1. Limited time only! Sign up for a free 30min personal tutor trial with Chegg Tutors
    Dismiss Notice
Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Dimensional Analysis - Comparison of exponents

  1. Jan 5, 2009 #1
    I have been reading a paper which introduced classical mechanics concerning only one dimension. Before we get into anything about displacement and velocity, I read about dimensional analysis.

    There is a section of the paper which isn't very well explained and I hope someone can explain it to me, so that I can continue reading.

    "A film company wants to shoot the leaning tower of pisa falling. They have built a model tower. They cannot just let it drop otherwise it would look too unrealistic. Therefore they need to slow the video down so it looks more realistic by a factor t. This factor depends on mass of tower,m, the height of the tower,h, and acceleration due to gravity, g. In other words...

    t = C m^x h^y g^z
    Where C is a dimensionless constant.

    The dimensions =

    [T] = [M]^x [L]^y ([L]/[T-squared])^z

    We can now compare the exponents of [L], [M] and [T].

    0 = y + z
    0 = x
    1 = -2z


    While I understand what the author is attempting to do, I do not understand how we gain the above equations, and hence the following.

    x = 0
    y = 0.5
    z = -0.5

    t = C (sqrt) h/g

    Thank you in advance.

    ps - I want to understand fully how we compare the exponents, get three equations and the formula.
     
  2. jcsd
  3. Jan 5, 2009 #2
    I think what it's explaining is that the factor t is multiplied by the speed of fall, to slow it down.

    M=mass
    L=lenght
    T=time

    Therefore your end units of t*v (where v is you speed) should be units of v. Speed is distance divided by time, so it's dimensional units are L1 T-1. I assume that you understand that this is the same as writing Lenght / Time ;).

    Hence:

    t*v=v

    so;

    C Mx Ly gz * L1 T-1 = L1 T-1

    Now g is not in fundamental units it's Newtons per Kilogram, but Newtons are Kilograms-Meters per second per second. So;

    g => M1 L1 T-2 / M1

    g => M1 L1 T-2 M-1

    So

    g = L1 T-2

    Ok knowing that;


    C Mx Ly (L1 T-2)z * L1 T-1 = L1 T-1

    We can ignore C because it's not got a dimension and consider this as a set of equations. So basically we are going to count up the powers for each of the dimensions on each side of the equation. So for M, then L, then T; we have;


    C Mx Ly (L1 T-2)z * L1 T-1 = L1 T-1

    C Mx Ly (L1 T-2)z * L1 T-1 = L1 T-1

    C Mx Ly (L1 T-2)z * L1 T-1 = L1 T-1

    (1) x = 0
    (2) y+z+1 = 1
    (3) -2z+-1=-1

    Equation 1, tells us that this factor t doesn't depend on the mass at all. Which should make sense as a tonne of feathers and a ton of iron fall at the same rate. 2 and 3 can be rewritten;

    (2) y+z=0
    (3) -2z=0

    Errm different to what the last one is, but let's continue anyhow. These are a set of simultaneous equations, these we can solve as -2z=0, implies that z needs to be 0, but that would imply that y also equals zero, so somewhere in my adding up of the powers I've gone wrong. Ok using;

    (3) -2z=1

    We can see that z must be -1/2 because -2*-1/2 = 1 As we know y+z=0 and y+-1/2=0 so y=1/2

    Going back to;

    C Mx Ly (L1 T-2)z

    We put our values of x,y and z into the powers to find out what our constant is. Like;

    C M0 L1/2 (L1 T-2)-1/2

    Hence;

    t = C sqrt{h/g}

    As the power of 1/2 is the same as a square root.

    As for the problem with equation 3, it might be because t is not a scale factor for the speed, but rather the acceleration of the tower. So it would actually be;

    t*a=v

    C Mx Ly (L1 T-2)z * L1 T-2 = L1 T-1

    Which would give; -2z-2=-1 which is -2z=1 so it's a scale factor for the acceleration of the tower. So the formula for the velocity of the tower would be;

    C sqrt{h/g}*a = v

    I think...
    Haths
     
  4. Jan 5, 2009 #3
    Here's a different take on the problem statement, which I think could be worded better.

    To my reading, it sounds like we want to make the tower take time t to fall (note that it is given dimensions of time (T) later on). That is, t itself is not the scale factor, but the desired scaled time.

    Per the problem, we suppose it can depend in as-yet-unknown ways on the mass of the tower m, its height h, g, and an arbitrary dimensionless constant C. Turning that last sentence into an equation just gives
    t = C mx hy gz,​
    where x, y and z are constant exponents we want to determine.

    Dimensional analysis makes this easy: t has dimensions of time (T), so we demand that C mx hy gz have dimensions of time as well. Since m has dimensions of mass (M), h has dimensions of length (L), g has dimensions of length per time-squared (L/T2 = LT-2), and C has no dimensions at all, we have
    T = Mx Ly (LT-2)z = Mx L(y + z)T(-2z).​

    Now all we have to do is match the exponent of each dimension on each side of the equation. Writing everything out explicitly,
    M0 L0 T1 = Mx L(y + z)T(-2z).​
    Separately matching the exponents of M, L, and T on each side of the equation immediately gives the three equations
    0 = x
    0 = y + z
    1 = -2z,​
    which have the solution
    x = 0
    z = -1 / 2
    y = 1 / 2.​
    Plugging x, y and z back into the original formula, we have
    t = C m0 h1/2 g-1/2 = C(h / g)1/2,
    [tex]t = C\sqrt{h / g}.[/tex]​
    And that's all there is to it.
     
  5. Jan 6, 2009 #4
    Excellent. Both of your replies helped me to understand things better. Any confusions/doubts were gotten rid off when I read daschaich's reply.

    Thank you.
     
Know someone interested in this topic? Share this thread via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook




Similar Discussions: Dimensional Analysis - Comparison of exponents
Loading...