Football freaks only - Which league is the best?

  • Thread starter Thread starter EL
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary
The discussion centers around which football league has the strongest average team, with participants predominantly favoring the Premier League and La Liga. Many contributors assert that the Premier League boasts higher overall quality, citing its competitive nature and depth of talent. Others argue that La Liga, with its historically strong teams like Barcelona and Real Madrid, presents a more technically skilled competition. The debate touches on the perceived physicality of English teams versus the technical prowess of Spanish teams, with references to UEFA rankings and the performance of clubs in European competitions. Participants also humorously engage in comparing football (soccer) and American football, highlighting cultural differences in terminology and gameplay. The conversation reflects a mix of personal biases, regional pride, and statistical references, ultimately underscoring the ongoing rivalry between these two prominent leagues.

Which football league is the best?

  • Total voters
    30
  • #61
And meteor's not going to be biased at all is he? I don't think there is much too choose between either of the leagues, but in my opinion the premiership is the best because the football that is played is soo open and normally end to end stuff. Will be interesting to see the outcome of Chelsea v Barcelona and Arsenal v Real Madrid. Both of those games will be awesome, haven't a clue who will go through to the next round though.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #62
I'm going to have to say AFC South with the colts and jaguars is the best division. Why would you guys call soccer football? That doesn't make any sense.
 
  • #63
Andy said:
And meteor's not going to be biased at all is he?
Well, anyway, I should be biased, in favour of PL!
 
  • #64
KingNothing said:
Why would you guys call soccer football? That doesn't make any sense.
Do the words foot and ball say you anything?:rolleyes:
 
  • #65
Everyone that's into football knows that La liga is a stronger competition than the Premier League.

why is this? Let's just see whos clubs get the furthest in the ufea and Champions league...
 
  • #66
Anttech said:
why is this? Let's just see whos clubs get the furthest in the ufea and Champions league...

You must know that english teams are always praised for their physical strength, but they habitually lack technical skills. However, spanish teams use to be well-skilled.

But you want proofs? Ok, no problem

Here's a nice list portraying the UEFA team ranking for year 2005.
http://www.xs4all.nl/~kassiesa/bert/uefa/data/method3/trank2005.html

Let's examine the first 50 teams. I count 10 spanish teams.: R.Madrid, Valencia, Barça, D.Coruña, Villarreal, Celta, Alaves, Zaragoza, Mallorca and Malaga

When I count english teams: oh surprise! only 6: Liverpool, Manchester, Arsenal, Newcastle, Chelsea and Leeds

That's enough? No?, Well, I have this other nice list with the FIFA ranking of national teams. Spain is 5th and England is 9th
http://www.fifa.com/en/mens/statistics/index.html

Now the ball is in your court :approve:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #67
Look arounf your www site and you will see

first:
http://www.xs4all.nl/~kassiesa/bert/uefa/data/method3/tcoef2005.html

second:
http://www.xs4all.nl/~kassiesa/bert/uefa/data/method3/ccoef2005.html

third:
http://www.xs4all.nl/~kassiesa/bert/uefa/data/method3/crank2005.html

(Spain is better for the past 5 years accumulatively but not this year) and we are talking about the CURRENT EPL.

The ball is now in your goal... 3-1 EPL ;-D

That's enough? No?, Well, I have this other nice list with the FIFA ranking of national teams. Spain is 5th and England is 9th
http://www.fifa.com/en/mens/statistics/index.html

what on Earth as that to do with the national league.. clutching straws
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #68
Anttech said:
what on Earth as that to do with the national league.. clutching straws
You're completely right on this. Just look at Sweden: The leuague sux more than my new vacuum cleaner, but still we'll win the WC!:biggrin:
 
  • #69
You're completely right on this. Just look at Sweden: The leuague sux more than my new vacuum cleaner, but still we'll win the WC!
***SNAP*** ***SNAP*** ***SNAP***
wakey wakey EL... Your Dreaming hehe :smile:
 
  • #70
Isn't the jumbo prize a water closet?

(Ouch, that was bad...really bad... )
 
  • #71
If spain are the 5th best team in the world and england only the 9th, then why are England joint favourites to win the tournemant? And your UEFA rankings are soo far out of date its unbeleivable, did you not hear about leeds getting relegated going into administration and now being absolutely useless? Anyone who knows anything about football will know about leeds, Champions league semi-finalists and just a few short years later they get relegated to the first division.
 
  • #72
Andy said:
If spain are the 5th best team in the world and england only the 9th, then why are England joint favourites to win the tournemant? And your UEFA rankings are soo far out of date its unbeleivable, did you not hear about leeds getting relegated going into administration and now being absolutely useless? Anyone who knows anything about football will know about leeds, Champions league semi-finalists and just a few short years later they get relegated to the first division.
England favourites? They have not won the championship in decades...
And they are not my UEFA rankings. This is an official list that takes into consideration the results obtained over the last years by the teams. Leeds was relegated, but the years before to the relegation was performing fairly well, right? So, that's why it has a great amount of points
Ronaldinho has just won the FIFA Player of the year for the second consecutive season. Second is Lampard, that plays in Premier league, for Chelsea. But third is another player of La Liga, Eto'o.
I'm looking forward for the Barcelona vs Chelsea, because they are actually the best teams in Europe,IMHO, so it's like a premature final. Here were I live people speak to no end about the matches. Barcelona has just beaten its historical record of 11 victories in a row (with the victory yesterday against Celta it has 13 accumulated until now)
Possibly we will see another row Mourinho vs Rijkaard, just like last year... :wink:
 
Last edited:
  • #73
Guarenteed to be an arguement, mourinho is far too arrogant and to be honest i would love to see barcelona beat chelsea.
 
  • #74
oooooooooooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh you mean soccer...
 
  • #75
Premiership of course, Let Stuart Pearce and Manchester City rule supreme! Actually Brazil are 7/2 favs for the world cup, England are 6/1 second fav.

Arsenal for the champions league!
 
  • #76
Anttech said:
So EL.. when you going to eat your hat :-)
I'd just like to point out that in the CL quarter finals we now have:
One english team (Arsenal)
Two spanish teams (Villarreal and Barcelona)
Two point nine italian teams (Juventus, Milan, 0.9*Inter who will just have to defeat Ajax).
Could it be more clear...:wink:
 
  • #77
In all fairness though the referee ruined the chelsea barcelona game by sending del horno off in the first leg, it was a stupid challenge but not a red card. Liverpool outplayed benfica but had one of those days when they couldn't score. And as for Rangers, they where lucky to get through the group stages.

Its only between Barcelona, AC Milan and Juventus for me. They are the strongest teams left in it.
 
  • #78
I think that Arsenal have the ace up their sleeve. Much like Liverpool last year, they were the underdogs, and whilst Arsenal's record in Europe is poor, Thierry Henry is on fire.
 
  • #79
Liverpool did not outplay Benfica, they just didn't play (especially in the first leg) and Benfica did what they had to do with two awesome goals.
You don't outplay an opponent and lose 3-0 aggregate, geez.
 
  • #80
Difficult to say - the Premier league has more depth, but Barca are the best domestic team in the world at the moment. the truth is the difference between the big three leagues at the moemnt is miniscule, but I'd say right now La Liga has just taken over the mantle of the bets league int he world form the Premiership (which was the best league in the world last season IMHO).

Metoer - hmm are you seriously giving any credence to the FIFA rankings when they rank a relatively minor team such like the USA as fifth in the world! Spain is among the top inetrnational teams - but England right now is better.
 
  • #81
jcsd said:
they rank a relatively minor team such like the USA as fifth in the world! .

True, that's sort of preposterous. A glitch in the points assignment system, I reckon


I wil remind the draw for the quarterfinals

Villarreal-Inter Milan
Barcelona-Benfica Lisbon
Milan-Lyon
Arsenal London-Juventus Turin
 
  • #82
As fantastic a team as Barcelona are, I am not sure whether they are good enough to beat AC milan or Juventus.

This season though i really don't think La liga has been that good, apart from Barcelona and Real Madrid (who are struggling) they don't have any other top class teams.
 
