- #1
42Physics
- 30
- 0
Dr. Who fans, unite!
Dr Who Fans Unite - Join the Community
- Thread starter 42Physics
- Start date
Click For Summary
Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the television series Doctor Who, exploring participants' experiences, opinions on characters, and the show's appeal. It includes reflections on both the classic and modern iterations of the series, as well as personal anecdotes related to viewing habits and preferences.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- Some participants express their love for Doctor Who, while others find it unwatchable, highlighting a divide in viewer preferences.
- Several participants discuss their favorite Doctors and companions, with names like Tennant, Rose, Amy, and Tom Baker frequently mentioned.
- There are differing opinions on the show's storytelling style, with some appreciating its humor and informal tone, while others criticize its reliance on technobabble.
- Some participants note the show's ability to reinvent itself through the Doctor's regeneration and the introduction of new companions.
- There are mentions of upcoming episodes and excitement about new characters, with speculation about the fate of companions and their potential reincarnations.
- Participants share their viewing experiences, including challenges in accessing episodes and nostalgia for earlier seasons.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants generally express a mix of enthusiasm and skepticism about Doctor Who, with no consensus on its overall quality or appeal. Multiple competing views on favorite characters and the show's merits remain evident throughout the discussion.
Contextual Notes
Some participants reference specific episodes and story arcs, indicating a variety of interpretations and emotional connections to the series. There are also mentions of the show's historical context and its evolution over time.
Who May Find This Useful
Fans of Doctor Who, individuals interested in science fiction television, and those exploring community discussions about popular media may find this thread engaging.
- #2
- 19,881
- 10,890
I have a few friends that watch it still. I must admit I haven't seen any episodes :(
- #3
willbell
- 20
- 6
I love doctor who, but I only get it after the season is over because without the right channel I'm stuck buying the DVDs. :(
- #4
- 19,378
- 15,614
I love SciFc in general but am utterly mystified by the popularity of Dr Who, which I consider to be unwatchable.
- #5
willbell
- 20
- 6
Well it has decent special effects, good stories, characters you can love, and is structured in such a way that it is able to run forever if it so pleases because of the practically immortal main character. Its a SciFi and we have so little good SciFi on TV, not only that but it has a very happy attitude that is informal unlike Star Trek and shows like that. It takes technobabble and turns it into a joke, it tells the audience that it doesn't care about realism and that this can be a good thing.phinds said:
The way it is designed it gives you fascinating glimpses into the life of an alien through the eyes of a human companion, and if they start becoming closer to the doctor than to humanity you can kill them off and have another companion make it all seem new again.
Sure it doesn't work for everybody, but it is magical almost when it does.
- #6
trollcast
Gold Member
- 282
- 13
I love Doctor Who, I've seen all the episodes of the reboot as well as some of the old ones.
I can't wait for the 2nd half of series 7 (Its on this Saturday on BBC in the UK, not sure about anywhere else)
Its going to be interesting to see the new assistant as the 2 episodes she's been in so far have been excellent, the christmas episode was especially good, much better than the one before that was about trees or something.
I can't wait for the 2nd half of series 7 (Its on this Saturday on BBC in the UK, not sure about anywhere else)
Its going to be interesting to see the new assistant as the 2 episodes she's been in so far have been excellent, the christmas episode was especially good, much better than the one before that was about trees or something.
- #7
willbell
- 20
- 6
trollcast said:
I believe that was meant to be a Narnia episode.
- #8
Rolen
Gold Member
- 23
- 1
So, what are your favorite personality of the doctor and favorite companion?
Mine is Tennant and Rose.
Mine is Tennant and Rose.
- #9
willbell
- 20
- 6
Tennant and Amy most likely. Matt Smith is awesome too, and for companions I liked Donna, Martha, and I already like Clara.Rolen said:
- #10
strangerep
Science Advisor
- 3,766
- 2,214
Favorite doctor: Matt, favorite companion: Rose -- especially in her Secret Diary episodes...Rolen said:
... but I didn't see a legitimate doctor there. 
Worst companion: the dickhead guy who joined after the original Barbra-and-Ian left by returning to 1960's Earth in the dalek's 1st time machine.
I actually saw the original broadcasts of Dr Who, so I've seen all the now-missing episodes.
I was really annoyed when William Hartnell got replaced by Patrick Troughton. I kept waiting for him to change back, but it never happened. Got kinda bored after Peter Davison and stopped watching.
BTW, what was the name of the actress who played the primitive companion, always running around like a female warrior out of D&D? She ended up pairing off with another timelord!?
So glad they revived it with vastly better special effects. The first new dalek episode was really excellent -- but they ruined it by having ever more millions of daleks being defeated every series (sigh).
1st episode of the latest series is on here tomorrow night.
- #11
Darwin123
- 732
- 3
And when the Doctor starts to become more human than the companion, you can kill him off so he can be replaced by an "incarnation".willbell said:
This new companion may be different. There are rumors that she will be killed in several episodes, only to return in new reincarnations.
It serves the Doctor right. For two long has he confused companions with his new incarnations. Now, it will be his turn to be confused.
- #12
Integral
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
- 7,225
- 66
I watched it some in the late '70s so Tom Baker remains my fav doctor. I think Rose is my fav companion but Amy is not far off.
I am looking forward to the next episode, ~2hrs from now.
I am looking forward to the next episode, ~2hrs from now.
- #13
Rolen
Gold Member
- 23
- 1
Darwin123 said:
Wait, what? The companion is a timelord like the first companion who was the granddaughter of the doctor?
