Dynamics rigid body cabinet problem

5 replies · 2K views · last reply
Pipsqueakalchemist
Messages
141
Reaction score
20
Homework Statement
Question and solution below
Relevant Equations
Newton’s 2nd law
Moment equation
So for this question I understand part A but part B is confusing me, when using point B as the centre of the moment, I get different sign for the mad term. If you take clockwise as positive than 100N force and the force at point G are causing a positive moment and gravity is causing an negative moment. But the solutions have different signs as my attempt I don’t understand why. Appreciate it if someone can explain this to me.
 
Attachments
  • Solution page excerpt: a free-body diagram of a cabinet with force W=mg, a 100 N push at height h, friction F_A and F_B and normal forces N_A and N_B, next to a kinetic diagram showing mā at G; below, equations sum Fy = 0, sum Fx = ma, and a = 2.548 m/s^2 with 2.55 m/s^2 noted.
    2B0EA3B6-4D57-469A-A3A3-B37BED2170AE.png
    30 KB · Views: 220
  • Textbook figure of a tall cabinet on casters on a floor, with a horizontal 100 N force arrow pushing at its left side at height h, centre of mass G marked, width 0.6 m and height 0.9 m labelled, beside printed Problems 16.9 and 16.10.
    38C10DBE-70B6-4406-BFBA-4245743FDC9B.png
    20 KB · Views: 206
  • Handwritten free-body diagram of a tipping cabinet with a 100 N horizontal force at height h, weight W = mg = 196.2 N at centre G, and reactions NA and NB at the base corners A and B; dimensions 0.3 m and 0.2 m are marked, with a second sketch of the cabinet at the tipping condition.
    3651C1E1-9807-4DB3-8E4A-9A973D84B10C.png
    19.4 KB · Views: 239
  • Solution page from Problem 16.10 (continued) showing moment equations about points B and A for a tipping cabinet, with the results h = 1.047 m, h = -0.130 m (impossible) and the conclusion h ≤ 1.047 m.
    4E5EAB39-0DC1-47D9-B97F-D6D0DD26C5FA.png
    24.9 KB · Views: 220
  • Handwritten moment equation on lined paper with a counterclockwise arrow labelled + next to M_B: 100h + mad - 0.3W = 0, with a pen lying on the dark desk above.
    image.jpg
    39.2 KB · Views: 208
Hi there,

Perhaps I am wrong, but from the problem statement, it seems as if the point B is accelerating and thus we are taking moments about an accelerating point. Hence, the ## m a d ## term is included. See the derivation below for why this is the case. ## G ## is the centre of mass and ## A ## is an arbitrary accelerating point.

Diagram of a rigid body with arbitrary point O, accelerating point A, centre of mass G, and element Δm at position r from O and p from A, with velocity and acceleration arrows, followed by the derivation of angular momentum about a moving point.


Hope this is of some help.
 
I understand why mad term is included, what I don’t understand is the sign. If you take clockwise direction as positive than the mad term and the 100h should be positive and the weight negative but that’s not the case. If you move the mad term to the left side of the equation the mad term is negative and that’s what I don’t understand.
 
Sorry I don't quite follow. Can you point me towards which equation you are looking at? I see the equation:

Handwritten-style textbook solution for Problem 16.10 (continued): moment equation about B, sum of M_B = I_G alpha + m a-bar d, giving (100 N)h - (196.2 N)(0.3 m) = (20 kg)(2.548 m/s^2)(0.9 m), so h = 1.047 m.


Pipsqueakalchemist said:
I understand why mad term is included, what I don’t understand is the sign.
What is wrong with the sign in the equation? From the derivation that I posted above, this sign convention seems to agree with that (unless I am missing something...).

Pipsqueakalchemist said:
If you take clockwise direction as positive than the mad term and the 100h should be positive and the weight negative but that’s not the case. If you move the mad term to the left side of the equation the mad term is negative and that’s what I don’t understand.
The ## mad ## term is not on the same side of the equation as the ## 100h ## term, as shown in the derivation above. I don't believe the horizontal acceleration is being treated as a fictitious force in this instance. By including the ## mad## term on the same side of the equation as the 'actual forces', you are treating it as a fictitious force, which is not what the solutions do. If you are keen on treating it as such (thus allowing you to include it on the left hand side of the moments equation), the fictitious force should actually oppose the direction of the force ## F ##, which would yield the same moment equation as the solutions show. In short: why would you include the ## mad ## term on the same side of the equation as the other moments?
 
Oh I see, I think I understand now, well sort of. Good enough to get the right answer.
 
Pipsqueakalchemist said:
Oh I see, I think I understand now, well sort of. Good enough to get the right answer.

It just comes down to the moments expression. When we take moments about an accelerating point, we need to include this extra acceleration of the centre of mass in the expression. It is a tricky concept and that is why we often try to take moments about the centre of mass, such that we can ignore this extra term. I would suggest reading up on rigid body dynamics and rotational dynamics for a deeper discussion on the topic.
 
Last edited: