Forces on a Block and Friction on a Surface

Homework Statement

A 2.5 kg block is initially at rest on a horizontal surface. A horizontal force
of magnitude 5.8 N and a vertical force
are then applied to the block. The coefficients of friction for the block and surface are μs = 0.43 and μk = 0.24.
(a) Determine the magnitude of the frictional force acting on the block if the magnitude of
is 8.0 N.

Homework Equations

F_friction = Mu*F_normal

The Attempt at a Solution

I really need help with this one, because I don't understand why I get a wrong answer.
Firstly, the net force in the y direction is 0. So F_g = P + F_N.
Then F_N = F_g - P = 2.5 * 9.8 - 8 = 16.5 N
Then since (I believe) the block is stationary, we use μs = 0.43, and so F_f = 0.43 * 16.5 =7.095.
Satisfied with my answer, I put this in the webassign, but it won't accept this as the correct answer. Where did I go wrong?

Attachments

• Farrowitalic.gif
82 bytes · Views: 443
• Parrowitalic.gif
128 bytes · Views: 431
• Parrowitalic.gif
128 bytes · Views: 151
Last edited by a moderator:

TSny
Homework Helper
Gold Member
The formula ##f_s = \mu_s N## gives the maximum possible value for the static friction force. (It would be better to write the formula as ##f_s^{\rm max} = \mu_s N##.)

The static friction force in your situation need not be at its maximum possible value.

Merlin3189
@TSny — so does that mean the WebAssign's looking for an answer that's like say, 7, rather than 7.095?

update: no, what I said above isn't right bc I checked... but how else should I interpret your hint?

haruspex
Homework Helper
Gold Member
2020 Award
It would be better to write the formula as ##f_s^{\rm max} = \mu_s N##.
The form I use is ##|F_s|≤\mu_s|N|##. This emphasises that the direction of the frictional force is not dictated by the equation.

TSny
@haruspex @TSny —Oh so since the maximum frictional force is 7.095N, but the other horizontal force being applied is 5.8 N, would the answer be 5.8 N?

haruspex
Homework Helper
Gold Member
2020 Award
how else should I interpret your hint?
The relevant equation you quoted is incorrect. See either of the forms in posts 2 and 4.
Consider this: if the applied horizontal force is 5.8N and the frictional force in the other direction is 7N, what will happen to the block?

haruspex
Homework Helper
Gold Member
2020 Award
@haruspex @TSny —Oh so since the maximum frictional force is 7.095N, but the other horizontal force being applied is 5.8 N, would the answer be 5.8 N?
Yes.

@haruspex @TSny — thank you! Can I ask another question though?

(c) Determine the magnitude of the frictional force acting on the block if the magnitude of
is 12.0 N.

So now that yields a maximum friction of 0.43*(2.5*9.8 - 12) = 5.375 N, which is less than the horizontal force F=5.8N. Then it's going to move right off the bat, right? How should I answer this?

Attachments

• Parrowitalic.gif
128 bytes · Views: 105
haruspex