Einstein Notation - Not sure if my answers are right

5 replies · 2K views · last reply
unscientific
Messages
1,728
Reaction score
13

Homework Statement



Questions 11 and 12 specifically..
Printed homework problems 11 and 12 on index notation: find the grad of |r|^n, a dot r, and |r|^n r; div and curl of r, a dot r times b, and a cross r, with a and b fixed vectors.


Homework Equations


The Attempt at a Solution


11(a)
Handwritten derivation labelled (a): |r|^n = (r_i r_i)^(n/2), then the gradient of |r|^n computed by the chain rule as n |r|^(n-2) r_i e_i, using Einstein index notation.


11(b)
Handwritten tensor-notation derivation of the gradient of a dot product: the gradient of (a dot r) equals a_i a_i,r_i e_i, then equals (r_i (da_i/dr_i) + a_i) e_i, with index sums written out.


12(a)
Handwritten working for question 12(a): the divergence of vector r written as nabla dot r, equal to d_i r_i = 3.


12(b)
Handwritten working in index notation: |r|^n r equals (r_i r_i)^(n/2) r_i e_i, then divergence of |r|^n r computed step by step to give |r|^n (3 + n).

Handwritten derivation of part 12(b) in index notation: the i-th component of curl of |r|^n r equals epsilon_ijk d_j of (r_l r_l)^(n/2) r_k, then becomes epsilon_ijk (n/2)(r_l r_l)^(n/2 - 1) times 2 r_j r_k, which reduces to zero because r cross r is zero.


12(c)
Handwritten index-notation derivation of the gradient of (a·r) b, showing the steps ∂_i a_k r_k b_i = b_i ∂_i a_k r_k = b_i a_i = b·a, with a red side note that ∂_i acts only on i = k and a_i r_k = 0 otherwise.

Handwritten index-notation derivation of the gradient of (a·r) b, using Levi-Civita epsilon and partial derivatives, ending in the result a × b.


12(d)
Handwritten derivation of the divergence of a cross product in index notation: nabla dot (a cross r) equals partial_i epsilon_ijk a_j r_k, then epsilon_ijk partial_i a_j r_k, then 0.

Handwritten derivation in index notation of the curl of (a cross r), reducing step by step using the epsilon-delta identity to 3a_i minus a_j d_j r_i, with a red note asking whether summation of r_i is implied, and the final line 3a.


(I did the last part of 12(d) by normal vector methods and got 2a instead...which is the correct answer)
 
Last edited:
An index shouldn't appear more than twice. For the first one, for example, you should have
$$\frac{\partial}{\partial r_i} (r_j r_j)^{n/2}$$
 
vela said:
An index shouldn't appear more than twice. For the first one, for example, you should have
$$\frac{\partial}{\partial r_i} (r_j r_j)^{n/2}$$

Thanks for your reply!

Also, I can't see what's wrong with my final answer in part 12(d)...i think the last line is the cross product of ∂j and r which equates to zero??

I think I have figured out every question other than part 12(d)
 
Last edited:
Hint: ##\partial_i r_j = \delta_{ij}##. You can use that in several of the problems. In 12b, you need to use the product rule.
 
vela said:
Hint: ##\partial_i r_j = \delta_{ij}##.

thanks i think I've sorted it out!
 
unscientific said:
what does this mean? is it a vector or a scalar? summation implied or not?
It is not a summation. It is just the statement that the partial of the jth coordinate function with respect to the ith coordinate function is just the kronecker delta.