Drawing resonance structure for SO42

1 reply · 7K views · last reply
Sunwoo Bae
Messages
60
Reaction score
4
Homework Statement
Draw the important resonance forms for SO42-
Relevant Equations
none
I was told that there are six resonance structures for SO42-, as shown below.

Six resonance structures of sulfate ion SO4 2-, each with S at the centre, two S=O double bonds and two O- single-bonded oxygens, arranged in a cycle of double-headed arrows.


I am wondering why this structure with single bonds is not one of the possible resonance.
I understand that it is unfavorable as the formal charges are spread out over all four atoms, but shouldn't is still be a part of the resonance, given that the total formal charge of the molecule adds up to 2- in total?

Handwritten Lewis structure of sulfate ion with sulfur at centre bonded by single lines to four oxygen atoms, each with lone pairs and circled formal charges: -1 on three oxygens and +2 on sulfur.


Thank you
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Theoretically that is a possible resonance structure, but that degree of charge separation makes it much less stable than the other structures, so it contributes very little to the resonance hybrid.