Extremely confusing dynamics question

  • Thread starter Thread starter SecretSnow
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Confusing Dynamics
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
2 replies · 3K views
SecretSnow
Messages
66
Reaction score
0
Hi guys, this is so confusing as there are lots of assumption needed (I think). I can't do this even though I got the answer and tried working backwards.

A painter in a crate which hangs alongside a building, weighs 1000N.When the painter pulls on the rope, the force he exerts on the floor of the crate is 450N. If the crate wieghs 250N, find the acceleration. Answer: 2.0ms^-2

Firstly, we don't know whether the system is even accelerating upwards or downwards..and I also realized that the tension exerted may be just the normal force of 450N exerted back onto the painter (since he exerts 450N on the floor) does that mean he is apparently weightless? That is quite strange though, because if we consider in terms of forces acting on the painter, then it's 450N from the floor and 450N from the rope, both acting upwards. And I'm asking this because some answers I found online say the weight of the painter can be neglected although I don't know why...pls help! I'm stuck in this one question for a long long long time...
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Phrased like that, the problem statement should have some sketch attached.

The answer is right if a rope goes from the crate over some fixed anchor (at the top of the building) back to the painter.
 
SecretSnow said:
A painter in a crate which hangs alongside a building, weighs 1000N.
Note this means the painter weighs 1000N, not painter plus crate.
we don't know whether the system is even accelerating upwards or downwards..
You shouldn't need to predict that - it will come out in the answer.
and I also realized that the tension exerted may be just the normal force of 450N exerted back onto the painter
The tension in the rope equals the normal force from the floor? Why should it?
some answers I found online say the weight of the painter can be neglected
The weight of the painter is given, and certainly cannot be neglected.
Have you drawn free body diagrams for crate and painter, including an unknown tension? What equations do you get?