- #1

- 1,827

- 7

## Main Question or Discussion Point

The laser is able to vaporize an Earth sized planet in about a second.

- Thread starter Count Iblis
- Start date

- #1

- 1,827

- 7

The laser is able to vaporize an Earth sized planet in about a second.

- #2

mgb_phys

Science Advisor

Homework Helper

- 7,744

- 12

Then you just need the mass of Earth and the heat of vaporisation of rock ( or the crust)

- #3

- 1,827

- 7

We need to do more than that. The Earth has to be destroyed in just a second. When a huge amount of energy is delivered to the surface a big schockwave develops. This has to travel through the entire planet in a second.Then you just need the mass of Earth and the heat of vaporisation of rock ( or the crust)

- #4

mgb_phys

Science Advisor

Homework Helper

- 7,744

- 12

Still if you intending to convert 6x10^24kg of rock to gas that's going to take quite a bit of energy anyway leaving aside the dynamics ;-)

- #5

- 52

- 0

I'd like to see this solved. It would also be a neat problem to show to my physics teacher.

- #6

vanesch

Staff Emeritus

Science Advisor

Gold Member

- 5,007

- 16

Ok, let us estimate: latent heat of evaporation, say 1000 J/g (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latent_heat) or 1 MJ/kg. That brings us to about 6 10^30 J, or let's say, 10^31 J.

I'd like to see this solved. It would also be a neat problem to show to my physics teacher.

Now, a supernova has an energy output of something (if I remember well) like 10^42 J.

So if the death star runs on supernovas, one supernova has more than 100 billion "bullets" that can blow up the earth...

- #7

russ_watters

Mentor

- 19,028

- 5,187

Or 2x10^15 megatons, which is somewhere around 200 billion times the nuclear warheads on earth.

- #8

mgb_phys

Science Advisor

Homework Helper

- 7,744

- 12

Russ - you've obviously been planning this, should we be worried?

- #9

- 1,222

- 2

There is a neat method for doing problems like this that doesn't get taught to undergraduates as I feel it shoud be:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buckingham_π_theorem

It's called Buckingham's pi theorem, where pi refers not to Archimedes's constant in this case but to the defacto appearance of the greek character in the notation. Anyway, Buckingham's theorem formalizes the use of dimensional analysis to generate relevant equations out of no where. When I saw this question I thought of the classic example whereby the energy released in the trinity test of the atomic bomb was estimated before the actual value was declassified. Fortunately Wikipedia has this example:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buckingham_π_theorem#The_atomic_bomb

The equation we get is:

[tex] R = (\frac{E t^2}{\rho})^{\frac{1}{5}} [/tex]

This equation describes the expansion of the radius of the blast as a function of time in terms of the energy of the blast and the density of the environment. If we use the average density of the earth, the radius of the earth, and a destruction time of 0.5 seconds (maybe someone with a stop watch and a new hope DVD can do a better estimate) I calculate a total energy of 2*10^32 Joules, which would be over a trillion megatons!

- #10

- 220

- 1

This is such a nerdy thread.

What about the power ouput of captain kirk's gun when set to stun?

btw, Crosson thanks for posting that, I hadn't heard of Buckingham's pi theorem, I'm finding it very interesting

What about the power ouput of captain kirk's gun when set to stun?

btw, Crosson thanks for posting that, I hadn't heard of Buckingham's pi theorem, I'm finding it very interesting

Last edited:

- #11

- 85

- 0

At such power densities vacuum will be olso plasma of particle-antiparticle

And what is the laser freaquency and width of the ray? How do we focus it?

- #12

- 1,827

- 7

Perhaps it could be focussed using a black hole as a gravitational lens?

At such power densities vacuum will be olso plasma of particle-antiparticle

And what is the laser freaquency and width of the ray? How do we focus it?

- #13

- 3,427

- 1,117

Interesting that that number works out to very close to the gravitational binding energy of the Earth (2.24*10^32 J)(1000th post!)

If we use the average density of the earth, the radius of the earth, and a destruction time of 0.5 seconds (maybe someone with a stop watch and a new hope DVD can do a better estimate) I calculate a total energy of 2*10^32 Joules, which would be over a trillion megatons!

- #14

- 167

- 0

Well.. since this is for a High school class (im giessing since leftyguitarjo said to show his teacher), I think it could be simplified, couldnt it? I mean just not overthought.

At such power densities vacuum will be olso plasma of particle-antiparticle

And what is the laser freaquency and width of the ray? How do we focus it?

The original Q is to vaporize teh earth - so use the melting point and heat of vaporization of Rock and the mass of the earth as your data. Then its a simple thermo problem.

When you find the total energy needed, that is the power since the time taken to output that much energy is 1 second.

- #15

DrClapeyron

- #16

Borek

Mentor

- 28,137

- 2,648

Alderaan was not evaporated. There was a lot of debris left.

- #17

- 5

- 0

yeah but you dont know how large Alderaan was, might have been slightly larger than earth.

- #18

- 111

- 0

[tex]

P=2*10^{32}W,\;

<S>=\frac{\epsilon_0c}{2}E^2, \;W/m^2,\;

P=A*<S>\;

A=\pi R^2,\;

R=R_{earth}/100,\;

E_{ion,Hydro}=13eV/0.5 Angstrom

[/tex]

This gives that the electric field over the bohr-radii is abot 13 times bigger than the "break-down" of an hydrogen atom (E_{ion,Hydro}=13eV/0.5Å). reosonable?

- Replies
- 8

- Views
- 2K

- Last Post

- Replies
- 6

- Views
- 733

- Last Post

- Replies
- 19

- Views
- 1K

- Replies
- 3

- Views
- 9K

- Last Post

- Replies
- 11

- Views
- 5K

- Last Post

- Replies
- 54

- Views
- 15K

- Replies
- 3

- Views
- 823

- Last Post

- Replies
- 3

- Views
- 714