Evaluating Scattering Integral

14 replies · 3K views · last reply
Waxterzz
Messages
82
Reaction score
0
Hi,

I really don't have a clue to solve this.

Slide showing the scattering rate integral for electrons and its spherical-coordinate result, with a plot of momentum relaxation rate versus electron energy from 0 to 0.6 eV on a log scale, and a k, k' coordinate sketch.
I tried something like the dirac function identity:

Typeset equation: integral of dt f(t) delta(t - t0) equals f(t0), the sifting property of the Dirac delta function.


But then I saw it's dk' not dk' and couldn't got it straight.

Can someone help me with this?
 
As it is said, you have to change to spherical coordinates. The Dirac delta will then only affect the integral over r.
 
DrClaude said:
As it is said, you have to change to spherical coordinates. The Dirac delta will then only affect the integral over r.

I don't see it. dk' is not a volume element?
 
Typeset vector identity: dr = dr r-hat + r dθ θ-hat + r sin θ dφ φ-hat, expressing an infinitesimal displacement in spherical coordinates with unit vectors r-hat, θ-hat and φ-hat.


dk' is a vector. Then I have an integral comprising of 3 terms each involving unit vectors.

I really don't have a clue.
 
Wait wait, I am extremely confused.

I just have to integrate over the k' first?
 
Mr
DrClaude said:
As it is said, you have to change to spherical coordinates. The Dirac delta will then only affect the integral over r.
6 hours and I still have no clue, can you please hold my hand and solve it with me. I mean, just say what I have to do, I will solve it, but give me instructions.

I mean what's the deal with the dirac function and the dk', it's supposed to be a volume element and the dirac term, why isn't it delta(k-k')
 
##d\vec{k}## is a volume element. Write it as a volume element in spherical coordinate. To make the integrand even more transparent, use the cosine law to express ##|\vec{k}-\vec{k'}|^2## in terms of ##k##, ##k'##, and ##\theta##.
 
blue_leaf77 said:
##d\vec{k}## is a volume element. Write it as a volume element in spherical coordinate. To make the integrand even more transparent, use the cosine law to express ##|\vec{k}-\vec{k'}|^2## in terms of ##k##, ##k'##, and ##\theta##.
Handwritten derivation on graph paper of a scattering integral with delta function, showing spherical volume element d^3k' = k'^2 sin(theta) dk' dtheta dphi, with a question mark and sad face, and a crossed-out 'NO!' at the bottom.


How come dk' is a volume element, it's the derivative of a vector. Most textbooks, the volume element is called a d tau or a dV

My head is a mess. It's like I completely forgot how to calculus.

Good news: I know I'm wrong.

Really don't see it
 
What happened to the Dirac delta? You should do the integral over k' first.
 
Waxterzz said:
How come dk' is a volume element, it's the derivative of a vector. Most textbooks, the volume element is called a d tau or a dV
It's not a derivative, it is an infinitesimal vector element.
 
DrClaude said:
It's not a derivative, it is an infinitesimal vector element.

It's been this the whole time?, with r being k'

Typeset volume element in spherical coordinates: dV = (dr)(r dθ)(r sin θ dφ) = r^2 dr sin θ dθ dφ, written as two aligned equation lines.


Ps: After this I'm going to finally learn LaTeX
 
Handwritten integral derivation on grid paper: one-half times the integral over phi from 0 to 2pi of an integral over k of k^2 sin(theta) times a delta function, followed by crossed-out attempts and a final line of pi/4 times an integral with a denominator (2k^2 - 2k^2 cos(theta) + lambda^2) squared.
Handwritten derivation on grid paper: pi/4 integral of 1/(2k^2 - 2k^2 cos(theta) + lambda^2) over theta from 0 to 180, then k-integral steps, ending with pi times integral of k^2/(k^2 lambda^2 + lambda^4) equal to pi/lambda^2 times integral of k^2/(k^2+lambda^2) dk.


This is what I got uptil now, but I have to leave.

Thanks for help, give me feedback if you want to, and I will post update when I'm back, probably tomorrow. Thanks for the patience anyway!
 
DrClaude said:
It's not a derivative, it is an infinitesimal vector element.

blue_leaf77 said:
Why did the Dirac delta disappear in the second equation from the last one?

Hi,

Sorry for the late reply.

Hope this is somewhat more clear, because last post was a bit messy. Still haven't learned LaTex.

Handwritten derivation on grid paper: triple integral of a delta function over k-squared sin theta, reduced step by step via delta-function sifting to a single integral of sin theta over (1 - 2cos theta + lambda squared over k squared) squared, equal to pi k over k^4 times an integral from 0 to pi.


Is this valid?

I couldn't evaluatie the last integral, because of the square.

Do I need to use partial fractions?

Thanks
 
Hi myself,

I found out I need to include something like 1- ( stuff going in the z direction after k scattering) / (stuff that would go in z direction if there was no scattering at all), so 1 - k' projected on z axis /k = 1 - (k cos theta) / k

Yes, I'm a noob.

So I'll start over. :')