. Use Chain Rule: dy/dx = (dy/du)(du/dx)
    3. du/dt = -1. Therefor -du = dt
    4. Find limits:
    For t=1: u= -1
    For t=0: u= 0
    5. New integral becomes (-1) [tex]\int e ^{u} du [/tex].
    6. My question/issue is about the new limits:
    Do I have to evaluate the integral with u=-1 on bottom of integral and u=0 on top of integral or the other way.

    Problem 2 Statement:

    y= [tex]x^{x^x}[/tex]. Find the minimum of y.

    Problem 2 Solution
    I am not really sure that I am doing this right. So plz advise

    I know how to find the derivative of [tex] x^x [/tex].

    So here are my steps

    1. make a = [tex] x^x [/tex] (I am taking the first two x's)
    2. Therefore y = [tex] a^x [/tex]
    3. dy/dx = (dy/da)(da/dx)
    4. Find dy/da:
    y = [tex] a^x [/tex] ​
    = [tex] e^{xlna} [/tex] ​
    dy/da = [tex] a^x [/tex] d(xlna)/da = [tex] (a^x) [/tex] [tex] x^{1-x} [/tex] ​
    5. Find da/dx
    a = [tex] x^x [/tex] = [tex] e^{xlnx} [/tex]​
    By productrule da/dx = [tex] x^x[/tex] (ln x + 1)​

    6. Multiple from step 4,5 and equate to 0.

    My question is: is step 4 right? Actually now that I am looking at it, I am wondering if step 5 is right also. Plz advise on this.


  2. jcsd
  3. Dec 16, 2007 #2


    User Avatar
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper

    For the first problem: you have taken u = -t. Plugging in the lower boundary for t gives you the new lower boundary for u (and similarly for the upper). So the new integral runs from u = -0 below to u = -1 above. You are allowed to interchange the boundary values though, as long as you put in a minus sign, that is:
    [tex]\int_a^b f(x) dx = - \int_b^a f(x) dx[/tex]
    In this case, it will cancel the minus you get from the substitution du -> -dt.
  4. Dec 16, 2007 #3


    User Avatar
    Gold Member

    In your first problem, the limits were from t=0 to t=1

    When you substituted for u, and integrated with respect to du, you're limits were still t=o and t=1, if you were to swap these to be from t=1 to t=0 zero you would have to put a minus sign before the entire integral.
    remember [tex] \int_{a}^{b}f(x)dx=-\int_{b}^{a}f(x)dx[/tex]

    So you cannot put u=-1 on the bottom without altering the sign of the integral, because you cannot put t=1 on the bottom without changin sign.

    //Ah I see, compuchip already said this:smile:

    For part 2, you could save yourself a lot of hassle by just letting

    [tex] y=x^{x^x} =y=x^{x^2}[/tex] ;)
    Last edited: Dec 16, 2007
  5. Dec 16, 2007 #4
    Problem 1:
    You should evaluate your "new" integral between the "old" limits, expressed in terms of the "new" variable u.
    For example: the limit t=0 becomes u(0) = -0 = 0.
    The limit t=1 becomes u(1) = -1.

    Problem 2:
    The chain rule works on functions of functions. In your case, you took y=a^x, while you should've taken y=x^a (i.e. the ARGUMENT of the function should be a). The final result should have more lns in it ;).

    Last edited by a moderator: Apr 23, 2017
  6. Dec 18, 2007 #5
    I came back to this derivative question after some time. Thanks for the response on integrals

    So the problem statement was to find the minimum of [tex] x^{x^x} [/tex]

    Problem solution

    As ozymandis said I was taking the wrong approach to find derivative. Here is the proper approach.

    [tex] x^{x^x} [/tex] = [tex] e^{e^{xlnx} ln x} [/tex]

    Step2: take derivative of above equation on right hand side

    y' = [tex] x^{x^x} [/tex] * derivative of ([tex] e^{e^{xlnx} ln x} [/tex])

    = [tex] x^{x^x} [/tex] * ( [tex] (x^x /x) [/tex] + ln x [tex] (x^x)' [/tex] )

    = [tex] x^{x^x} [/tex] * ( [tex] (x^x /x) [/tex] + ln x ([tex] x^x [/tex] )(ln x + 1) ) --- eq1

    Step3: Set eq 1 to 0 to find min

    [tex] x^{x^x} [/tex] * ( [tex] (x^x /x) [/tex] + ln x ([tex] x^x [/tex] )(ln x + 1) ) = 0

    I can simplify this to

    lnx (lnx + 1) + 1/x = 0 -----eq2


    1- How the heck do I evaluate this eq2. I ran this on matlab and the minimum value I get for x = 1. I never get to 0. Have I calculated the derivative properly.

    2. I ran the x^x^x on matlab and came up with a val of 0.832 so thats the value I should come up with once I evaluate eq2 but I cannot get past above problem.

    What am I doing wrong?


  7. Dec 19, 2007 #6
    Hi Asif,

    Take q = ln(x), then solve the quadratic equation.
    Edit: whoops, just saw the 1/x. :)
    I don't believe this equation can be solved symbolically.
    Edit 2: I just re-differentiated, your result still seems in error.
    [tex]y(x) = x^{x^x} = x^a[/tex] where [tex]a=x^x[/tex] and use the chain rule.

    Last edited by a moderator: Apr 23, 2017
  8. Dec 19, 2007 #7
    Hi Ozymandias:

    Seems I am doing something wrong.
    Actually I tried your method of replacing a=[tex] x^x[/tex] and I still got the same equation that I had before - namely the 1/x component.

    Here are the steps - I cannot figure out what I am doing wrong.

    y = [tex] x^a [/tex] = [tex] exp ^{alnx} [/tex] where a = [tex]x^x[/tex] = [tex] exp ^{xlnx} [/tex]

    y' = [tex]x^{x^x} [/tex] (a'lnx + a/x) <--- 2nd component from chain rule. As you can see I still get the 1/x component.

    a' = [tex] x^{x^x}[/tex] (1+ lnx)

    Substituting from step3 into step2
    y' = [tex]x^{x^x} [/tex] ( [tex] x^x[/tex] lnx (lnx + 1) + ([tex]x^x [/tex])/x )
    = ([tex]x^{x^x} [/tex])([tex] x^x[/tex]) ( 1/x + lnx(lnx+1) )

    Step5:To find min
    0 = [/tex])([tex] x^x[/tex]) ( 1/x + lnx(lnx+1) )

    Which is where I was. So obviously I am doing something wrong. Step2. I have re-read the text book and I think I have understood it properly. I did the other problems and got the right ans.

    This is driving me crazy.


Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook