Finding the force of reaction as a function of time

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around finding the force of reaction as a function of time, with the original poster attempting to derive this using the equations F=Ma and F=-Kx. They incorrectly conclude that F(t)=MV from their integration steps, which is clarified by other participants who point out that it should be dF=MdV instead. The correct approach involves starting from F=dP/dt, using the definition of momentum, and applying the product rule for differentiation. Ultimately, the consensus emphasizes the importance of correctly applying calculus principles to derive the force function. Accurate formulation and integration are crucial for solving such physics problems effectively.
jumboopizza
Messages
13
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


the only part of the question I am unsure about is finding the force of reaction as a function of time


Homework Equations


F=Ma
F=-Kx


The Attempt at a Solution



F=Ma
F=M(Dv/Dt)

F Dt= M Dv

i integrate force with respect to time from final time=t and initial time = 0

integrating M with respect to velocity from final velocity=V and initial velocity=0

I get F(t)=MV

is this the correct way to get the force as a function of time?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
did you find the solution
 
na na said:
did you find the solution
This thread is ten years old!
 
I know but I also have a problem that is very similar to that one . how do you find the force as a function of time
 
Make a new thread in homework forums please and be sure to post as many details as you can about your problem and attempted solution, including the exact statement of the problem as it is given to you.

What the OP does here is not entirely correct. From ##Fdt=MdV## it is not correct to conclude ##F(t)=MV##, it should have been ##dF=MdV## in order to conclude that.
 
  • Like
Likes jim mcnamara and na na
Delta2 said:
Make a new thread in homework forums please and be sure to post as many details as you can about your problem and attempted solution, including the exact statement of the problem as it is given to you.

What the OP does here is not entirely correct. From ##Fdt=MdV## it is not correct to conclude ##F(t)=MV##, it should have been ##dF=MdV## in order to conclude that.
ok thank you very much
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman and Delta2
Delta2 said:
Make a new thread in homework forums please and be sure to post as many details as you can about your problem and attempted solution, including the exact statement of the problem as it is given to you.

What the OP does here is not entirely correct. From ##Fdt=MdV## it is not correct to conclude ##F(t)=MV##, it should have been ##dF=MdV## in order to conclude that.
Ummm, make that ##F = M \frac{dV}{dt}##. Which would more conventionally have used a lower case M and V and would be commonly written as: ##F=ma##

One could start with ##F=\frac{dp}{dt}##, take the definition of momentum ##p## as ##mv##, substitute to arrive at ##F=\frac{d(mv)}{dt}## use the product rule for differentiation and get ##F=m \frac{dv}{dt} + v \frac{dm}{dt}##, take m as a constant so that its derivative is zero to get ##F = m \frac{dv}{dt}## and then use the definition of acceleration to rewrite that as ##F=ma##.
 
Back
Top