Determine the probability of ##P(x>4)##

  • Thread starter Thread starter chwala
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Probability
Click For Summary
The discussion focuses on calculating the probability P(x>4) using integrals and geometric interpretations. Participants clarify the correct approach to evaluate the integral and emphasize avoiding decimals in probability calculations, suggesting rational expressions instead. They discuss breaking the area under the graph into simpler shapes, like triangles and rectangles, to facilitate easier calculations. The final consensus is that P(x>4) can be derived from the complementary probability P(x≤4) using straightforward geometric reasoning. The conversation concludes with an acknowledgment of the clarity gained regarding the relationship between parts (b) and (c) of the problem.
chwala
Gold Member
Messages
2,827
Reaction score
415
Homework Statement
see attached
Relevant Equations
Knowledge of distributions
1649156003777.png


Find the solution here;

1649156029036.png


Ok my interest is on part (b) and (c) only. Let's start with (b),
My take is,
$$\int_4^5 \dfrac{2}{75}x\,dx=\left.[\frac{x^2}{75}]\right|_4^5$$
$$=(0.33333333-0.21333333)+\frac{2}{15}×5$$
$$=0.12+0.6666666666=0.78666666$$
note that at ##f(x)##=##\dfrac{2}{15}##, the probability value will be the area subtended by values of ##x## from ##x=5## to ##10## hence ##10-5=5##...in short, probability ##P(x>4)## at this point will be the area subtended by the straight line within the given domain ##5<x≤10##.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
You are confusing the reader with all those decimals. The general rule is
<br /> \mathbb P(X\leqslant a) = \int _{-\infty}^a f(t)\mathrm{d}t,<br />
if ##X## has a probability density ##f##. For b) apply what you know about the probabilities of an event and its opposite event.

If you are looking for feedback, explain your thought process that leads you to a certain computation. The probability you are looking for in c) is that at least one battery fails within the next ##40## hours, because both batteries are required for the device to work.
 
  • Like
Likes chwala
nuuskur said:
You are confusing the reader with all those decimals.
Yes, you should not use decimals in a problem like this; express your answer as a rational number. And look up the meaning of the word "subtend", it has nothing to do with area.

As to method: you have correctly worked out ## P(x>4) ## by evaluating an integral at 2 points and adding on an area of a rectangle. Can you think of a way to arrive at the same answer simply by calculating the area of a triangle? (Perhaps it would have been better not to ignore part (a).)
 
pbuk said:
Yes, you should not use decimals in a problem like this; express your answer as a rational number. And look up the meaning of the word "subtend", it has nothing to do with area.

As to method: you have correctly worked out ## P(x>4) ## by evaluating an integral at 2 points and adding on an area of a rectangle. Can you think of a way to arrive at the same answer simply by calculating the area of a triangle? (Perhaps it would have been better not to ignore part (a).)
Ok I will look at that...I had already seen how the graph looks like in part (a)...we have a right angle triangle and a rectangle...noted on 'subtended'...
 
chwala said:
Ok I will look at that...I had already seen how the graph looks like in part (a)...we have a right angle triangle and a rectangle...noted on 'subtended'...
OK, so if you divide the area under the graph into two pieces by drawing a vertical line at ## x = 4 ##, you have a triangle with a known base and a height which can be calculated with a trivial substitution. You also have an irregular pentagon. For which piece is it easier to calculate the area?
 
  • Like
Likes chwala
Thanks @pbuk ...kindly let me look at this later...when I am through with other tasks...
 
Ok we shall have,
##\left[(\dfrac{1}{2}×5×\dfrac{2}{15})-(\dfrac{1}{2}×4×\dfrac{8}{75})\right]+5×\dfrac{2}{15}=\dfrac{59}{75}##
 
chwala said:
Ok we shall have,
##\left[(\dfrac{1}{2}×5×\dfrac{2}{15})-(\dfrac{1}{2}×4×\dfrac{8}{75})\right]+5×\dfrac{2}{15}=\dfrac{59}{75}##
You are still over-complicating this, you should be able to see on inspection that
## P(x \gt 4) = 1 - P(x \le 4) = 1 - \dfrac{1}{2}×4×\dfrac{8}{75} = \dfrac{59}{75}##.
 
pbuk said:
You are still over-complicating this, you should be able to see on inspection that
## P(x \gt 4) = 1 - P(x \le 4) = 1 - \dfrac{1}{2}×4×\dfrac{8}{75} = \dfrac{59}{75}##.
Thanks mate.
 
  • #10
Find the solution below from the Markscheme.

Now for part (c), i was not understanding how they came up with using part (b) to realize the solution i.e

1649328188537.png


...then i realized from the question itself indicate...in tens of hours... implying in our case, ##4## × tens of hours = ##40## hours. The steps to final solution is very much clear to me. Cheers guys.
 

Similar threads