  • #83
meteor said:
True, that's sort of preposterous. A glitch in the points assignment system, I reckon

The rankings really don't mean anything no-one thinks they are accuarte indicators of who is better. England's squad at the moment is defintely stronger than Spain's. I'd put both teams among the top ten in the world, but at the moment England defintely have the upper hand.


I wil remind the draw for the quarterfinals

Villarreal-Inter Milan
Barcelona-Benfica Lisbon
Milan-Lyon
Arsenal London-Juventus Turin

Yes it's not been a great year in Europe for England's top clubs, but I'm not reading too much into it, the Premier League is still very strong, though so is La Liga and Serie A.
 
  • #84
Andy said:
As fantastic a team as Barcelona are, I am not sure whether they are good enough to beat AC milan or Juventus.

This season though i really don't think La liga has been that good, apart from Barcelona and Real Madrid (who are struggling) they don't have any other top class teams.

Barca are the best club team in the world at the moment - they may not have the best defence, but their attack is unbelivable I'd expect them to beat both those teams. Villareal aren't too shabby either they have Forlan, Sorin and most importantly Riquelme, but it is true that outside the top few teams La Liga suffers in comparison to the Premiership and Serie A.
 
  • #85
It wasn't a great year for England last year, but look at Liverpool :) I think Arsenal have every chance of winning. If only Dennis Bergkamp would fly.

Barca are a great team, but I personally think that Juventus are the best in the world. Juve's midfield would certainly cause more problems than Milan's.

All these leagues have super-teams, where no-one else is going to get a look in. La Liga has Barca, Real Madrid and Valencia, Serie A has Inter, AC Milan and Juve, even the Bundesliga has Bayern Munich and you could also add Shalke '04. The Premiership has Chelsea, Arsenal, Man Utd and Liverpool and (pre and post Souness) Newcastle. That's what makes the premiership seem better, is because it is more open.
 
  • #86
jimmy p said:
I think that Arsenal have the ace up their sleeve. Much like Liverpool last year, they were the underdogs, and whilst Arsenal's record in Europe is poor, Thierry Henry is on fire.

The word in the street is that Arsenal superstar T. Henry has signed for Barca to play here the next season :biggrin:
 
  • #87
Hmm, we all thought it hinged on how well Arsenal did in the Champions League determined where Henry would be. I think he would be wasted in any other league other than the premiership. He is quite unremarkable for the French national team, and they play European football.
 
  • #88
jimmy p said:
I think he would be wasted in any other league other than the premiership.

I disagree. I think his talent is being wasted at Arsenal. Imagine if he could play alongside the likes of Ronaldinho at Barca.
 
  • #89
Arsenal London suffered to beat the modest Villarreal, but now it has reached the final (first time in its history)

So congrats to my briton friends, though they have foiled the possibility of an all-spanish final

I always liked the Champions League Hymn, sohttp://www.wasimmer.de/downloads/champions_league_hymne.mp3 it is. If it sounds like Handel, it's not a coincidence
 
Last edited:
  • #90
For entertainment value - Premier League.

Tho', even with Arsenal in the final and Liverpool's success, I still don't think we've cracked Europe.

Chelsea look unstoppable in the PL but average playing the other European teams.

PL is fast-paced and exciting, but I'm having my doubts over the quality these days.

Still, bring on the summer and we'll see how the likes of Lampard and Gerrard stand up against Ronaldhinio :smile:

LMAO @ Arsenal London :biggrin: :biggrin: :biggrin: :wink:
 
Last edited:

Similar threads

1968 NY Jets vs. 2018 Clemson Tigers football team---Who would win?
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
2K
How to Visually Document Darts League Playoff Progressions and Results?
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
What are the governing bodies for cricket, baseball, and soccer?
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
3K
News The US Digital Service, aka DOGE
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
Exploring Mental Blocks in Mathematics: A Personal Perspective
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
Gorillas should be America's professional football players
  • · Replies 84 ·
3
Replies
84
Views
17K
How to get Hackathon sponsors?
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
1K
Why urn for your favorite sports team?
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
What are the strengths and weaknesses of top teams in world football?
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
I Regression line with zero slope and average as best prediction
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K