- #1
Wesleytf
- 32
- 0
Homework Statement
Not so much a problem, just an error I noticed... It's in the third edition (and update of the third edition) of David C. Lay's Linear Algebra and its Applications.
Homework Equations
p.228, last sentence:
"Every linear combination of u, v, and w is an element of Nul A. Thus, {u, v, w} is a spanning set for Nul A."
The Attempt at a Solution
The "thus" is incorrect--I think what he's trying to say is that every element of Nul A is a linear combination of u, v and w. Thus, {u, v, w} is a spanning set for Nul A.
As stated, I think it is false.
For instance, take this case:
Given: {u, v, w} is a basis for Nul A
Superimpose his statement:
Every linear combination of u and v is an element of Nul A.
Thus, {u, v} is a spanning set for Nul A. (--><--) (contradiction).
I found this while doing the reading for class several weeks back. I looked online and I couldn't find any errata for this book--does anyone know of any other errors in the book? Anyone disagree that this is incorrect, or at least unclear?