Do Lorentz Transformations Affect Simultaneity in Different Frames?

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
1 reply · 2K views
DarkMalice
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Anyone help. I know I must be doing this wrong somehow

Lightning hits both a tree and a pole. The spacetime coordinates for each is (x=0, t=10us) for the tree and (x=30000m, t=10us) for the pole relative to the ground. Therefore they occur simultaneously relative to the ground. A rocket comes whizzing by at 0.5c in the x-direction. Find the spacetime coordinates relative to the rocket. Do the events happen simultaneously in the rocket's frame? (us is microseconds by the way)


First and foremost, I was able to find the factor y as y= 1/(1-.05^2)^.5 = 1.1547

Using Lorentz transformations
For the tree
x'= 1.1547 X [0 -(0.5c)(10us)]
= -1732.05m

t'=1.1547 X [10us -(0.5c)(0)/c^2]
= 11.547us

For the pole
x'= 1.1547 X [30000-(0.5c)(10us)]
= 32908.95

t'= 1.1547 X [10us - (0.5c)(30000)/c^2]
=-46.18us


What I want to know is why is x'(pole)-x'(tree)> 30000? Shouldn't the distance between both poles go through length contraction in the rocket's frame and therefore be shorter than 30000?

Please someone help
 
Physics news on Phys.org
You're comparing the location of the tree and the location of the pole at different times in the rocket's frame. To find the distance between the two, you need to compare where they are at the same time.