Derive the expression for the work done by the friction force

17 replies · 4K views · last reply
Alexanddros81
Messages
177
Reaction score
4

Homework Statement


14.6 The coefficient of kinetic friction between the slider and the rod is μ, and the
free length of the spring is ##L_0 = b##. Derive the expression for the work done by
the friction force on the slider as it moves from A to B. Neglect the weight of the slider.

Diagram of a slider on a horizontal rod between points A and B, attached to a spring that runs diagonally down to a pivot below; labelled b for the horizontal span and b for the vertical height, with the spring labelled k. Fig. P14.5, P14.6.


Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution



Handwritten solution to problem 14.6 on lined paper: states kinetic friction coefficient μ and spring free length L0 = b, applies work-energy from A to B, giving F_k·b = -½k(δB² - δA²).

I[/B] am going the right direction with my solution?
I don't see to be getting the ##-0.1186μkb^2## solution.
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a slider on a horizontal rod between points A and B, attached to a spring that runs diagonally down to a pivot below; labelled b for the horizontal span and b for the vertical height, with the spring labelled k. Fig. P14.5, P14.6.
    Fig P14_5_6.png
    6.1 KB · Views: 832
  • Handwritten solution to problem 14.6 on lined paper: states kinetic friction coefficient μ and spring free length L0 = b, applies work-energy from A to B, giving F_k·b = -½k(δB² - δA²).
    Pytels_Dynamics101.jpg
    13 KB · Views: 1,226
##\mu## stands for the ratio of the friction force and some normal force. What's that normal force as a function of position ?

Pity you don't give any relevant equations. I don't think the exercise wants you to look at the velocities.
 
Handwritten derivation: a sketch of a block on a horizontal rod between points A and B with a spring at angle phi, a free-body diagram showing FK, NA and P, then the work of friction equations u(A-B) = -FK.x = -FK.b, FK = mu.NA, NA = P cos phi, and u(A-B) = -mu.K.x cos phi.b.

Am going the right direction with the above calculation?
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten derivation: a sketch of a block on a horizontal rod between points A and B with a spring at angle phi, a free-body diagram showing FK, NA and P, then the work of friction equations u(A-B) = -FK.x = -FK.b, FK = mu.NA, NA = P cos phi, and u(A-B) = -mu.K.x cos phi.b.
    Pytels_Dynamics103.jpg
    17.2 KB · Views: 1,943
Alexanddros81 said:
View attachment 215969
Am going the right direction with the above calculation?
It is preferred that you type in your algebra. This makes it easier to comment on specific lines. Or you could number the equations.
Your FBD omits the force dragging the slider from A to B. You should take acceleration to be negligible. This invalidates your force balance equation for the x direction.
The NA=P cos(φ) equation is the useful one, but you need to find P as a function of φ and integrate.
 
Handwritten sketch of a horizontal bar fixed at both ends, with a block on it, a spring-like coil hanging from the block, and dashed lines to a pivot point below. Right side shows a free-body diagram of the block with forces N_A, F, F_k and P.


haruspex said:
Your FBD omits the force dragging the slider from A to B. You should take acceleration to be negligible. This invalidates your force balance equation for the x direction.
For the x direction:
##ΣFx=0 => F-F_k=0 => F=F_k## (1)

For the y direction:
##ΣFy=0 => N_A-Pcosφ=0 => N_A=Pcos(φ)## (2)

haruspex said:
The NA=P cos(φ) equation is the useful one, but you need to find P as a function of φ and integrate

How do I do that? I am a bit confused...
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten sketch of a horizontal bar fixed at both ends, with a block on it, a spring-like coil hanging from the block, and dashed lines to a pivot point below. Right side shows a free-body diagram of the block with forces N_A, F, F_k and P.
    upload_2017-12-4_22-3-44.png
    9 KB · Views: 708
How would you calculate ##P## at point B ?
 
Last edited:
Alexanddros81 said:
How do I do that? I am a bit confused...
It's the tension in a spring. What determines the value of that?
 
BvU said:
How would you calculate PPP at point B ?

P at point B be should be ## -kx## where x is the elongation of the spring.

##x = L_B-L_0 = \sqrt {b^2+b^2} - b = 0.414b##

So P = -0.414kb

Am I correct? (it is the second problem with springs ever i am trying to solve )
 
Alexanddros81 said:
P at point B be should be ## -kx## where x is the elongation of the spring.

