MHB Equation With Integer Solutions

  • Thread starter Thread starter anemone
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Integer
AI Thread Summary
The equation $a^2(b-2)+b^2(a-2)+28=0$ is discussed for integer solutions. Participants express gratitude for contributions and confirm the correctness of solutions provided. There is a mention of a previous oversight regarding the inclusion of a plus-minus sign in the calculations. The conversation emphasizes collaborative problem-solving and the importance of accuracy in mathematical discussions. Overall, the thread highlights the process of finding integer solutions to the given equation.
anemone
Gold Member
MHB
POTW Director
Messages
3,851
Reaction score
115
Solve the following equation for integer solutions:

$a^2(b-2)+b^2(a-2)+28=0$
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
anemone said:
Solve the following equation for integer solutions:

$a^2(b-2)+b^2(a-2)+28=0---(A)$
suppose the original equation $A$ can be factorized as $(B)$ or $(C)$
$a^2(b-2)+b^2(a-2)+28=0----(A)\\
(a^2-x)[(b-2)-\dfrac{28}{x}]=0---(B)\\
\therefore x=1,\,\, or\,\, x=4\\
\rightarrow a=\pm 1\,\, or \,\, a=\pm 2--------(1)\\
(a-y)[a(b-2)-\dfrac{28}{y}]=0---(C)\\
\therefore a=y=\pm 1,\pm 2,\pm 4,\pm 7,\pm 14,\pm 28---(2)$
for $a,b\in Z$
check $(1)(2)$
the only solution :$a=2,b=-5$ will satisfy (A)
by symmetry:
$\therefore (a,b)=(2,-5) \,\, or \,\, (a,b)=(-5,2)$
 
Last edited:
Thanks Albert for participating, and your final solution is correct.

My solution:

$a^2(b-2)+b^2(a-2)+28=0$

$a^2(b-2)+b^2(a-2)+32=4$

$a^2b-2a^2+ab^2-2b^2+32=4$

$ab(a+b)-2(a^2+b^2)+32=4$

$ab(a+b)-2(a+b)^2+4ab+32=4$

$(a+b)(ab-2(a+b))+4(ab+8)=4$

$(a+b)(ab-2(a+b)+8)-8(a+b)+4(ab+8)=4$

$(a+b)(ab-2(a+b)+8)+4(ab-2(a+b)+8)=4$

$(a+b+4)(ab-2(a+b)+8)=4$

$(a+b+4)(ab-2(a+b)+8)=\pm 1(\pm 1)\stackrel{\text{or}}=\pm 2(\pm 2)\stackrel{\text{or}}=\pm 4(\pm 1)\stackrel{\text{or}}=\pm 1(\pm 4)$

Upon checking for all cases, we see that the following two are the only solutions:

$(a,\,b)=(-5,\,2),\,(2,\,-5)$
 
anemone said:
Thanks Albert for participating, and your final solution is correct.

My solution:

$a^2(b-2)+b^2(a-2)+28=0$

$a^2(b-2)+b^2(a-2)+32=4$

$a^2b-2a^2+ab^2-2b^2+32=4$

$ab(a+b)-2(a^2+b^2)+32=4$

$ab(a+b)-2(a+b)^2+4ab+32=4$

$(a+b)(ab-2(a+b))+4(ab+8)=4$

$(a+b)(ab-2(a+b)+8)-8(a+b)+4(ab+8)=4$

$(a+b)(ab-2(a+b)+8)+4(ab-2(a+b)+8)=4$

$(a+b+4)(ab-2(a+b)+8)=4$

$(a+b+4)(ab-2(a+b)+8)=1(1)\stackrel{\text{or}}=2(2)\stackrel{\text{or}}=4(1)\stackrel{\text{or}}=1(4)$

Upon checking for all cases, we see that the following two are the only solutions:

$(a,\,b)=(-5,\,2),\,(2,\,-5)$

above ans is correct nut

you missed out some cases of factors (-ve) * (-ve) in which you could have missed out solution but you did not miss out
 
Ah, my mistake...I in fact took into consideration of all cases, just that I forgot to put the plus minus sign in the post...I just fixed it, thanks!
 
anemone said:
Thanks Albert for participating, and your final solution is correct.

My solution:

$a^2(b-2)+b^2(a-2)+28=0$

$a^2(b-2)+b^2(a-2)+32=4$

$a^2b-2a^2+ab^2-2b^2+32=4$

$ab(a+b)-2(a^2+b^2)+32=4$

$ab(a+b)-2(a+b)^2+4ab+32=4$

$(a+b)(ab-2(a+b))+4(ab+8)=4$

$(a+b)(ab-2(a+b)+8)-8(a+b)+4(ab+8)=4$

$(a+b)(ab-2(a+b)+8)+4(ab-2(a+b)+8)=4$

$(a+b+4)(ab-2(a+b)+8)=4$

$(a+b+4)(ab-2(a+b)+8)=\pm 1(\pm 1)\stackrel{\text{or}}=\pm 2(\pm 2)\stackrel{\text{or}}=\pm 4(\pm 1)\stackrel{\text{or}}=\pm 1(\pm 4)$

Upon checking for all cases, we see that the following two are the only solutions:

$(a,\,b)=(-5,\,2),\,(2,\,-5)$

Sorry that I missed out last time

$\pm1(\pm 1)$ is invalid
 
Seemingly by some mathematical coincidence, a hexagon of sides 2,2,7,7, 11, and 11 can be inscribed in a circle of radius 7. The other day I saw a math problem on line, which they said came from a Polish Olympiad, where you compute the length x of the 3rd side which is the same as the radius, so that the sides of length 2,x, and 11 are inscribed on the arc of a semi-circle. The law of cosines applied twice gives the answer for x of exactly 7, but the arithmetic is so complex that the...
Back
Top