Diode Analysis and Thevenins Theorem

15 replies · 4K views · last reply
CoolDude420
Messages
199
Reaction score
9

Homework Statement


Circuit schematic with a 2 V source feeding resistors of 1 kΩ, 500 Ω and 1 kΩ, a diode in series near the output, and output voltage v_o marked across a final 1 kΩ resistor.

Printed text reading: Find v_o, modelling the diode by an ideal diode


Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


Handwritten notes on lined paper working out Thevenin equivalent resistance and voltage for a circuit with resistors of 1k and 500 ohms and a diode, including a 1V source and a 1k ohm load with a diode in series.

Handwritten notes on lined paper showing a Thevenin equivalent circuit with a 0.667V source, a 1k resistor, a diode and a 1k load resistor labelled Vo, followed by a KVL derivation giving i0 = 3.335x10^-4 A and Vo = 0.3335V, marked wrong against a correct answer of 0.25V.


The correct answer is 0.25V. I'm getting 0.3335V[/B]
 
gneill said:
Check your Thevenin voltage derivation.
Handwritten working on lined paper titled Thevenin Voltage Vth, showing a circuit with a 2V source, resistors, a diode and a V0 node, then the open-circuit load-terminal step, with voltage division giving V2 = 1V and Vth = 0.6666667 V.


I tried it again, same answer.
 
Still incorrect. You're mucking up after the first stage when you apply the voltage division with the 500 Ohm resistor. Take the circuit one stage at a time:
Circuit schematic of a ladder network with a 2 V source, 1 kΩ and 500 Ω series resistors, 1 kΩ shunt resistors, and a diode feeding a load labeled vo, with blue cut lines numbered 1 and 2.


First break the circuit at (1) and find the Thevenin equivalent. What do you find?
 
gneill said:
Still incorrect. You're mucking up after the first stage when you apply the voltage division with the 500 Ohm resistor. Take the circuit one stage at a time:
View attachment 114680

First break the circuit at (1) and find the Thevenin equivalent. What do you find?
Handwritten circuit on lined paper: a 2 V battery in series with two 1k resistors in a loop, with an arrow pointing to a simplified circuit with the 2 V battery and a single 2k resistor labelled 2kΩ.
 
No. There are three resistors involved and you haven't dealt with the voltage divider. A Thevenin model consists of a voltage source with a series resistance and does not form a closed loop!
 
gneill said:
No. There are three resistors involved and you haven't dealt with the voltage divider. A Thevenin model consists of a voltage source with a series resistance and does not form a closed loop!
Hand-drawn circuit schematic in blue ink on lined paper: a 2V battery in series with a resistor labelled 2k, with terminals at the ends of the wire loop.


my apologies, is this fine
 
No. How do you arrive at 2 kΩ? How come the original 2 V hasn't been divided by the voltage divider consisting of the two 1 kΩ resistors? This is the circuit that you are starting with for this first part:

Circuit schematic: a 2 V battery on the left feeds a 1 kΩ resistor in series, then a node with a 1 kΩ resistor down to the bottom rail and a 500 Ω resistor to terminal a; terminal b is on the bottom rail.


Apply the procedure to find its Thevenin equivalent.
 
gneill said:
No. How do you arrive at 2 kΩ? How come the original 2 V hasn't been divided by the voltage divider consisting of the two 1 kΩ resistors? This is the circuit that you are starting with for this first part:

View attachment 114681

Apply the procedure to find its Thevenin equivalent.
Handwritten notes on lined paper working out a Thevenin equivalent: a circuit with a 2V source, a 1k resistor and a 1k resistor, then steps for zero sources and short-circuit output, R_Th = (1000)(1000)/(1000+1000) = 500 ohms, open-circuit output giving V_Th = 1V, and the final Thevenin equivalent of a 1V source in series with 1k ohm.
 
Right!

Now tack on the next stage and repeat:

Circuit schematic: 1 V battery with a 1 kΩ resistor to node a, a 1 kΩ resistor from node a down to node b, a 500 Ω resistor from node a to terminal 2, with a dashed diode and 1 kΩ resistor branch across terminal 2 and the lower terminal.

What's the Thevenin equivalent for the terminals at (2)?
 
gneill said:
Right!

Now tack on the next stage and repeat:

View attachment 114682
What's the Thevenin equivalent for the terminals at (2)?

Ah. I seem to have gotten it now. Thank you, not entirely sure why my method that I did initially to find Vth is wrong.
 
CoolDude420 said:
Ah. I seem to have gotten it now. Thank you, not entirely sure why my method that I did initially to find Vth is wrong.
Great.

You were doing something strange with 1.5 kΩ that I couldn't see the reasoning behind. It's best to either break the circuit up into discrete stages and proceed methodically, or apply something like mesh or nodal analysis when you want to do it all at once.
 
gneill said:
Great.

You were doing something strange with 1.5 kΩ that I couldn't see the reasoning behind. It's best to either break the circuit up into discrete stages and proceed methodically, or apply something like mesh or nodal analysis when you want to do it all at once.

Handwritten circuit analysis notes for Thevenin voltage: a 2V source, 1k and 500 ohm resistors, node V1 = 1V, a 1000/2000 divider, and the result Vth = 0.6667 V across terminals A and B.


Okay, I've written in detail to what my approach was. I have a feeling that I'm neglecting that extension of A-B at the right and assuming no current flows? But isn't that what I'm meant to do. I mean Vth is the open circuit voltage?
 
I think I see my mistake. I'm applying voltage division even though the current through the resistors is different.
 
CoolDude420 said:
Okay, I've written in detail to what my approach was. I have a feeling that I'm neglecting that extension of A-B at the right and assuming no current flows? But isn't that what I'm meant to do. I mean Vth is the open circuit voltage?
The problem is that you started finding the Thevenin equivalent for the first section of the circuit and did not complete the operation before you applied the partial result to the next section. Your paragraph labelled (2) assumed that the 1 V first Thevenin voltage would be expressed across the first vertical 1 k resistor and hence would be applied to the following section's voltage divider consisting of the 500 Ω resistor and 1k Ω resistor. That was an error. The 1 V should be behind a 1 kΩ series resistor (the Thevenin resistance of the first stage) that includes the 500 Ω resistor.
 
gneill said:
The problem is that you started finding the Thevenin equivalent for the first section of the circuit and did not complete the operation before you applied the partial result to the next section. Your paragraph labelled (2) assumed that the 1 V first Thevenin voltage would be expressed across the first vertical 1 k resistor and hence would be applied to the following section's voltage divider consisting of the 500 Ω resistor and 1k Ω resistor. That was an error. The 1 V should be behind a 1 kΩ series resistor (the Thevenin resistance of the first stage) that includes the 500 Ω resistor.
Thanks!