##x = L_B-L_0 = \sqrt {b^2+b^2} - b = 0.414b##

So P = -0.414kb

Am I correct? (it is the second problem with springs ever i am trying to solve )

I think the problem is a lot more complicated than that. First, you need an expression for the length of the spring as a function of the distance from A to B.
 
PeroK said:
I think the problem is a lot more complicated than that. First, you need an expression for the length of the spring as a function of the distance from A to B.

So to do that I split the distance between A and B to 3 sections. from 0 to 1/3 of b, from 1/3b to 2/3b, and from 2/3b to b.

At 1/3b ##sinφ = \frac {1b/3} {l} => sinφ = \frac {1b/3} {1.054b} = 0.316## (where ##l = b + L_{1/3b} - L_0##)

At 2/3b ##sinφ = 0.55##
At 3/3b ##sinφ = 0.707## that verifies that when collar is at position B the angle φ is 45 degrees.

So from above we can say that ##l = L_{AB} = \sqrt {b^2+(xb)^2}## where x is between 0 and 1
 
Alexanddros81 said:
So from above we can say that ##l = L_{AB} = \sqrt {b^2+(xb)^2}## where x is between 0 and 1

Well, I'd say just use good old Pythagoras:

##L = \sqrt{x^2 + b^2}##, where ##0 \le x \le b##

Now you need to analyse the forces at each point ##x## between ##A## and ##B##.
 
Alexanddros81 said:
So to do that I split the distance between A and B to 3 sections. from 0 to 1/3 of b, from 1/3b to 2/3b, and from 2/3b to b.

At 1/3b ##sinφ = \frac {1b/3} {l} => sinφ = \frac {1b/3} {1.054b} = 0.316## (where ##l = b + L_{1/3b} - L_0##)

At 2/3b ##sinφ = 0.55##
At 3/3b ##sinφ = 0.707## that verifies that when collar is at position B the angle φ is 45 degrees.

So from above we can say that ##l = L_{AB} = \sqrt {b^2+(xb)^2}## where x is between 0 and 1
Remember the last line in #4: You need ##P## as a function of ##\phi##. I think you do fine for ##\phi## at specific values, but you need a function for all ##\phi## in ##[0,\pi/4]##
 
PeroK said:
Now you need to analyse the forces at each point x between A and B

Well using Inkscape, FBD is:

Free-body diagram of a box with axes x and y, showing normal force N_A up, weight P pointing down-left at angle φ from the vertical with components P_x left and P_y down, applied force F to the right, and kinetic friction F_k to the left.


in y-axis ##N_A = P_y => N_A = Pcos(φ)##

in x-axis ##-F_k - P_x < F## (Is this correct?)

BvU said:
Remember the last line in #4: You need P as a function of ϕ. I think you do fine for ϕ at specific values, but you need a function for all ϕ in [0,π/4]

##P=Pcos(φ) ## (Is this correct?)
 
Attachments
  • Free-body diagram of a box with axes x and y, showing normal force N_A up, weight P pointing down-left at angle φ from the vertical with components P_x left and P_y down, applied force F to the right, and kinetic friction F_k to the left.
    FBD P14_6.jpg
    10.6 KB · Views: 616
##\ P_y = P \cos\phi## is right. Both factors change during the trip. So fill in something for ##P##: a function of ##\phi##.
 
BvU said:
Py=Pcosϕ is right. Both factors change during the trip. So fill in something for P: a function of ϕ
The only thing i understand is that ##P = -kl##
I can see that as the angle increases so does P. So P∝φ

should it be P related to ##1/cos(φ) ? If angle is 0deg the 1/cos(φ) is 1; Then as angle increases so does 1/cos(φ);
 
Write it out in full so you have something that you can integrate from ##\phi=0## to ##\phi = \pi/2##...
To help you: ##k## is given. Now you need ##l(\phi)## -- you did it already, see above
 
BvU said:
To help you: k is given. Now you need l(ϕ) -- you did it already, see above
Hi. When you say "see above" which post you are referring to?
thanks
 
Alexanddros81 said:
Hi. When you say "see above" which post you are referring to?
thanks
Post #10, but you would do better to use PeroK's simplification in post #11. It will be more convenient to have x as the distance along the bar from A, so x ranges from 0 to b.