- #14
notinthebox
- 15
- 0
Dr WHO Fan yes I would like mor of the old ones
I would like to see some of the old ones DR's 1 to 8. I also liked the show tripods on the BBC the brits have had some great sifi shows but the DR WHO has the power to stay. I hope they do remakes of the DR WHO'S and let's see the old movies of DR WHO. DR WHO fan from 1964
I would like to see some of the old ones DR's 1 to 8. I also liked the show tripods on the BBC the brits have had some great sifi shows but the DR WHO has the power to stay. I hope they do remakes of the DR WHO'S and let's see the old movies of DR WHO. DR WHO fan from 1964
- #15
willbell
- 20
- 6
No the companion is not a time lord, but she certainly has a knack for reincarnation.Rolen said:
- #16
ImATrackMan
I am an absolutely massive fan of DW. Apparently BBC America are showing monthly specials (well, "specials") that showcase a classic episode from each regeneration of the Doctor. I can't wait 'til they get to the 8th Doctor, because they pretty much have no choice but to show the Canadian-made reboot-attempt movie done in 1996.
- #17
willbell
- 20
- 6
Awesome, I've only seen one episode of the classic series.ImATrackMan said:
- #18
arianabedi
- 36
- 0
I started watching Dr. WHO recently (started with the 2005 reboot up to yesterday's release) and I must say its a great show! However I have fell in love with the newest Dr and this last two seasons. The writers are using the true potential of a time traveler in term of complex stories and good use of paradox's. Plus some obvious question regarding holes in stories (and its physics) are nicely explain by the Dr himself.
In all and all, its a great show that has recently reached its peak, and I'm loving it!
-Rule no.1, the Dorctor lies :D
In all and all, its a great show that has recently reached its peak, and I'm loving it!
-Rule no.1, the Dorctor lies :D
- #19
notinthebox
- 15
- 0
If you want you can get netflix they have 86 or so of the new ones and a load of the old ones as well. Also if anyone know how to watch tv over the net I would like to know how well that works. One thing about the DR that I love is his humans can do anything and great things if we try. It's the best parts of what we can be and hopfully we will try to be better then we are.
- #20
arianabedi
- 36
- 0
notinthebox said:
Humans doing anything is portrayed very nicely in the series, I absolutly loved the episode *THERE ARE NO REAL SPOILERS HERE, READ ON* where they travel to the end of the universe and its just humans on a planet "Utopia" and they just live there forever laughing at the thermodynamic death of the universe :D
Well sadly I am a student and in China so netflix isn't a great option. I watch it over some other websites or download the series via torrents (did I just dorp a T bomb?)
alright then I just saw the reply of someone posting a torrent link, so to watch online, I go to : http://www.free-tv-video-online.me/internet/doctor_who_(2005)/
Its a great website and I watch all my series there (basically familyguy/southpark/simpsons/how i met your mother + ofc Dr Who).
- #21
willbell
- 20
- 6
Unfortunately Netflix is out of the cards for me as well given that I am still a teenager and my parents think that imposing a 5GB limit on internet usage is a good idea in a house of four internet users.notinthebox said:
- #22
bigfooted
Gold Member
- 685
- 222
willbell said:Unfortunately Netflix is out of the cards for me as well given that I am still a teenager and my parents think that imposing a 5GB limit on internet usage is a good idea in a house of four internet users.
5GB a day is usually sufficient for me, but I'm the only serious internet user at home.
EDIT: Oh yes, and Dr. Who is great, saw the first two episodes today from season 6.
- #23
willbell
- 20
- 6
A month. :(bigfooted said:
- #24
Geekaholic
Dr. Who FANDOM
I am an absolute HUGE fan of The Doctor! Tom Baker, David Tennant, and Matt Smith are the best! I know all of the lore and I'm just a huge fanboy...
I am an absolute HUGE fan of The Doctor! Tom Baker, David Tennant, and Matt Smith are the best! I know all of the lore and I'm just a huge fanboy...
- #25
brenan
- 38
- 0
The show is starting to loose its way again. Its historic audience seems to be ignored now
and the stories frequently becoming more and more confused. The reliance on the same characters
all the time is also making them loose their power to entertain.
Someone needs to stand back and get a grip before it all falls appart IMHO.
and the stories frequently becoming more and more confused. The reliance on the same characters
all the time is also making them loose their power to entertain.
Someone needs to stand back and get a grip before it all falls appart IMHO.
- #26
Algr
- 935
- 459
Loosing it's way? I thought it was improving. You can go through a lot of styles and audiences in 50 years, so no particular era is going to satisfy everyone. But I particularly like last weeks episode.
That was Leela, played by Louise Jameson.
That was Leela, played by Louise Jameson.
- #27
brenan
- 38
- 0
They are writing it into a brick wall.
There are good reasons its suurvived this long and the current trends
are destroying that. You can see it in almost every episode now.
They are like kids in a sweet shop. Or if you like -
They are doing the writing equivalent of day trading and we all know how that ends.
There are good reasons its suurvived this long and the current trends
are destroying that. You can see it in almost every episode now.
They are like kids in a sweet shop. Or if you like -
They are doing the writing equivalent of day trading and we all know how that ends.
- #28
ImATrackMan
Algr said:
My cable went out, and the livestream would freeze after thirteen minutes. I never got to finish it...
- #29
Integral
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
- 7,225
- 66
The Tom Baker episode they played Sunday was great. Wish they would do that more often. They sure have improved the inside of the TARDIS. Tom Bakers TARDIS looked like something from a high school play.
- #30
Algr
- 935
- 459
In those years they didn't have too many scenes inside the Tardis, so I guess they didn't put so much money into it.