Finding the resultant couple moment

1 reply · 5K views · last reply
theBEAST
Messages
361
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


I attached the question as a picture to this thread

Homework Equations


M=Fd

The Attempt at a Solution


I was taught that the moment produced by two equal but opposite forces is the magnitude of one force multiplied by the distance between the two forces.

I used Pythagoras to solve for the distances between each of the couples and found sqrt32 and sqrt8 to be these distances.

Thus
M1= 150*sqrt32
M2=200*sqrt8

and the resultant moment
=M1-M2
=283Nm [clockwise]

This is not the answer, the method the answer key used was breaking up the couples into x and y. I don't understand why my method does not work as well.
 
Attachments
  • Textbook problem 4-75 with a solution worked by resolving the 150 lb and 200 lb couples into x and y components, and a structural frame diagram showing a vertical member with forces F, 150 lb and 200 lb at angles.
    Capture.PNG
    31 KB · Views: 1,660
hi theBEAST! :smile:
theBEAST said:
… the distances between each of the couples and found sqrt32 and sqrt8 to be these distances.

nooo :redface: …

√32 and √8 are the distances between the points of application of these forces

the couple uses the distance between the lines of application of the forces :wink: