Does a Variable capacitance switch exist?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the feasibility of creating a variable capacitance switch for a circuit, with a focus on the ability to adjust capacitance values, potentially using a rotary switch or similar mechanism. Participants explore various methods for achieving this, including mechanical and electronic solutions, while considering practical applications and safety concerns.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Experimental/applied

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses a desire for a device that allows for variable capacitance adjustment, ideally through a knob to select from a bank of capacitors.
  • Another participant mentions that continuously variable capacitors are available but may not meet the size requirements.
  • Concerns are raised about the feasibility of building a switched bank of capacitors and the implications of "capacitance modulation."
  • Participants discuss the potential use of back-to-back polar capacitors to create a non-polar capacitor, particularly in audio applications.
  • There are suggestions for using mechanical switches or relays to achieve the desired capacitance variation, with caution advised regarding current transients when switching capacitors at non-zero voltages.
  • One participant inquires about the specifications for operating voltage and load, emphasizing the importance of voltage ratings for switch contacts.
  • Another participant suggests looking into programmable rotary switches, although they note the potential high cost associated with such devices.
  • Safety concerns are raised regarding the use of AC mains voltages, with a recommendation for synchronizing capacitor connections with the zero-crossing of the AC waveform.
  • A participant indicates plans to update the thread with progress on their project and design details after prototyping.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of ideas and concerns regarding the implementation of a variable capacitance switch, with no clear consensus on the best approach or specific solutions. Safety issues related to AC mains voltage introduce additional complexity to the discussion.

Contextual Notes

Participants have not fully defined the parameters of the project, such as the exact voltage and current specifications, which may affect the feasibility of proposed solutions. The discussion also reflects varying levels of experience among participants, particularly regarding working with AC circuits.

tim9000
Messages
866
Reaction score
17
Hi,
I want to be able to vary the amount of capacitance in a circuit, ideally I'd like to be able to turn a knob to tap a bank of capacitors, something like the attached picture.Is there some sort of switching or device available that anyone can think of which does this?

Cheers
 

Attachments

  • capacitance modulation.png
    capacitance modulation.png
    465 bytes · Views: 526
Engineering news on Phys.org
I don't know about a switched bank, but continuously variable caps are readily available.
 
phinds said:
I don't know about a switched bank, but continuously variable caps are readily available.
Hmm, too small I think. thanks anyway
 
tim9000 said:
ideally I'd like to be able to turn a knob to tap a bank of capacitors, something like the attached picture.

not too difficult to build a switched bank of caps
you labelled your image ... "capacitance modulation" ... what do you mean by that ?
what are you trying to achieve ?
 
davenn said:
not too difficult to build a switched bank of caps
you labelled your image ... "capacitance modulation" ... what do you mean by that ?
what are you trying to achieve ?
Well I wasn't really thinking about the name, anything's better than 'Untitled', but where the need arose was from an idea for a filter I've been thinking about. I wanted to easily tweak the amount of bipolar capacitance across something (something like 1uF to 500uF for instance). At this point turning a knob would be best, but even if I could do it electronically that would be good (but I wouldn't want any semiconductor voltage drop because minimal series resistance etc. is what I'm after).
Thanks
 
tim9000 said:
I wanted to easily tweak the amount of bipolar capacitance across something (something like 1uF to 500uF for instance)
For non-polar capacitance, that's pretty big. Are you familiar with how to use 2 polar caps back-to-back to make a non-polar capacitor (of half the value)? That is done in audio circuits pretty commonly, since audio frequencies typically require fairly high capacitance.

And a mechanical switch sounds like your best bet for changing the capacitance. Be careful of large current transients if you switch capacitors at non-zero voltages. You probably want to use multiple values that can be switched in and out (via relays?), so you can vary the total value fairly smoothly...

http://www.mouser.com/images/globalspecialties/lrg/CDB-10-1.jpg
CDB-10-1.jpg
 
Digitally with Relays? Rotary switch - there are lots of ways to do this, still a lot to be defined. Operating voltage, load (current), speed, resolution ( 1 to 500uF -in what size steps - 1uF resolution would take about 10 steps).
 
berkeman said:
For non-polar capacitance, that's pretty big. Are you familiar with how to use 2 polar caps back-to-back to make a non-polar capacitor (of half the value)? That is done in audio circuits pretty commonly, since audio frequencies typically require fairly high capacitance.

And a mechanical switch sounds like your best bet for changing the capacitance. Be careful of large current transients if you switch capacitors at non-zero voltages. You probably want to use multiple values that can be switched in and out (via relays?), so you can vary the total value fairly smoothly...

http://www.mouser.com/images/globalspecialties/lrg/CDB-10-1.jpg
View attachment 195300

It had occurred to me to use two back to back polar caps to make a bipolar, but I was worried it might still fatigue them. Does it?

Yeah, a mechanical switch was what I was after, like a sliding bar, but I want to avoid relays and extra complication.

Windadct said:
Digitally with Relays? Rotary switch - there are lots of ways to do this, still a lot to be defined. Operating voltage, load (current), speed, resolution ( 1 to 500uF -in what size steps - 1uF resolution would take about 10 steps).
If there was a rotary switch that maintained connection with the previous taps that would be great, rather than just taping a new section. Do you know of one?
Thanks!
 
You haven't said at what voltages the caps will be experiencing and at what kind of load. Switch contacts are voltage rated; think arc welding.
 
  • #10
dlgoff said:
You haven't said at what voltages the caps will be experiencing and at what kind of load. Switch contacts are voltage rated; think arc welding.
I haven't really decided, for arguments sake say 240VAC but no more current than an Ampere, probably a lot less. I really would like some sort of rotary tap selector switch or rotary contact bar preferably.

Thanks
 
  • #11
Search for Programmable Rotary Switch, EXAMPLE - when you see the price tag, you may head back to relays - really not that difficult. They do make Power Factor correction systems with film caps and relays like that.
 
  • #12
Thread closed temporarily for Moderation...
 
  • #13
tim9000 said:
I haven't really decided, for arguments sake say 240VAC but no more current than an Ampere, probably a lot less
Holy crap, @tim9000 you hadn't mentioned using AC Mains voltages up until now. That can be very dangerous, especially since you don't have much experience with circuits yet. please send me a PM describing exactly what you are wanting to build this for, so I can try to make a decision about letting this thread go on. At the very least, you will need to synchronize any disconnection/connection of capacitors with the zero-crossing of the AC Mains voltage waveform (assuming a non-inductive load).
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: davenn and dlgoff
  • #14
After a PM discussion with @tim9000 this thread is re-opened. Tim understands some of the issues in working with AC-Mains powered projects, and he understands that it is a good idea to power off his circuit before switching in different capacitors.
 
  • #15
I will post an update on the progress of my project and design details in due course for anyone interested; I have some prototyping to do and some things to buy.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
2K
Replies
37
Views
7K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
965
  • · Replies 31 ·
2
Replies
31
Views
5K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
20
Views
6K
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
13
Views
3K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
3K