Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the characteristics of electromagnetic wave modes, specifically TEM, TE, and TM modes, in different contexts such as free space and waveguides. Participants explore the implications of these modes in relation to the direction of the electric field and the propagation vector, as well as their occurrence in systems like lasers and waveguides.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Conceptual clarification
Main Points Raised
- One participant questions the presence of an electric field in the direction of propagation in TM modes and whether such modes can exist in free space or only in lasers.
- Another participant expresses limited knowledge of quantum mechanics and seeks clarification on the definitions of TEM, TE, and TM modes, while also noting the perpendicularity of the propagation vector.
- A participant discusses the similarity between the wave equation for electromagnetic waves in waveguides and Schrödinger's Equation, mentioning the role of refractive indices in determining the "potential" of waveguides.
- There is a suggestion that TE and TM modes relate to the presence of electric or magnetic fields in the direction of propagation, with a request for visual aids to enhance understanding.
- One participant asserts that electromagnetic waves in free space travel in TEM mode, while TE and TM modes are specific to guided waves, explaining the concept of zig-zagging waves in waveguides.
- It is noted that a laser shining down a waveguide can still be in TEM mode if it does not interact with the guide walls, and that multiple conductors can allow for TEM mode propagation.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express varying levels of understanding and agreement regarding the definitions and implications of TEM, TE, and TM modes. There is no clear consensus on the conditions under which these modes can exist or their characteristics in different contexts.
Contextual Notes
Some assumptions regarding the definitions of modes and their physical implications remain unresolved. The discussion includes varying interpretations of how these modes relate to waveguides and free space.