Direction of normal reactions on a beam

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
1 reply · 2K views
arestes
Messages
84
Reaction score
4

Homework Statement


Problem 10.36 The bar has cross-sectional areaAand
modulus of elasticity E. If an axial force F directed toward
the right is applied atC, what is the normal stress in
the part of the bar to the left ofC? (Strategy: Drawthe
free-body diagram of the entire bar and write the equilibrium
equation. Then apply the compatibility condition
that the increase in length of the part of the bar to the left
of C must equal the decrease in length of the part to the
right of C.) SEE ATTACHED PDF

Homework Equations


sum of forces =0
Young's modulus definition for compatibility of deformations

The Attempt at a Solution


Solution is already in the pdf, I just don't understand why the reactions (normal forces) on the bar are both to the left. Normals are supposed to go towards the body. However, if I were to take the left reaction force going to the right (where I think it should point) the solution would be negative. Same happens with other lecture notes (page 6 here http://www.yamnuska.ca/student/smtl/notes/StaticIndetermW06.pdf ) . What am I doing wrong?
 

Attachments

Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
These forces are reactions. It's not clear why you are calling reactions 'normal forces'.
It is not made very clear in the problem statement, but the bar must be built in or fixed at each end.
With the axial force applied at point C, if one were to make a cut in the bar just to the right of C and draw the resulting FBD, then it is clear that the reaction at the left end of the bar must be in the opposite direction to the axial force at C. Similarly, if a cut is made in bar to the left of C, then drawing the FBD will show that the reaction at the right end of the bar must also point to the left, in order for equilibrium to exist.